Showing posts with label costuming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label costuming. Show all posts

Sunday, 3 March 2019

Historically inspired NOT historically accurate

As you've probably noticed 2018 was the year of railing against the historically accurate community. Perhaps railing isn't the word, but I was growing increasingly frustrated with the snobbery I was experiencing at events, and at how unsatisfied I was if something I made wasn't as HA as possible.

HA caused me nothing but misery, and also a considerable sum of money. I was inspired to write this post because I read an open letter by another blogger to "newbies" to the historical costuming scene. The longer I roam in these cyber circles the more I realise that historical costuming is actually a subset of the broader costuming hobby.

For instance, you have cosplayers who make costumes based on characters in literature, manga, tv series, and films. Then you have general costumers who dabble in cosplay, fantasy, and also historical pieces. The historical costuming community is just one group under the general umbrella. There's no doubt loads more (Furry comes to mind) that I don't know about.

I'm only talking about the historical community because that's the one I've been more exposed to, and let's just say I'm far from impressed. I'll admit, I skim read the open letter despite not being a newbie, but I have a short attention span at the best of times. The general message I got from the skim read was research, research some more, and then maybe you'll be accepted....I'm kidding about the last part but the gist was the more you research the more accurate your creations will be. This is true, but how many iterations is that going to take you? How many events are you going to have to get sneered at to finally get to an "acceptable" level of accuracy.

I'll say at this point I'm biased against the HA community solely because I can't stand snobbery. Sorry, but just because you had the time and willpower to sew that 18th century gown doesn't mean you can act high and mighty.

Historical costuming is great, all hobbies that keep people engaged are great, but the fact there seems to be eligibility criteria for practising it is baffling to me. I think these stringent rules will put people off.

I read an article not so long ago, the source escapes me, that pointed out the deficit of young people in the reenactment community, and the suppliers of historically accurate costume. Hmmmmm, I wonder why....

It's all well and good for the handful of HA bloggers to write kind, encouraging open letters, but that's going to be about as helpful as a chocolate fire guard if newbies are showing up to events and being snubbed or sneered at by the veteran reenactors. In some cases, ignored completely.

I find the HA scene to be very much like high school where everyone was in their separate camps and no one dared venture outside of those groups for fear of retribution. I also felt that somehow everyone already knew each other, and if you weren't already established in that group then there was no way of getting in. It's like the entire community is a VIP club and it's full so no one else is getting in.

Granted, I haven't been to an event in some time, but that's because the ones I did start going to when I was a newbie weren't welcoming, so why bother? Perhaps other newbies had a better time than me, perhaps they managed to get past the velvet ropes, but as an introvert with social anxiety I found the clique-ish atmosphere unbearable and frankly quite frustrating since it had taken courage to attend the event anyway.

I suppose what I'm trying to say in my ranting way is that HA isn't everything. Creativity shouldn't have rules, that's why I like it over my science day job. You should be able to use that polyester to make that gown because silk is too expensive, you should be able to use that kind of seam even if it wasn't used at that time, and you should be able to wear a modern corset because it's all you can afford, because a modern corset is better than no corset at all. You should be able to do all of these things without being judged.

In light of the last year and my general experience I've discovered a new sewing mantra that the HA rejects like myself can use. Historically inspired. Inspired by historical gowns and clothes but made using modern techniques and materials. This doesn't have to mean they look cheap, or were any easier to put together, sewing isn't easy no matter what. It just means machine sewn regency gowns, polyester 1860s gowns, and bum pads stuffed with polyfill.

Don't be afraid to create! Despite these kind letters from the occasional blogger, events tend to be ruled by the firm HA crowd. However, I do encourage independent thought, so attend as many events as you wish because my experience won't be yours, and if you do find a nice group then drop a comment so I can join.

Thursday, 28 February 2019

Robe a la francaise a.k.a Oh God, no.

I wouldn't really be a proper costumer if I didn't at least try to make a francaise, would I? But can you believe it's not something I've ever had on my bucket list, solely because it look so time consuming. Yet, somehow, here we are.
ca. 1750s

I'm attending an event in 2020 where a francaise is the order of the day (an optional one but considering it's based on the 18th century French court I'd be mad to go without a francaise). I know what you're thinking - 2020? It only just turned 2019! And you'd be right, but I'm a planner, and since I've never made a francaise before I'd like to get some research in now.

Thankfully for me, the francaise is so iconic that tons of people have tried it before (unlike my 17th century court gown). American Duchess (AD) even have detailed instructions in their book! I am tempted to cave in and buy a commercial pattern, but why go down the easy route when I have an abundance of costuming books up the stairs all with patterns and details about the francaise?

As you know if you've been following me for a while, I'm a no-frills sort of costumer. Minimal trim kind of stuff, which is the complete opposite of the 18th century, especially the francaise where trim is mandatory, the more the better. I don't mind trim, honestly I don't, it's just that whenever I find myself designing costumes they don't have much. Even my 18th century Pierrot ( which almost went completely untrimmed) only has trim around the neckline and cuffs, and the silk petticoat has none at all! The largest amount of trim I've ever done were the 3 rows of pleating and 6 bows I had to put on my natural form era gown.

Don't get me wrong, my francaise will be trimmed....the silk version anyway. But this is more of an inspiration post. What are the garments I use to get ideas onto paper?  My francaise will be mid-century, so before the big hair of the 1770s. I'm thinking about 1750s-1760s, but of course the francaise doesn't go through that many changes in the entire century, let alone these 20 years, so it might be difficult to pinpoint an extant garment to a precise year. Paintings are better.

The only thing different between earlier gowns and later ones is the size of the pleats at the back. They tend to be wider earlier in the century. Can't say I've noticed.

Madame de Pompadour was my first person of interest during my research because it was she who was dominant during these decades, despite not being the official Maitresse en titre (she retired in 1750 from that role and just became the King's close friend).




The first is by far the most famous portrait of her painted by Francois Bouchet about 1750. In fact I think all of the above are painted by him during her lifetime. Obviously I love the colour of the first one, but just the thought of all that floof makes me sad.

Then I moved onto extant garments. Now, I don't know about you, but most reproduction francaise by costumers are done in silk taffeta which tends to be one colour. Conversely, most, if not all, extant francaises are silk brocade. To add another layer onto this mess most of the paintings from the era also have the gowns as one or two solid colour silk. Obviously silk is still expensive, and after finding out you need at least 10m for one I fell out with silk taffeta for a little while. Let's just say that any silk francaise you make will be an investment.

The robe a la francaise can be fastened 2 ways. The first is the old stomacher and pins method, which was very, very common. The other is the so-called compere front, which usually attached the stomacher to the sides of the gown and buttoned up down the centre front. A lot of the stomacher's I noticed, both in portraits and extant garments, were trimmed up the wazoo, and I'm just not a fan.
circa 1760s, currently held in the Bath Fashion museum
circa 1760s, Museum of Fine Arts Boston

circa 1740s
circa 1760s

You see I'm more of an embroidery kind of gal. Ironic since embroidery actually takes longer than normal 18th century stomacher trim, but I just prefer it. And embroidered stomachers were also worn with the robe a la francaise.

ca. 1775


Stomacher ca. 1730-1750, VA museum

All in all designing the francaise itself was actually one of the easiest parts of this idea. On the other hand, we had the foundation garments. WTF is up with the 18th century and all of these weird cushions, cages, panniers, and rumps? Just calm the f**k down.

At least in the 19th century its the crinoline, then bustle, then 2nd bustle, there's one silhouette for each, and usually one or two variations on the same undergarment. God forbid the 18th century is the same.

We have pocket hoops, court panniers, normal panniers, square panniers, and all give a slightly different silhouette. I've spent more time researching these garments than I did the friggin francaise itself!!


These are my current favourite, but I have the intentions of shortening it a bit. There is a name for it, I think it's a short hoop (at least that's what they call it in POF 5). I came to this conclusion after reading somewhere that pocket hoops tend to be a bit unstable, but I;m not sure if perhaps tying them together would alleviate that problem. Never having made or worn them I can't say either way, but I have plans to make them as well (I've got an abundance of books with a pattern in it).

The square/rectangular panniers I'm talking about I think are usually worn with court gowns, like whatever is underneath the gown below.
Court gown ca. 1750, The Met
ca. 1759
If I thought I had the skills I'd want to make these minimalist ones.

POF 5 has 2 patterns for a pannier similar to this, but from a brief skim it looked quite fiddly, so I think I'll stick to the short hoop for now.

I am making pocket hoops, but I'm unsure if they're as large as I'd like, especially the ones below. I know there is a costumer recently who's made slightly bigger ones and they look perfect, but again stability issues. Don't get me wrong, I'm not making a court pannier size, but I just feel the pocket hoops are a little too small and flimsy for me.

Perhaps it's just the mannequin. I did notice with my prototype pair that the size of my hips did make them stick out more, but it's more the stability issues that concern me.

I've found recently that I actually prefer making undergarments. I know that's a strange thing to enjoy because a lot of people find it tedious and just want to get onto the actual gown, but with gowns come trim. I find undergarments fascinating, and despite the sheer number of them in the 18th century, I really enjoy finding the differences between them, and when they would've been worn.

So, that's it for my inspiration post, but don't expect a completed francaise this year (2019). I still intend to do my 1890s gown first, then if my obsession for the francaise lingers then I'll attempt one in cotton because can you believe, my money tree still hasn't grown.

Sunday, 1 July 2018

An 18th century Robe en Chemise

Very few garments have ever been so scandalous as the chemise a la reine, Gaulle, or robe en chemise, whichever you prefer. I've gone into the history of the robe en chemise in another post, so I won't repeat myself here.

We're all here because I wanted one. Not the white, high-maintenance ones that are extant, or in the paintings, although that was tempting. Somehow, mine is made from printed floral cotton.

As I've said in other posts, in 2018 I am anti-HA. There is no evidence that chemise a la reine's were made of printed fabric, white and other plain colours, yes, but not prints. Obviously, absence of evidence doesn't necessarily mean they didn't exist. After all, there are only about 2 or 3 chemises still extant. Regardless, when I saw the fabric I just thought it would make a nice robe en chemise.

It's cotton lawn, I didn't feel like voile which is common for chemises, but this fabric was a bitch to work with. For a lawn it was so so thin! Not sheer, just really soft, floppy and frayed so easily, worse than the lawns I usually work with. It had a very loose weave, if you know what I mean. I can forgive its many sins though because it's so pretty.

It's worn with a chemise, my 1780s stays, a small bustle pad originally intended for an 1870s ensemble, my hybrid petticoat, American Duchess Pemberley shoes (discontinued), and a cute little regency beret ( a little later than this gown but it was too hot for my 1780s half wig).





















Let's get undressed!!

Off with the sash
From the front it could quite easily be a 1790s round gown, shame I did the fitted back...
You can barely see, but there are two cotton tapes for ties at the neckline, and underbust
The lining is laced up for a snug fit....perhaps too snug
My experimental 18th century petticoat, lined with cotton organdie
The bustle pad made for the 1870s, but fits with 1780s.

The making of.......

There was a case of a missing pattern during this project. I lengthened the pattern I used for my regency ensemble and cut out the lining. I had about 3 or 4 projects on the go by this time (June was a hell of a month) so I'd be jumping from one thing to the other. I made quite a few alterations to the lining, despite mock-ups, and left it for a few days. When I came to cut out the lawn I couldn't find that pattern anywhere. My sewing room is in a bad state, I'm not going to lie, but I turned that place upside down looking for these pattern pieces and couldn't find them anywhere. So this means I'll find them in September, not so handy now.

I had to just use the lining, which was already constructed, to try and cut out the fabric. This was not fun and so unbelievably frustrating. It also prompted me to try a different construction method; mounting the fashion fabric to the lining. I assumed because of my patternless-ness the pieces wouldn't match up exactly, so I folded in the seam allowance and mounted them to the lining, which hid any mistakes.

The front lining is laced up with...that's right, metal grommets!! #antiHAcrew

Things got worse when it came to the front. Somehow my fashion fabric shoulder straps were smaller than the lining ones. I ended up having to do them again and make them wider.

The next problem was the casings for the drawstrings. The neckline was fine, although I realised that using bias binding was a bit too stiff, so changed to twill tape afterwards. I ensured that the casing for the waist was put on straight, and hand sewed it on with tiny stitches. During the fitting stage I found that it wasn't straight at all and was messing with the front panel. I'm still not quite sure what happened, but after that I just decided to put a casing at the under bust, and leave the waist. I might go back and put one on, but since I'll always be wearing a belt with it I just couldn't see the point in the drawstring.

There was a lot of hand sewing of the front panel, in fact there was a lot of hand sewing on this entire project!
That's just string so I got the placement of the casings right after the first disaster
Another source of problems came from the hem. You can see in the picture above that the front it shorter than the back. This is because I had measured the back to go over a false rump, which is now in the bin. The rump was more of an experiment. I didn't want to use my 1780s false rump because I think they look a bit too big for the robe en chemise, so I tested my skills and made one based on an extant. This also turned out to be too big, but I knew I needed something for my derriere.

I haven't published it on the blog yet, but I was working on an 1870s natural form gown at the beginning of the year, which remains a UFO for now, and I made a small bustle pillow. I ended up not needing it for the natural form because it looked too big for that, and it lay abandoned in a corner for months. When I was trying on the robe en chemise I remembered this little bustle, made out of an old pillow case and stuffed with the scraps from the sewing room bin. It was the perfect amount of volume, especially under my experimental 18th century petticoat.

Back to the hem. I had roughly 2.5" difference between the front panel and the back skirt panel. To be honest the front was too short for my liking, and the back was the perfect length, but how to fix it? I know I complained about this fabric being a bitch to work with, but I'm so glad I chose it. I'm finding, ever since working with patterned fabrics, that they're really quite forgiving. They're so busy that any mistakes kind of just disappear, as proven by my Pierrot.

I cut out a strip of the lawn (which I still had about 1m leftover) and sewed it to the bottom of the front panel. Sorted. I thought it would be awful and that the seam would be really obvious, but it's not that bad, in my opinion. Just don't look that closely.

God forbid this project went smoothly, this is what happens when you don't pattern or mock-up correctly. I'm glad I got this fabric on sale. I designed the front of this gown a bit strangely in that the arm scye at the front had quite a sharp angle where the strap met the front panel. I attempted to fix this with the strap, but it didn't work. I attached the sleeves whilst the dress was on an armless mannequin, and when I put it on, the sleeves were pulling from the front. I'd also had to put a few pleats in the sleeves to fit them in.
Look at those peaks!! Ugh! But let's look on the bright side, the rest of the sleeve fit perfectly over my arms, and I mean perfect. I patterned these from the American Duchess book, in the section on the round gown from the 1790s. I wish I'd done this with my Pierrot.

My solution was to unpick the top of the arm scye, at the shoulder, and kind of feed the sleeve further into the arm scye. I think the head of the sleeve is to steep, I had this problem with the Pierrot sleeves as well. I'm actually glad I hand sewed these in because the stitching was a lot easier to unravel than if it had been done on machine.

I cut them to the right length, they're a bit long for my liking in the above picture, and then I was done.

The belt is just a piece of brown velvet ribbon that I originally intended to go with my Pierrot. The sash I made for this was from a remnant I had of the blue silk taffeta I used to make my 1780s petticoat. I even bought a vintage buckle and everything, but when I put it on with the chemise it just didn't go, and if I thought that, the person who needs fashion plates to chose colours, then you can imagine how bad it must have been. The ribbon was thin, and because the floral pattern was brown, i think the brown of the velvet just went better.

I would have liked a longer tail, hence why I made the taffeta sash quite long, but I wasn't going to buy more velvet ribbon just for that. I think the bustle pad just gives the backside that extra volume that it needed without it being too big.

Friday, 22 June 2018

What to do about the 1790s?

I'm knee deep in the latter quarter of the 18th century for events in July. But what happens when you get to the 1790s? Apparently, anything you like.

I'm exaggerating, but it was a strange time, both in life as well as in fashion, and one is a reflection of the other.

The short version is that French society finally became sick of the vast inequalities between the aristocracy and themselves and overthrew the monarchy in what is known as the French Revolution. This happened circa 1793. Before this, fitted gowns reigned supreme, big bums, back pleats, and polonaise'd skirts. We get to 1793 and everything changes.

By this point in history Paris firmly led the way in European fashion. With the revolution there was a new status quo, and fashion began to reflect this. There was a growing interest in ancient civilisations, Rome and Greece, the delicate drapery, the abundance of curly hair flying every which way. By 1793 waistlines were beginning to rise above the natural position. This was a gradual ascent until we reach the empire lines of the regency period.

Let's start in 1793.Waistlines are creeping towards the bust, raised from the natural waist which they've been at for nearly a century. Round gowns, the type of dress that has a closed-front bodice and attached closed-front petticoat, are shoving the anglaise's and Italian gowns out of the way. The robe en chemise is being altered for the higher waistline.

Skirts are full, gathered all the way around. In fact, the fuller the better. The pregnant look reigns supreme. Women want boobs again. The rigid boned stays of previous decades are giving way to stays with less boning, and gussets to allow for boob-age (this is totally a word). The thrusty-ness of the 1780s is still fashionable, and in less than a decade the boobs will be elevated well above their natural position.

It's actually quite difficult to date fashion plates and extant garments from the 1790s, in my humble opinion. Since I was doing research into this time period it was difficult to tell what was from the later 1790s and what was from 1793.

The above is circa 1791, which fits because these are both perfect examples of fashionable gowns at the end of the 1780s. The lady on the left has what appears to be a chemise a la reine hybrid gown (if it has a name, please educate me). It's gathered at the waist and neck, and has long, tight-fitting sleeves. The lady on the right has a zone-front Pierrot, with awesome tail. Both sport a hedgehog hairstyle, again from the 1780s. Most importantly, the waistline is still in its natural position.

The way I see it is fashion doesn't change overnight, it's a gradual progression from one thing to another, an evolution. 1793 doesn't just come around and all of a sudden waistlines are right under the bust. If we remember that fabric was an expensive commodity in the 18th century, with many gowns and garments being refitted or re-purposed for someone else. There are many examples of this on extant garments, when francaises have been turned into anglaises, Italian gowns turned into closed round gowns. Hence, it's not unbelievable that women took garments like the above and altered them for a slightly higher waistline.

The next point I can give examples of is 1795. My 1790s pinterest board is sparse because it seems to be quite difficult to date the transition period between the natural waistlines and the full empire. As I said, fashion doesn't change overnight. The 1790s themselves are "transitional" years bridging the gap between the tight fitting Georgian fashions to the empire waisted, delicate regency gowns. So I'm trying to find an elusive transitional period within a transitional period. Does your head hurt, too?


apparently from 1798


circa. 1795

dated: 1795-1800


1790s

The above are all dated, roughly, from early to mid 1790s, and they're perfect examples of my point. Most of them aren't empire waisted, but somewhere between the waist and underbust. We can also see that the skirts are quite full, and don't worry, they get fuller.

We can also see early incarnations of the Spencer jacket, both with sleeves and without. I actually prefer these versions to the Regency ones. I know they're very similar, but there's something much nicer about these in my opinion.

The ones I could find a date for say 1795, and other examples I've found of the 1790s fashion all date from the latter third of the decade, roughly from 1797-1800. By this time the waistline is fully under the bust, and skirts have become fabulously full.






The above are all very similar to each other in regards to style, but I guess that's what happens.

Fabric is another difference about this transitional period. It seems to me that printed cottons, and silk brocades were used more in the 1790s than later years when simplicity reigned. As I said previously, women altered gowns to fit fashions, so the above are most likely alterations from the late 1780s, possibly even earlier when printed cottons and silk brocades were still in fashion. The robe en chemise is really the only plain garment before these. The fashion for flow-y, graceful fabrics also hasn't kicked in, hence some of these gowns are made from stiff fabrics like taffeta.

The fashion plate above also gives a glimpse into how hair is changing. Gone are the gorgeous hedgehogs, replaced by turbans, head wraps, and locks of disarrayed natural curls.

It's not until 1799 and into the early 1800s that the fashion for the infamous white dresses we all associate with the regency period really come into full swing. I should mention that fashion plates will have been references, but there will obviously be variations. Silk was certainly still used, but the Grecian/Roman influence is firmly in its way by 1800, so light material is perhaps more common than the silks seen above.

Printed cotton is also something that changes. it never falls out of fashion, but the large, bold prints of the 1780s and before make way for delicate, small prints. The period from 1800 to about 1820 s definitely a minimal period. Extant gowns aren't trimmed to the nines, and hair also becomes a lot simpler than the hedgehogs of the 1780s and the ridiculousness that is the 1820s/30s.

Let's get back to the 1790s though. We know so far that waistlines raised gradually, and the spencer jacket begins to become fashionable. The bib-front gown also starts to emerge, which I think owes its existence to the round gowns of the previous decade. I want to focus specifically on Spencers. For me, 1790s gowns are all a bit...similar. It feels like they're all just gathered necklines and waistlines. There's no variation in construction or look. Accessories were used instead.

The reason I zoned in on spencers was this extant garment everyone will be familiar with.



I love red, it's no secret, and this has been on my to make list for a few years. I actually have a red silk taffeta in the stash left over from an 1860s project. Another blogger has also re-created it in cotton, but can't remember the blog's name. This entire ensemble is lovely, and seems to be from that sweet spot I was talking about earlier, the transitional period in a transitional period.

Then I found another extant red silk Spencer.



My luck allowed me to find another 1790s spencer, and it's definitely on my to make list.


What can I say? I'm a sucker for tails on jackets.

My plan is to make a round gown, the generic gathered at the waist and neckline, made of printed Indian cotton voile (I know, turns out there are people who still make block painted fabrics!). As for the silk, the leftover red taffeta I have is earmarked for another project, and I didn't want to fork out for silk, especially considering how hot it can get. The next best thing, in my mind, was cotton satin. Instead of red, like above, I opted for a navy blue (although don't think I wasn't super tempted by crimson).

So, what do we do about the 1790s? We can research until we're blue in the face, we can look at fashion plates and assume that everyone followed them, and we can look at extant garments and make the same conclusions, but in reality it was a time of transition, of great political and societal change. The true answer is that we can do whatever we want, because the ladies of the 1790s certainly did.