Showing posts with label mistress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mistress. Show all posts

Sunday, 2 November 2014

History Sunday: John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster (III)

My apologies for having to split this up into so many parts, I honestly thought one post and that would be it.  Presenting the third and final instalment of my posts about John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster.

Gaunt was in charge of the 1376 "Good Parliament" when the commons demanded less taxation and
Alice Perrers at Edward III's side
the removal of Alice Perrers, King Edward III's mistress.  Another woman hated at the time and condemned by history, fiction and fact alike, although a few novels have tried to remedy that opinion (the only one I've read is Anne O'Brien's, another one I couldn't finish; I do apologise, Ms O'Brien you are a talented writer but the romance is personally too soppy for me).  Gaunt was opposed to this but didn't have the support of the rest of the lords or Edward of Woodstock and so initiated their demands.

Edward of Woodstock died at 38 in June 1376, effectively leaving Gaunt with the responsibility for everything.  His nephew, Richard, was now heir presumptive to the English throne but was still a child.

1377 was the year of the "bad parliament" when Gaunt effectively reversed all of the things he had done the previous year.  Alice Perrers was reinstated as mistress and apparently controller of the King, and the poll tax was levied much to the furious displeasure of the commons.  Why did Gaunt do this?  It's a decision I can't get my head around, perhaps it's because I don't know enough.  Had he perhaps agreed to the 1376 parliamentary terms because his older brother had insisted and that as soon as he was dead he did as he pleased?  Gaunt wasn't a stupid man, he would have known his decision to anull the acts of 1376 would provoke national anger but he did it anyway. I will never understand that decision and I don't condone or approve of it either; it was a dickish move, sir!  The commons obviously thought so too because apparently his coats of arms were destroyed wherever they were to be found and his famous Savoy Palace on the Strand in London was nearly looted; John himself was also forced to remain at the other side of the Thames to escape the violence.

Gaunt's unpopularity maintained and during this time was when various nasty rumours surrounding him were created.  One that was reported to riled him was that he was actually the son of a butcher, or
baker (think it was butcher) in Ghent so wasn't the King's real son.  I think the person I feel more sorry for is Philippa in this rumour because it puts her in a terrible light; I'm actually glad she was dead when that rumour was bandied about.  The reason, or origin, of this rumour was that Edward III was not at John's birth in Ghent....how is that a clue that he must be illegitimate?  Poor commoners, grasping at straws.  The other, and one I've mentioned before, was that John wanted the throne of England for himself......oh, really, is that why he angered the nation he was trying to claim?  Yes, you can see these rumours were beyond baseless.

When John went once again to France in 1378 and was unsuccessful his popularity took a further dip.

King Edward III died in June 1377, Richard II, son of Edward of Woodstock, was made King at ten years old.  John proved the rumours false by disappearing and not acting as regent to his young nephew.

Jumping to 1381, the Peasant's revolt, evidently Gaunt was a main target of anger and violence, being the figurehead of the government under the young King Richard II.
The revolt is not really complicated but there are a lot of moving parts and it doesn't all begin in 1381.  I don't know that much about it, I know the leader of the movement was Wat Tyler and that he and a large group of commoners marched on London to demand change.  Richard II, at 14, went out to meet them.  Because he was so young nobody blamed him for the decisions of government because he was still a minor and had practically no power.  The rebels demanded the removal and execution of some of the leading people in the government, Gaunt was one of them.  John was in Scotland at the time.  Richard agreed to all of their terms and everything looked peachy, until Tyler was killed following some easily misunderstood actions in a tense situation.
If Richard looked anything
like David history would
be a lot different.  I also
went to see this in Stratford
and ended up feeling
sorry when Richard died.
 The revolt stretched out over months as parts of the south of England and London were destroyed by the rebels.  It all ended with Tyler's death, and of course, the reneging by Richard of his promises of change and the execution of the other main leaders.

Gaunt, who was in Scotland, came back down into England only to be told about the peasant revolts and that his mansion in London, the Savoy, had been destroyed as a result.  The nobles in the north of England closed their doors to him and he had to go back over the border to my native Scotland, to the court of King Robert II until everything had been settled.  How must he have felt then?  Having to, effectively, run back to Scotland who had minor skirmishes with England during this time, and practically beg for protection?  As much as I want to feel sympathy for John, he did bring it on himself.  This, for me, is where the fictional version I absolutely adore and the real man really separate for me.  The man I speak of, the man who practically gave the finger to the commons and ploughed on, isn't the chivalric, noble man I wish he was.  Nobody's perfect but it seems as though if John had ever been noble or kind it had disappeared by 1377.  I do get the impression he was stubborn and terribly wilful, both of which do not make good leaders.

In 1386 John set sail to Castile to try to take the throne there but failed and remained in Portugal where he married his eldest daughter, Philippa, to King John I in 1387.  This was to create an alliance, and a place for his army to rest, where he could get to Castile better, but in the end it was to no avail. His only surviving child by Constance of Castile, Catherine, was married to Henri III of Castile in 1388.  He then went to Aquitaine where he remained until 1389.

Whilst John was gone it left his youngest brother, Thomas, Duke of Gloucester, to raise a form of rebellion against Richard II who was by now beginning to irritate the nobles.  He was an unsuitable king and his decadent behaviour got him dethroned by his cousin in 1399.  The Lords Appellant, led by Gloucester, caused a political crisis whilst Gaunt was absent.  Gloucester, it seems, would never give up his opposition of Richard's rule.

When John returned in 1389 it was less than a year later that his nephew, the king, gave him the Duchy of Aquitaine.  Apparently this was not popular in Aquitaine as they were accustomed to being ruled by either the King or his heir.  He didn't actually go to Aquitaine until about 1394.

We all know he returned to England in 1396 and married his long time mistress, Katherine de Roet-Swynford.  Gaunt at this time was a counsellor to the king, but also by this time his son had become involved in the politics of Richard's unhappy reign.  When Gloucester was murdered sometime in the late 1390s Gaunt said and did nothing, probably because Henry, his son, had also been involved in the anti-Richard corner.  Unfortunately he could do nothing to prevent his son's exile in 1398.  How must he have felt when his only son was forced to leave England and only return after six years had passed?  John was in his late 50s by now and at a time when people didn't live that long he may have thought he would never see his son again.  Unfortunately if that was the case his fears came to fruition.

John of Gaunt, first Duke of Lancaster, died at Leicester castle on the 3rd February 1399 at aged 58.  He was buried beside his first wife, Blanche of Lancaster, at St Paul's cathedral.
A reconstruction of what St Paul's
used to look like.
 My mind always goes to Katherine here.  How did she feel that the love of her life wanted to be buried beside his first wife and not her?  I think I read somewhere that his decision to be buried next to Blanche was to effectively strengthen Henry of Bolingbroke's claims, as he was the only legitimate son of Gaunt.  Maybe I just made that up but whatever the reason that's where he was buried.

As I've said in another post Leicester castle is now just a mound but I do intend to go there next week and see where Gaunt, and Constance of Castile, both left this world; when I put it like that it sounds morbid, doesn't it?

What was intended as one post became three, I would like to thank those who have made it to the third post, it must have been difficult with all my lapses of concentration.  As for references, there are none in the text (I hate referencing and I find with history someone has always said it before you).  I have two sources.

Wikipedia (numerous pages on everyone I've mentioned in this post)
Weir, Alison: The Story of John of Gaunt and his scandalous Duchess, 2011.

I would also recommend the novels:
Seton, Anya: Katherine, 1954
O'Brien, Anne: The Scandalous Duchess, 2014
                         The King's Concubine, 2012
Harper, Karen: The First Princess of Wales, 2006

No doubt I've read more on this time period but those are the ones that stick out in my mind.  Happy reading!

Sunday, 26 October 2014

History Sunday: John of Gaunt, First Duke of Lancaster (II)

This is the second installment of my new segment, History Sunday! More about the amazing John of Gaunt (Ghent), first Duke of Lancaster, son of King Edward III and Queen Phillipa.

I'm not so sure about this image of him.  I remember reading somewhere that it was a copy of an actual portrait, perhaps I'm wrong.  Due to Anya Seton's novel, and most others I've read that concerns Edward III and his family, the children have blue eyes, or "Plantagenet blue eyes" and since this portrait is lacking that I'm a little disappointed.  That's not to say they actually had blue eyes but since blue eye colour is my favourite I wanted that to be true.  I will have to be consoled by King Henry II who had blue eyes and was red haired to boot.

Getting back to it, and something I missed in my last post.  John was created Duke of Lancaster in 1362 by his clever father, who also gave similar titles to his other sons.  It was the first creation of an English Duke if I remember that correctly.  John's younger brother, Edmund, was created Duke of York and this is where the families in the wars of the roses came from.  The other titles were, Lionel, Duke of Clarence, John's immediate elder sibling, and Thomas, Duke of Gloucester, who was the youngest of the brood.  I think Edward of Woodstock was also created Duke of Cornwall but since he was also Prince of Wales and Duke of Aquitaine I suppose it was a bit less important than those two.

So we left John in France where it seemed to be a lot of Guerrilla tactics, attacking towns, and small skirmishes with the French Army.  All in all the only thing these years provided to do was prevent an apparent French invasion of England (that's from wikipedia and has a source but I'll take it with a pinch of salt).  John would have been around 29-30 during these years and it was his first proper command so there must have been pressure, at least placed by himself if not by those around him, to have a glorious victory as his father and eldest brother had.  Sadly it was not to be.

If you can't tell by now I know very little about the Duke's military campaigns because it just doesn't interest me that much but I will march on because there were many during his lifetime.  In 1370 he was summoned to Aquitaine (or Gascony but I prefer the first name) to help his brothers Edward of Woodstock and Edmund of Langley defend England's territory there.  By this time Edward of Woodstock was not in the best of health and after fighting off enemies as long as he could he gave up (because he was Duke of Aquitaine) and sailed back to England, leaving John in charge (Edmund of Langley was John's younger brother).  Unfortunately Aquitaine was not in a good way, he struggled for a year to defend it against the French but subsequently also gave up and returned to England, but not before he found himself a wife.

Peter "the cruel" of
Castile
Infanta Constance (Constanza and many other variations) of Castile was a claimant to the throne of Castile (apparently the true heir).  She was the second eldest daughter of King Peter of  Castile and Leon and his mistress Maria de Padilla.  When King Peter died his illegitimate half-brother, Henri of Trastamara, claimed the throne and ousted Constance and her younger sister Isabella (who went onto marry Edmund of Langley).  The English, wanting an ally against the French, supported Constance's claim to the Castilian throne (even though she was just as illegitimate as Henri of Trastamara).

This is where John's reasons and mind become very interesting to think about.  As the third son of Edward III he was in line to the throne, but as his two older brother's had children he got further and further away.  When Gaunt became unpopular in later life people thought he wished the throne for himself but there has never been any evidence in any source that he ever had designs on the English throne.  Yet, he went after the Castilian throne in right of his wife.  He obviously wanted a throne but why did he go for Castile?  I think it probably has to do with the relationship between Edward of Woodstock and John.  As we all know the Prince of Wales had two sons by Joan of Kent, the younger of which, Richard of Bordeaux, became Richard II of England.  I think it was the love John had for Prince Edward that he didn't go after the throne and supported his nephew when he ascended to the English throne.  Gaunt could have taken England, he was the richest man at the time, is the 15th or 16th richest man in history, there is no way he could have failed, especially given the unpopularity Richard's reign quickly cultivated (even if it wasn't always, in the early years, directed at the boy king).  Instead, John wanted the throne of Castile, by right of Constance.

And so began a bitter and ultimately fruitless campaign.  Constance was taken back to England whilst Henri of Trastamara ruled in Castile.  John claimed the hollow title of King of Castile in 1372.  It wouldn't be until the late 1380s he actually tried to take the throne with an army but it ended in defeat.

Now, what Gaunt is perhaps most famous for.  Katherine de Roet.  Anya Seton's novel, and one by Anne O'Brien which I also attempted to read but couldn't.  The latter novel was just too focused around their love story and it wasn't as believable or realistic as Katherine by Anya Seton.  It did satisfy my lust for the time period though.
Another book I read about her was by Alison Weir and I really enjoyed that one and would recommend it if you want to find out about the true story of Katherine de Roet.

Katherine was a daughter of a herald from Hainault, Paon de Roet, who probably had something to do with Queen Philippa.  She had two sisters and a brother and I only know about her sisters and nothing about her brother, Walter.  Elizabeth, who people assume is the eldest, was given as a nun to St Waudru's in Mons, and later became the Canoness.  According to Weir this seemed to be a de Roet family tradition of giving a daughter to God as Katherine also did the same.  Phillipa de Roet, better known as the wife of the famous writer Jeoffrey Chaucer, was the other sister.  Who was older has been debated, some say Katherine was the eldest, others say Philippa; certainly in Anya Seton's novel Katherine is the younger one, not to say that is any kind of proof whatsoever.

Katherine married Ottes Swynford, or Hugh Swynford, kind of confused by the naming, but he was a knight from Lincolnshire.  She had two or three children with him, one son and potentially two daughters, although the existence of Margaret Swynford, a nun, is disputed.  The other daughter, Blanche, was John of Gaunt's Goddaughter and she was put into the ducal nursery with his two daughters by Blanche of Lancaster.  Katherine was given the position of governess to his two children during the time Blanche was still alive.  They did not begin their long lasting relationship until after she had died in 1369.
Probably a contemporary image of
Katherine

I'm not really sure when Hugh Swynford died but Katherine was unmarried by the time she began her relationship with John.  It was some time after 1369 but before 1372, but as we all know John was away a lot in France and Aquitaine between these years.  Weir gives some accurate dates so please read her book, it is much more informative than these posts which is mostly from memory and checked by Wikipedia.

If John was faithful to Blanche he was not so honest to Constance of Castile. The couple had a daughter and a son, but the son, John, died in infancy, and the daughter, Catherine (I chose a different spelling because Katherine had nothing to do with the naming of Catherine, as you can see it was a popular name) who later went onto become the Queen of Castile when she married King Henri III.  I have no idea how Constance felt about Katherine.  From what I've read in Weir's biography John was not discrete about his relationship with Katherine, perhaps at the beginning but that discretion didn't last long.  The opening pages of Weir's book vividly paints a picture of John and Katherine out riding with him holding her horse's bridle, a sign that she was his.  I feel sympathy for Constance even though both her fictional portrayals do nothing to evoke such a sentiment; in O'Brien's novel she is a bit of a spoiled child, the typical rightful wife who scorns the mistress.  I don't blame O'Brien for doing this, Katherine is the main character and the reader would like her less because at the end of the day she is the 'other' woman.  Seton's portrayal is a little less opposing but from what I can remember Constance features very little in the book at all.
How must it truly have felt for her?  So far away from home in a foreign, very different country.  Did she feel the same fervour that John did for the throne of Castile?  Did the existence of Katherine truly hurt and bother her?  It is wrong to look on medieval royalty as we look on ourselves in the 21st Century.  These days extramarital affairs are scorned and looked down upon, everyone feels sympathy for the wife and loathing for the mistress, but that's because monogamy is a huge part of our culture, we are all taught to think, or know, that we deserve a faithful partner.  This wasn't the case in the 14th century, or really any century until perhaps the 20th and even then it was a slow time in coming.  As a royal woman, the daughter of a King, would she have been taught to accept that her husband would take a mistress and that she had no place or even right to question that, or to become irritated by it.  Did she have a resigned acceptance that her future husband would take mistresses, but she would always be his proper wife?  Constance was the daughter of a mistress so perhaps I'm delving too much into this.
On the other hand did she really ever care for John in that way at all?  Was he just a means to an end which was the Castilian throne?  Perhaps she genuinely didn't give a fig about Katherine's existence but I find that a little hard to believe.  If she hated John, or truly never liked him, then fair enough, but John was fighting for her corner when few other people were, surely that breeds some kind of affection, if not mutual respect?  There is no doubt they had that for each other, but did that mean Katherine's existence would have irked Constance, potentially not.

Oh dear, so much for John of Gaunt.  His relationship with Katherine de Roet-Swynford lasted until his death and if you don't know by now he eventually married her.  It's easy to get all mushy and romantic about this
"he loved her so much he defied all boundaries to marry her"
"that's true love, enduring time and social stigma."
As much as I want to believe that John only married Katherine because he loved her I seriously doubt, no, I don't believe, that was the only reason; I think a big part of it was, as does Weir, that their children were actually the reason.  As most history buffs know illegitimate children were left out of inheritance unless specifically stated in the will.  The children Gaunt had by Katherine, the well-known Beauforts, were all illegitimate.  There were four in total:

John, Earl of Somerset, and the ancestor of the Tudor Kings.
The Beaufort Earls of Somerset
coat of arms
Henry, Cardinal
Thomas, Duke of Exeter
Joan, Countess of Westmorland.

*gasp* they have titles!  Indeed, and probably as a result of their father's marriage and subsequent efforts to have them legitimised.  Gaunt married Katherine in 1396 and sadly he died a mere three years later, but left Katherine to be the second lady in all of England; quite the rise for a mistress isn't it?  She was respected by both Richard II and Henry IV, there was even affection with the latter as he his own mother had died when he was very young and Katherine must have been a comfort.

Getting back to Gaunt, poor man I've been so distracted by the women in his life I've forgotten all about him, and this is the reason I'm not a biographer, or a very good blogger; too easily distracted.  He married Constance in 1371/1372 and had also began his relationship with Katherine.  Gaunt was in France until 1374 when he was forced to return to England after his army had either died of dysentery or deserted.  Edward of Woodstock was still ailing and now Edward III was also ill so Gaunt took a lot of responsibility of government on his shoulders.  Unfortunately this also marked the start of his negatively spiraling popularity with the people of the nation.
Or the Peasant's revolt