Showing posts with label accuracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label accuracy. Show all posts

Tuesday, 14 November 2017

Re-enactment and HA: Do we have a problem?

I was a bit hesitant to write this post for numerous reasons, mainly because a lot of people will dislike me a lot for it. The other reasons include the danger of sounding ungrateful, and the other is the fall-out that comes with holding a mirror up to people who think they know their own reflection but don't. Before I begin I would like to say that, as with most things in life, this is entirely my opinion (which I'm entitled to) from my experiences, and won't necessarily be shared by all.

No one wants to be the bad guy, and I've spent all of my life trying to be liked, but perhaps it's time to accept that I have opinions that sometimes aren't popular ones, and will most definitely offend someone out there. If you are a serious re-enactor and like it that way, then I strongly advise you not to read on. This post will possibly provide some re-enactor gossip fodder at the next event that you can discuss around your historically accurate stove. Bitch away, my friends, God knows you love to.

According to the dictionary re-enacting is to "act out a past event", whether this be one of the many thousands of battles that have happened in human history, or simply going about the day to day routine of a maid, or a lady. It all sounds rather tame, but the world of re-enactment has a long, arduous, and controversial history. The majority of the population, perhaps correctly, think that this hobby is just dressing up, and you know sometimes it is, but for the majority of people out there it is to experience history in a completely unique way. How better else can we understand something than by experiencing it ourselves? The knowledge we gain helps us become better historians, and hence helps the historical education of the next generation. All is good.

Re-enactment is more than just a passing hobby for a lot of people, it's a passion, but as with any passion sometimes it runs away with itself. This is where the problem starts. In my mind, and the mind of the majority of the human population, a hobby is something you do for fun, whether that be on your own or in a group, hence re-enactment is supposed to be fun. So why have my last 2 experiences been short of that mark?

Granted, I'm not a part of a re-enactment group or society, and after my most recent experience I don't intend to be, but it was something I was interested in. At events the groups were friendly, and loved to talk and share their knowledge and experience. Little did I know that they're only like that to the general public. It becomes an entirely different matter when you try to penetrate this world of historical accuracy.

I've never been one for essays, or beating around the bush (thanks, Scotland!) so the point of this entire post is to point the accusatory finger at the re-enactment community and call you out.  Call you out on what? Call you out on being snobs.  That's right, you heard me, snobs. It might sound harsh, and I can hear the disgruntlement all the way from here, but as an outsider who has attempted to be a part of the magic, I judge how I find. Your friendliness is kept for the general public, the people who have been disadvantaged by a narrow education system, but when someone tries to join in at your event, that warm welcome and conversation are gone.

Now, it's time to say here that I've only attended 3 events, all of which are practically the 19th Century, so perhaps the snobbery is confined to this century, who knows, but honestly, I doubt it. The rules of re-enactment are relatively strict, and the kit is expensive the higher you go up the class ladder. Since you are proper re-enactors, and not just people who dress up, everything has to be authentic, or as close to it as possible.  No polyester.....ever!!! No cotton in the 12th century, no metal eyelets in the 18th, no back-lacing kirtle on a peasant! The list goes on, and no doubt expands the sexes, but I'm not a man so I don't know. Some of it I agree with, you are meant to be living history, so you probably should make a good stab at being accurate, but at what cost? is everyone made of money? Does the Queen really have to have real silk, when a good quality poly could probably look as good, and not break the bank? Perhaps this is just me trying to make up reasons why I don't have to buy 100% silk for my next event gown, but the judgment I've seen people get when they turn up in poly is utterly disgusting.

Let's circle around to events for the "general public" or events where anyone who's interested can join in. Most specifically balls. I've already posted about the ones I went to, so there's no secret about who attends and who organises, and if this gets me on the blacklist then......whoops. These balls are advertised as anyone can come, not necessarily in period costume, but in evening wear. Let's face it, anyone who goes is at least going to make the minimal amount of effort at the time period. And here lies the problem.

The re-enactors are rubbing shoulders with the wannabe Joe publics. The people who have spent hundreds if not thousands on their gowns and evening attire are dancing dances they know rather well with amateurs in silk poly who don't know their left from their right. These events are meant to be fun, but like when a private school has to host classes for their poorer public school neighbour, there is some amount of judgment and snobbery. Is it justified? Not in hell.

These events aren't re-enactors only, and perhaps the HA attendees should remember this. Surely the point is to encourage people into historical accuracy? to make them want to join their local dance group, or re-enactment society so they can learn and join in? To do this you need to make them feel welcome, which I've not once felt at either events I've attended this year. I was contemplating joining a re-enactment society.....I'm not now. At the first event I attended I didn't notice this atmosphere, and I had so much fun, however by the second and third it was there, the elephant in the room that only I could see. By the third I thought I was imagining things, until a new friend of mine pointed it out to me.

There are two main sources of this icy civility. One, which I've never personally experienced, is connected to costumes and attire, which I have mentioned above. Silk is expensive, dependent on quality and type, and not many people can, or want, to fork out the money, especially for something they may only be wearing once or twice. What's a cheap alternative? Polyester! Is it historically accurate? No. Does a good quality one look very similar to the real deal? Yes. So what's the issue? Apparently a big one. Sewing machines weren't widely used until the 1840s, yet your 1820s gown was machine sewn? Cue the silent gasps and not so silent judgment. You're using a glue gun to attach your flowers? How dare you! I'm sure the list goes on. What is the big deal here? These events aren't HA, so why the judgment? Why shouldn't people use modern technques for their costumes to a non-HA event? I am 95% confident that it a pre-sewing machine woman were to appear in the 21st century and be told that someone had made their gown by hand she would give them a strange look. Why go through the pain, hassle, and frustration of sewing a dress by hand just because it's from a period when they weren't used? Of course, it's a different story if hand sewing is voluntary, but I digress. These balls and events that are open invitations shouldn't have this level of costume snobbery. Don't invite the general public if you want these events to be historically accurate, there's my advice you didn't ask for,

The second source of this elitism comes from the dances themselves. Personally, the only dancing I did was modern in a group of girls my age, and ceilidh because I'm Scottish. I love ceilidh dancing, and so does the majority of Britain, and the reason it's so popular is because in Scotland we incite everyone to join in, no matter their experience or ability. If someone makes a mistake (even Scottish people, we're not perfect) we laugh it off and carry on, we do not frown, glare, or tell anyone off. f people aren't taking it seriously then they're doing it correctly! The more giggles, snorts, and sniggers of laughter the better. But not in England, not in proper historical dances, oh no, one must not laugh at their mistakes, or go the wrong way and giggle away the momentary embarrassment, God forbid. This particular point I have experienced. I get it, learning regency and Victorian dances are some people's hobby, and that's fine, but it doesn't give you a right to act elitist when you're in a workshop with beginners. It's an event for the public, not a show. The dances are complicated, and unlike you, or our historical counterparts, we aren't taught by a trained teacher how to do the steps. Our French is a bit rusty, possibly non-existent, and some people just aren't dancing-inclined, whatever the reason sometimes it takes a while to learn the steps and put the dance together. Going the wrong way, offering the wrong hand, or giggling at some of the sheer humorous hops and moves, is how a beginner acts. Telling them off, glaring at them, or anything else that indicates disapproval, is not only mean, it's just plain rude. Attending dance classes doesn't give you the right to dictate how others behave or act during the practice, or the event itself.

We'll call the next paragraph a half source of snobbery, and one that's very common. This point may become pretty convoluted because I can be guilty of doing this myself. Everyone likes a good costume drama. BBC, ITV, all of the American production companies, they're throwing them out like they're on a conveyor belt, all of varying quality. I did a post many years ago on the sheer inaccuracy of Reign, but that show was never conveyed as historically accurate so half stepped down in my annoyance. There are other shows that are labelled as historically accurate, like The White Queen on BBC, most recently The White Princess by Starz, Versailles, Harlots, Outlander, the Jane Austen novel adaptations, and so on. These all have varying degrees of accuracy. I'm not a clothing historian, I don't know when a front laced gown changed to a back lacing one and so forth, but if i ever forget then Frock Flicks is always there to remind me.

I have a love hate relationship with this website. In short this site tears apart costumes in costume dramas labelled as historically accurate, or set in a historic time period. I don't care if they think it's an analysis, or something else, they literally tear everything apart. Why does this bother me? They don't seem to understand that the film and TV industry doesn't have tons of money to throw at the wardrobe department. They don't seem to understand that the costume designers don't get to have the final say in what the actors wear. No doubt there are many more things they don't understand, but I'm not a part of that industry, and I only have the word of interviews from the designers, or friends who are in the industry, to inform me. So what if they used poly silk? So what if the dresses are back laced if they should be front laced? So what if she doesn't have a hat on? These shows aren't produced for historically accuracy, they're produced for plot, the acting, the story, the costumes are an added extra. The modern world is very different to the past ones, and if you make everything completely HA then you're in danger of losing something that's very important; viewer empathy. If they can relate to the hero or heroine, if they look slightly modern, then it's easier for the viewer to cheer them on, or relate to them. Yes, women, especially married ones, never wore their hair down, but recently they all do. Who friggin cares? Sometimes a half updo is nicer than greasy looking centre-parted hair slicked to the sides of your head. I am not so elitist that I can't admire a good costume, or nice hair, despite its historic innacuracy.

A more minor snag is the way people in the community bitch about some gender roles in recent years. The one that comes to mind is the female doctor in Versailles. Yes, I know women weren't doctors, but it's fiction!! It is a made-up story, based in a real-life setting. It's called imagination, and God knows we all need some in our lives! As a writer I'm guilty of making my characters do inaccurate things, because sometimes historical etiquette gets in the way of plot development. If a woman can't go out unaccompanied then how is she to meet that one person that has vital information for her? If a man isn't allowed to speak to a woman he hasn't been introduced to, then how many pages am I going to have to add by describing the introduction method? If a man is encouraged not to speak to a woman he only met at a ball, then how are the two leads supposed to fall in love? Writing historical fiction is hard enough as it is, cut us some slack here or you'll have nothing to read!

This post services as a rant, as well as pointing out a serious problem with a community. Re-enacment is about experiencing history, so why does it matter so much how we do it? Why can't we use subtle modern methods to bring the past to life for those who are interested? Why can't someone who doesn't know any historic dances attend a ball and not be judged or scolded? Events should make everyone feel welcome, no matter how involved in the community they are. If you continue to act high and mighty you may end up putting re-enactment on the dying hobby list as sewing once was. History is interesting, but to really engage people it has to be relatable and accessible to them as individuals or else it holds no draw.

I will strongly state again that this is just my opinion as an observer and occasional participant in these events, and won't necessarily be found everywhere. Hopefully you'll have more luck than my friend and I.

Thursday, 9 November 2017

A natural form era corset

I hate corsets. Have I said that enough on this blog? I absolutely hate making them, and they never give me the shape I want. To be fair I've only ever made about 5, this being my 5th, so I don't know what I expect. My 4th was good, it was the Victoria kit by SewCurvy, and it was a dream. Unfortunately because that had gone so well I thought I was a friggin expert and went straight onto the advanced pattern, courtesy of Ageless patterns.


The above is the pattern I used. It's Ageless Patterns 1876 corset for Cuirass bodices. I thought because the beginner's kit had gone together so easily I was a big girl and could go straight for the HA ones. What was even better was that this pattern came in multiple different sizes, so there was no need to scale it up myself, which at this point I had never done.

Oh my, how wrong I was. I had done gussets before for my first bustle era ensemble foundations, and realised there were as many ways to put them in as there were ice-cream flavours in existence. This pattern offered yet a new way, which didn't work for me.

I began as any sensible costumer, by making a mock-up. The instructions were...well....sparse, but that didn't stop me. I could have sworn I took pictures of the mock-up stage, but my laptop died, as did most of the pics that weren't on Dropbox, so I can't find them/don't have them. All I can say is that it was roomy. I could have fit a watermelon or two in the bust, as well as the girls.

The bust has two gores, and there is one hip gusset at the front, and another at the back. I reduced both hip gussets, and took one of the bust ones out altogether, instead widening the front most one. Why did I do this? The placement of the second one ended up being nearly under my armpit, and I couldn't understand what exactly it was doing. My girls are quite small for my size, and that gusset was doing nothing. I always have problems with the bust area in patterns, so this was no surprise, but I couldn't be bothered faffing around with so many gores.

Also, it took me days to figure out how to insert them. All of the gores I've ever inserted have been in a slit in the fabric, but these are all between seams. It's hard to explain this pattern without a picture, but one panel would be smooth, and then the other would have a straight step towards the pattern piece where the bottom of the gusset was supposed to go. Yet the gussets weren't flat at the bottom themselves. How the hell you were supposed to get them in is still kind of beyond me.. The very talented owner of Before the Automobile blog made a much more successful corset than mine from the same pattern and managed it fine.

After the alterations it fit well, and it even gave me hip definition, (thank you hip gores).

The materials I decided to use for this were so stupid I don't know how I ever thought it was a good idea. This project was ambitious from start to finish, and my inflated ego about corsets didn't help. Arrogance doesn't make life better, kids. I was enamoured of the lovely silk covered silk corsets from costumers like Izabela of Prior Attire, and I wanted one of my own. My ego wasn't completely out of control because I knew I'd make a mistake at some point and so didn't want to fork out the money for silk. I went for poly satin. I know, I can hear the disapproving shakes of your heads from here.

I knew how to make a silk covered corset from the blogs I'd read on the subject, and the FB posts I'd seen. I still used coutil, trusty old coutil, and kind of flatlined the satin with the coutil, and treated them as one layer. That was where the problems started. The satin moved about like buggery, and there was already ripples in the pieces before I sewed them together. That's satin for you, no matter poly or silk.

The busk I used for this was true to pattern. The fabled spoon busk that started to become more frequently used in this period. It's wider at the bottom, and from what I understand is meant to give some more tummy control, which Lord knows I need in buckets. It goes in like any other busk. I was still proud.

I managed to wrangle in all the gussets, and put the eyelets in the back so I could check the fit. And shockingly enough it was still too big.
The office manager sleeping on the job

I had made some minor alterations after the second and final mock-up, mostly because the one-gusset was a little too snug in its support of the girls, but it wasn't anything major enough to fiddle with the fit everywhere. I must've forgotten to reduce something here or there. The fit illuminated the problems of the dreaded wrinkling. I suppose it was inevitable really considering my beginner status as a corset maker, but it's still annoying. If I was to do it again, which I won't be doing in a hurry, I would iron in fusible interfacing to the satin before attaching it to the coutil.

And it was way too long at the front, like not going to be able to sit down long. I had known that in the mock-ups, but had been too afraid to do anything with the length after my disastrous corset from last year that was too short. It was easily fixed, as was the fit.

Boning channels were sewn, based on the pattern on the original, but with a few alterations.

I was kind of hoping the wrinkling would go away when the bones went in, but only some of it did.

As the colour was purple, I, of course, had to bind it with black poly satin bias binding to complete the look. Then it was time for the final fitting.
Just about parallel lacing, potentially not so much, but look at those hip gussets!
Ugh, those wrinkles on the bust gussets!!

The wrinkles prevailed, but looking at it after a month or two makes it seem a little better, and not bad considering it was my first time working with poly satin. I do like the shape of this corset, especially giving my hips room to move.

There is another thing I've noticed in hindsight. I showed the finished pics to my seamstress friend in disgust and shame, and she asked me if I was sure it went up high enough at the bust. Looking at it now it does seem a bit on the low side, but I'm not spilling out. From what I can tell from the one Before the Automobile did hers curves up at the sides, so if I ever try this pattern again I might alter it to do the same, because I do look like I'm in danger of some spillage. I think the whole thing needs lengthened from the waist up by an inch or two because the bottom of those bust gussets are nearly at my waist!

Another lesson in corsetry.

Wednesday, 1 February 2017

Sewing Scot: HSM 2017 Challenge

I just made it in time with my HSM challenge for January.  I honestly don't know what took me so long, it is the most simple thing to make.  For those of you who don't know, one of my sewing aims of this year was to participate in at least one of the HSM challenges.  My post recording which ones currently stands at 6.  Well, one down, 5 to go.

The challenge was firsts and lasts, so something that would be first or last in an ensemble. Because I didn't particularly like my first regency chemise, I made a second one.  The back was a little high on my first one (it didn't show, but in case I ever want to make a gown with a low back), so I thought to make another one, this time lengthening the shoulder strap.  This did not turn out how I planned or imagined.  I think I probably extended the strap in the wrong place.  Instead of lengthening in the back like it was supposed to, the front just ended up being really, really low.

One, very stupid and avoidable mistake, is that I forgot to put an opening anywhere, and when then i snipped the bias binding around the neckline to make one, I realised it was the centre back I'd placed it.  Honestly, you lose concentration for a second.  It's hard to discern which is front and back when everything is white.

The Challenge: January 2017 - Firsts and Lasts
The Item: Regency chemise
Material:  100% Cotton Lawn
Pattern: Laughing Moon #115
Year: ~(1800-1810), although possibly give or take a few years on either bound.
Notions:  green satin ribbon for the neckline, 100% cotton bias binding for the arm holes and neckline.
How historically accurate is it?  That's a good question.  The pattern is pretty accurate, according to the booklet that comes with it.  As for the cotton lawn, I've been puzzling over this as I'm not overly familiar with regency undergarments.  I have been under the impression that linen was more widely used in this period for undergarments, but that cotton was also used....not entirely sure.  I'm going to say 80% (95% Confidence interval: 60-90%), sorry if you're not a statistician, but I can't give an estimate without one.
Hours to complete:  3-4 hours
First worn:  Regency Ball, Edinburgh, March 2017 (so not yet).
Total cost: ~£20, possibly less.  Cotton lawn was from my current supply, at roughly £8 p/m, and roughly 2m used for this, that's £16.  Ribbon was roughly £2, and let's just say the same for the bias binding.  
As so completes my first HSM challenge!

Thursday, 5 January 2017

Sewing Scot: Historical sew monthly 2017 challenges

One of my 2017 sewing goals was to complete at least one of the sew monthly challenges set by the dreamstress.  After looking through this year's challenges I'd like to compete in more than one, and because life changes so quickly, and my memory is so awful, I'd like to have a blog post that I can look back at, and maybe edit if need be.

1. "January: Firsts & Lasts – Create either the first item in a new ensemble, or one last piece to put the final fillip on an outfit."

Luckily for me I'm in the midst of an undergarment blitz, hence the planned 2nd evening 1870s chemise and second regency chemise fit perfectly into this.

2. "May: Literature – The written word has commemorated and immortalised fashions for centuries, from the ‘gleaming’ clothes that Trojans wore before the war, to Desdemona’s handkerchief, ‘spotted with strawberries’, to Meg in Belle Moffat’s borrowed ballgown, and Anne’s longed for puffed sleeves. In this challenge make something inspired by literature: whether you recreate a garment or accessory mentioned in a book, poem or play, or dress your favourite historical literary character as you imagine them."

My plans for a regency Spencer would fit greatly into a Jane Austen setting.

3. "June: Metallics – make something in silver, gold, bronze, and copper, whether it be an actual metal, cloth of gold or silver, or lamé"

This was a strange one.  For some reason I started thinking about the mesh caul pattern I have buried away in the growing pile of unused patterns.  It's been there for years, I can't even remember how long, it might be one of the first costuming patterns I got.  Weirdly over Christmas and New Year I started thinking about the pattern and had the sudden urge to start work on it and ordered the necessary supplies, which I'm currently waiting to arrive.  The pattern calls for gold braid, so hopefully this fits into this challenge?

4. "July: Fashion Plate – Make an outfit inspired by a fashion plate, whether it is a direct replica, or a more toned down version that fits the resources and lifestyle of the character you are portraying. If you want to stick to a period prior to the 17th century advent of fashion plates, either re-interpret a Victorian ‘historical’ fashion illustration as period accurate, or use an image from your period that depicts and idealised and aspirational fashion."

To be honest for both victorian ball gowns I made I was heavily inspired by fashion plates, more so this time than the 1860s one where I used an extant example.  There are so many fashion plates filled with things I want to make, so this challenge is a perfect excuse.

5.  "September: Seen Onscreen – Be inspired by period fashions as shown onscreen (film or TV), and recreate your favourite historical costume as a historically accurate period piece."

As costumers we always watch period dramas and films and become irritated by lack of historical accuracy.  This challenge offers such a wide breadth of options it'll be interesting to see if one comes to mind.  Perhaps a Burgundian for the White Queen (where the infamous zips were pointed out by the hawk-eyes viewer), or Braveheart (sorry Hollywood, polyester crushed velvet didn't exist in the 13th century).  My first thought was, of course, to Reign, but I'd rather avoid having to make appropriate undergarments that will include stays.  We'll have to see...

6. "October: Out of Your Comfort Zone – Create a garment from a time period you haven’t done before, or that uses a new skill or technique that you’ve never tried before."

This would probably involve either the 11/12th century project I've been postponing for a few years now, or maybe something different.  Considering everything I've made is either Victorian or Regency there's a lot of scope to slip out of my comfort zone.

If I get all of these done I'll consider myself winning at 2017.  However, I'll be happy with completing one or two considering this is my first try.

All posts will be of required format;
The Challenge:
Material:
Pattern: 
Year: 
Notions:
How historically accurate is it?
Hours to complete:
First worn:
Total cost:
I'm looking forward to see what comes from this as I've heard about it for at least 2 years now, and it'll be interesting to see what others make for them as well.