Showing posts with label reading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reading. Show all posts

Monday, 17 November 2014

Morality: can protagonists ever be morally corrupt?

This is something I've been thinking about recently especially as I'm starting a new historical novel and nearly finished my previous fantasy one based on Waterhouse's "The Tempest" painting.  I have written many, many characters over the years and all seem to have at least one thread going through them; they're all morally upright.  I used to think this was because I also have very strong morals which I blame entirely on Japanese anime and subsequently South Korean dramas (if you don't know what I mean just go and watch one of them and you'll see all protagonists are near saintly), but more recently I began to think that it's just the nature of the beast.  Your protagonist pushes your story forward and they're the ones that keep your reader abreast of the tale but if they're unlikeable then the reader won't continue.  Are heroes/heroines dislikeable if they have no morals?  Is having no morals the same as being a "bad" character/person?  I am now going to delve into this topic based on sources of books I've read, which doesn't really seem that much but there's a reason.  I am now solely into historical mystery/crime and the characters don't really push the story forward so much as the plot's twists and turns do.

The first example that came to mind when I was brainstorming this post was Game of Thrones.  With such a vast array of characters it's hard to exclude these pieces of work from any literary discussion.  I have read all five of the installments of a Song of Ice and Fire and at the time when the Tv series had just started I was obsessed.  What typically happens with an obsession?  It dies down and now I'm sick of hearing and looking at them, to the extent I stopped watching the TV series and don't know if I'm going to continue reading.  What I don't understand now that I've had time to look objectively is why they're so popular.  They're so so depressing!  I am a girl who likes happy endings, I like when I have hope during a story that things are going to get better, that good things as well as bad are going to happen to any character.  With Martin's works it was always the bad thing that was going to happen to each and every character he wrote about, this happened to the extent where a bit of the stories actually became predictable for me; think of the thing you don't want to happen to Arya, it happens.  Towards book 4 and 5 I was beginning to question the point in reading them, nothing was ever going right, and that is exactly the biggest flaw with this series.  It's too pessimistic and cynical to be convincing.  I know that everyone praises the humanity of the characters, and I will give Martin that, they are quite complex to a certain extent, but his story is just too doom and gloom to have that authentic, real feel to them.  Yes, I know it's fantasy, but I like my fantasy to be believable, a mirror of some sort of the real world.  Bad things do not incessantly happen to normal people, life is balanced, of which there is none in here.
But I didn't come here to talk about the plot, I came to mention a few characters.  I read these books at least two years ago now, probably nearing three, so I've forgotten a lot of things but here are what stuck out.  Tyrion is my favourite character and by far the most misunderstood by other characters in the novels; my opinion of Tyrion was that he was morally upright and wanted to do the right and honourable thing, he had a soft spot for outcasts understandably.  Therefore isn't Tyrion classed as a 'good' character?   Cersei, Tyrion's sister, is vicious, vindictive and let's face it a complete bitch, apparently she cares for her children but the only evidence of that was her threatening Tyrion because he sent one of them away.  Do these traits make her a 'bad' character; an evil queen type?
There are others who follow this same line, Jon Snow wants to do the right thing and is honourable, Danerys Targaryen is reaching for sainthood and even Jaime Lannister starts to become an honourable character when his POV is introduced.  Aren't there clear cut lines here between who's a 'good' character and who's a 'bad' one?
Delving deeper, Tyrion kills his father, but his father is Tywin Lannister, another 'bad' character.  Readers feel less inclined to hate him because of who is father was, some would even say he deserved it.  Unfortunately Jon Snow, Danaerys and Jaime have no such moral blunders the entire way through the books and all seem to do the right thing all of the time.
I give an honourable mention to Joffrey Baratheon/Lannister for being a typical, and unrealistic, villain.  Martin didn't even try to put some humanity in that boy, and guess what, everyone hated Joffrey.

Moving onto more familiar and less complex ground.  Mistresses are looked down upon by women today, being the 'other woman' is something to be ashamed of.  There have been recent assaults of mistresses in China by the spouses of the cheating husbands, it has always been a position of scorn and judgment.  Novel readers, especially historical (romantic) fiction is predominately women, which means you have to aim at your reader.  One of the most popular books of the 20th Century was about a mistress!  I've mentioned this novel before, Anya Seton's "Katherine" was published in 1954 and has maintained popularity ever since (which is why they should make it into a TV series) and is about John of Gaunt's long-time mistress and eventual third wife, Katherine de Roet-Swynford.  Click here to read my History Sunday segment about John of Gaunt and Katherine.  Why is a novel about a mistress so popular?
When I read Katherine I found the heroine morally upright, religiously so, because she was pious.  She had a conscience and was somewhat reluctant, for evident reasons, to become his mistress at first.  Throughout the novel she continues to display kindness, compassion and every trait that most people want for themselves.  Is this what makes her so likeable, or is it the historical setting which takes the heat away from the mistress position?
In Anne O'Brien's novel about Katherine she was also pious and a little reluctant to become Gaunt's mistress but the reasons were purely selfish this time.  I never finished this novel but I never truly hated this version of Katherine (I didn't really like her much but it wasn't because she lacked morals).
Another maligned mistress, Alice Perrers, has been the focus of some newer novels, only one of which I tried to read.  In Seton's novel she's portrayed as the shunned mistress of the king, a foreboding warning to the young katherine what's at stake when a woman gives up her reputation for a man, in Harper's novel about Joan of Kent she's horrible and ugly if I remember correctly and everyone hates her.  Finally, in O'brien's novel about her she's sort of bland but still seems to have a conscience, a far way away from how she's portrayed in every novel that isn't about her.  In the novels with her as a secondary character she's selfish, greedy, everything history reports her to be, whilst in novels about her she has some semblance of a conscience.  Coincidence?

Finally I'll move onto a character from the world of TV.  Dexter is a brilliant show and I honestly can't pin down the reason.  The protagonist is a serial killer and he gets away with it!  But most people who watch the show love Dexter because to a degree he is as cute as a button.
 The more I think about it the more I think its linked to humanity.  What I mean by this is that whenever we watch movies about non-human characters, Edward Scissor hands, Frankenstein, we all feel sorry for the bad things that happen to them because they display human characteristics even though they're not human.  They're learning to be human and are at times so innocent and genuinely good that when misfortune comes their way our hearts crack a little.  Dexter is in a very similar band.  He's human but not quite, a large chunk of what makes us all human is dormant and slowly awakens through the series.  I also think Dexter is very popular because he makes the audience laugh.  I first came across this tactic when I went to see Richard II at the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford.  He was a funny king, a little sardonic but still made me laugh, and I ended up feeling sorry for him by the end of the play.  But Dexter, by definition, is not a 'good' character, he's also not a bad one either.  Voila, a human protagonist.  It's a shame that a hero needs to be a serial killer to be human.  By killing people constantly he is what the world defines as a bad character, watch any murder/police drama and the bad guy kills people; but Dexter loves his family and will do anything, killing included, to protect and seek revenge for them.

It's a bit of a steep decision to make, though, for a writer, and a dangerous one.  I personally always try and avoid my characters killing anyone because I think it may make them seem a little less sympathetic.  Can a person truly be a killer and a 'good' person.  Going along those same lines, Taryn Connagh in my novel "Poison Most Royal" is a hitwoman/assassin.  I didn't think twice about her occupation because I've always wanted to write about a woman who kills people for a living, but Taryn has her reasons for doing so and questions her own morality throughout the novel.  I don't know if Taryn is likeable, it's hard to gain some perspective
when you're reading your own creation, but Taryn has morals, as all my characters seem to.

Returning to the question of this post.  Can a protagonist ever be morally corrupt?  Even Dexter has a set of rules he sticks to.  It is almost impossible for anyone to answer this question because no one in the world has read all the books in existence.  Making characters moral does increase the likelihood that the reader will like them, but simultaneously if you write a bad character they'll be immediately disliked anyway.  I've never read a book where the main characters don't have good morals and don't make good decisions.  I dislike reading posts and blogs about "how to write a good character" or "how to write ....... well".  There is no one set guide to writing!  If that were the case then every book published and written would be nothing more than a creative journal article.  There is a difference between science and art, there always has been.  Writing these guides on how to write is going against the very fabric of creative writing; the clue is in the title, creative!  There is no one way to write a novel, novella, short story, poem, or any of these things; it's not statistics, believe me, I know.  Scientific researchers, like myself, have guides to writing journal articles and reports, most, if not all, of our research write ups have to follow the same structure, but that's science, we like things that have a format.  Art isn't supposed to be like that.

I also love the deviation from statistics reports because at least with this research question I don't have to answer it.  There is no answer to my question.  Do characters have to be morally upstanding?  Personally I think they have to have some semblance of good sense, but above all they should, if possible, make good decisions.  There are books and novels where the main character makes a bad decision and it haunts them for the rest of their lives.  Characters aren't real people, they shouldn't have to conform to an exact human nature.  That being said they shouldn't be unbelievable as human beings.  Characters can reflect the best of human natures and the worst, but they shouldn't be saintly or villainous.  It's easy to make a character a saint that does no wrong and also, say, to make a villain with no good bone in their body, but neither are realistic.  If they do something bad they should have a reason for it, if they're morally upstanding there has to be a foundation for that behaviour.  Reason is what makes a character, their history, the things you don't write about, that's what makes them who they are; the nameless relatives also have a good say in that as well.  I don't know if my characters are very human, no one has reviewed my novel to tell me otherwise, but the above process is what I go through every time I think of a character, every time I sit down and begin typing their reaction to a scenario or something that has happened to them.

What are your views on characters?  Do you think a hero/heroine can be morally corrupt and still be liked by the readers?  Who is the most human character you have ever read?



Sunday, 16 November 2014

History Sunday: Eleanor of Castile (II)

Leonor, anglicised at the time as Alienor, and in modern English, Eleanor, was now Queen consort of England and had already completed her role as consort by giving Edward I his son and heir, at this time, Alfonso.  But there were more children to come.  Alfonso, created Earl of Chester, was born in roughly 1273 in Gascony and  became his father's heir after the deaths of his older brothers; John (1266-1271) and Henry (1268-1274).  As I said previously she gave birth an estimated sixteen times but only a handful survived infancy or childhood.
Katherine (1261-1264), Joanna (b/d.1265), Juliana (may have been unnamed)(d.1271), Berengaria (1276-1278), unnamed daughter (1277-1278) were all daughters who died in early infancy, as well as John, Henry and Alphonso who all predeceased their father.  Now her surviving children:
Eleanor (1269-1298), the eldest surviving child and daughter married Henry, Count of Bar, and had issue.
Joan of Acre (1272-1307), married firstly Gilbert de Clare and then Ralph de Monthermer, producing offspring from both marriages.
Margaret (1273-1333) married John II of Brabant and had one son.
Mary (1279-1332) a Benedictine Nun and Amesbury.
Elizabeth (1282-1316), married firstly John, Count of Holland, and secondly, Humphrey de Bohun, Earl of Hereford and Essex, and had issue.
Edward of Caernarvon (1284-1327), the ill-fated Edward II of England.

As you can see it was all daughters that survived childhood with only one son, Edward, becoming his father's heir.  I always feel for families at the time, especially ones like Eleanor's because despite their rank she cared a lot for her children.  Having os many of her offspring die before she did must have been heart wrenching.  According to sources the couple took the death of Alphonso particularly hard.

Eleanor Cross
I actually love Edward and Eleanor's marriage.  There's a story which I hope to God is true.  Since the church was very strict on when, how and where people could have sex, it was forbidden during Lent.  Edward I was a pious king and never shared his wife's bed during this holy time.  Every Easter Monday, at the end of Lent, he would pay Eleanor's ladies to trap him in his chambers so he would have to pay a ransom to be set free and visit Eleanor's rooms.  I love this story so much because it's not really a usual tale about medieval monarchs who always seem steeped in this fog like seriousness.  What is truly touching is that when Eleanor died, the next Easter Monday after her death he still paid her ladies the ransom.
There are many instances like this one that proves Edward and Eleanor's marriage was a successful one by any terms.  Edward is never recorded to have fathered any illegitimate children and by all accounts seems to have been faithful to his wife.  Another example is that when she died he erected the famous Eleanor crosses wherever her funeral entourage stopped and a few can still be seen today.
The final story I will tell here is that when the Earl of Norfolk was getting married, Edward I refused to attend, and so Eleanor paid minstrels to play for him.  Their marriage definitely held true affection that every historian and medievalist is surprised, if not impressed by.  Edward was a brutal, intimating and fearsome man, but Eleanor seemed to be his retainer, his literal better half, much like Matilda of Flanders was for William the Conqueror.  It is said after her death Edward seemed to become more temperamental and harsh.

Surprisingly Eleanor was not popular in her own time, in fact any foreign Queen had to make a grand gesture of some kind to be popular in England,  With foreign consorts came their many, many foreign relatives, and in true English style, the people of England despised them.  After Edward and Eleanor's recall to England by Henry III, her relatives came over with her and immediately garnered unpopularity from the commons because they were lavished with land, power and position.  This wasn't the first or the last time when a Queen's relatives would harm her popularity with her subjects, in fact Eleanor of Provence, consort of Henry III, was even more unpopular.  Eleanor, although a devoted wife and loving mother, was disliked by her subjects because they thought her a grasping foreigner.  There is some foundation to their reasons though as Eleanor had a lot of land as queen consort and made possibly unwise business transactions.

Although their relationship was loving and respectful Eleanor had limited influence over her husband, but she was consulted about her daughter's age of marriage, as is only right.  She had some influence in other political decisions her husband made but they were few and far between.

To get back to her education Eleanor really ran with the writing culture of the day having the only scriptorium in northern Europe open and copying and illuminiating manuscripts for her.  Books about the lives of saints and many more things from the time are all because of Eleanor who was a major patroness of literature in the day.

Eleanor died in Nottinghamshire in November 1290 at the age of 49 with Edward, her husband of 39 years, at her bedside.  I think this is heartbreaking because of the affection they held for one another which was further proven with the spectacle Edward made of her funeral procession.
Fortunately Eleanor died before things between her husband and only surviving son would get really bad, but its perhaps unfortunate for the younger Edward that he didn't have his mother around for surely she would have intervened on his behalf, as most royal mothers before her had.
Edward I remarried in 1299 to Margaret of France and the couple had two children together.  Although it did take 9 years for King Edward to remarry I don't think it was because of his grief; apparently as early as 1293 he was searching for a new bride.  He died in 1307, a somewhat resented king and angry man, leaving his son with debt, border strifes and political problems.

I like Eleanor of Castile just because she didn't do anything scandalous.  Isabella of France, the daughter-in-law she never met, overthrew her husband, and many more Queens of the age were scandalous, but Eleanor of Castile was just a normal consort who bore a ridiculous amount of children and who had the undying faitihfulness and respect of her husband.  She must have been quite a woman to garner the affection of the fearsome Edward Longshanks, bear as many offsring as she did and travel everywhere with her husband (which was somewhat unusual at the time).  Although she was disliked during her own time she's had a positive, if not easily forgotten, opinion since the 17th Century.  Unfortunately I think she's easy to forget, I always find people like Eleanor of Aquitaine, Empress Matilda and Isabella of France are the centre for novels because they're supposed to be these empowered females, but I have greater respect for women like Eleanor of Castile because they lived their life with grace and accomplishment.

Unfortuntely I've never read a novel about Eleanor or her husband, or even of her time period in history; they seem to be a bit thin on the ground or perhaps I'm just not looking in the right place.  All novels centre on the numerous battles between England and Scotland during her lifetime which I dislike.

As for sources; thanks Wikipedia!

Wednesday, 12 November 2014

Life has themes: this week's = Morality!

Recently I wrote a very long post about protagonist morality and whether a hero or heroine can ever be truly morally corrupt.  I meant to publish it to the world today until something unusual happened which mirrored that post.

We all like finding money whether it be in our pockets, pressed up against the washing machine door as your clothes are spinning, or in our bank accounts.  Some of us even like finding it outside on the ground.  When I was younger I never found money; I think I found a £2 coin once and was so happy.  Then adulthood hit and my belief system formed.  I am not a Christian or any of the other accepted religions of the world, I prefer to think I'm Wren Religion.  I don't want to go into the complicated labyrinth of my beliefs in deities but jumping straight to the main pivoting point of my entire life and the one thing that makes my decisions; Karma!

In the most basic definition of the word I have taken Karma to be simply, "what goes around, comes around" or sometimes "do good things and good things will come".  I mentioned in my post (soon to be published) about character morality that the reason why I staunchly believe in Karma is my childhood watching Japanese Anime and then my late adolescence and current life watching South Korean dramas.  Those cultures are very moral, they indoctrinate their youth with a clear sense of right and wrong from a very early age, obviously mirrored in their TV shows.  Like every population there's always outliers (showing my statistics roots there) but for the majority of people in Japan and South Korea they do the right thing; this is proven by the lowest crime rates, and highest reported safety by many foreigners that go over there to live.  I heard a story from Simon and Martina (if you haven't heard of them go and check out their blog.  They're a couple who have been living in South Korea for years and regularly post videos about life there) that someone lost their wallet in South Korea, they either went to the police station or someone handed it to them and all of the money, credit cards, etc, were still inside.

I never realised how much watching these things when I was younger affected me until my late teens, probably about 17 or 18, maybe even before that.  Getting back to the main point of this blog post, money....I mean morality.  Whenever I find things that don't belong to me, I hand them in, regardless of what it is, even money.

The first instance of this is when I was at John Knox's house in Edinburgh.  I found £40 pounds on the floor and handed it into reception.  They took my phone number and thanked me; I thought that was the end of it.  A few weeks later they phoned me saying none had claimed the money and did I want to come and pick it up.  I was probably about 16 at the time, £40 was a lot of money for me.  I told them to donate it to themselves (all heritage sights in Scotland are run by charities).  I gave away the money because it wasn't mine to keep.  Was it a stupid thing to do?  I don't think stupidity really factors into anything to do with morality.  Morals are very much based on individual beliefs, and people with none are usually the ones who say what I did was stupid.
The second instance was a few weeks ago.  There is a flat right beside mine, our doors are separated by a very small space.  As I was about to enter my flat I saw money, £30, lying on the floor.  It was over the border between my flat and theirs.  I wish I was joking when I said this but I stood there for what felt like 5 minutes trying to decide what to do.  What was the right course of action to take in that moment?  This is the problem with any belief system, there always comes a time when there's grey areas.  Good thing about my religion is I can make it up as I go along, change to suit circumstance.  Because it was lingering more outside next door's flat than mine, I picked it up and chapped on their door.  Handing it to the disgruntled occupant I entered my flat with a sigh or relief.  The money may not have been hers, and I'm not so naive in thinking she didn't just pocket it herself, but I did the right thing and my Karma is all I care about, not hers.  The only other thing would have been to trudge all the way down to reception and hand it in there, but from where it was positioned on the ground it either belonged to someone in her flat or mine, and it was closer to their door.  This was an exciting thing to happen in my life but it was soon forgotten, until today!!

So it wasn't as fancy as this but still

The elevator is out for the second time in 2 weeks (see here about my post when the lift was out of order the first time).  This means that the 200+ people in my block are all having to use the stairs again (but fret not, it's worth it because all of us got a small box of Roses chocolates and an apology note: I would walk up to the 14th floor of my block if it meant getting another box, but I am expecting a bigger box this time).  I ordered something from Amazon this week and got an email saying it had been delivered today.  Unfortunately it was too large to fit in our small mailbox and so I got a letter telling me to pick it up at reception.  Dumping my bag in my room and signing this little note, I went down the stairs again, and lone behold what did I find, £10!!

It was just lying there, on the stairs where 200 and more people walk.  To be honest it hadn't been there on my way up the first time, but on my way down there it was, crumpled and lost.  It was impossible to tell who it belonged to.  And so began another moral dilemma.  Now, I've been having a really Sh** week this week, my attempts at buying a new pair of glasses that actually fit me has left me out of pocket by more money than I'd care to admit (and no matter how many times they're adjusted they're still not right), and it's a coursework week which means stress with some more stress on the side.  I was on my way to the reception, and when I picked it up I did think about handing it in, but then I thought, what were they going to do with it?  There are 600+ people living in my building.  They would most likely keep it for a week and then if no one claimed it keep it themselves.  Yes, someone could have asked but that's not British is it?  We accept that if we lose money someone is going to take it.  Peeps, today I was that person, today, I was British, or more specifically, Scottish.  I was like any other person I know whose belief system is "finders keepers".

This is the question, was taking that £10 bad karma?  I have never kept money in the two instances before this.  Why during such a bad week did I find the money?  Coincidence would be what a rational person, and probably I, should say, but I am also a writer and I like to believe in more than that.  I was having a bad week, am having a bad week, and finding that £10 did cheer me up, before the onslaught of Karma worrying came.  I will admit, my belief system broke down a little bit, but don't they all?  I don't feel guilty about picking it up, after writing this post I do feel slightly guilty about keeping it, but aren't people permitted strays from their beliefs?

Some of you may think I'm contemplating this too much, it was only £10 after all, but for some people that could be something important.  Maybe it was just the fall-out from someone else's bad week (yes, pun intended).  It brightened up my week a little and has some new friends in my purse instead of being abandoned on the stairs with no one.  On the other hand, at least it came to me and inspired me to entertain people with this post, and at least I actually thought about doing the moral thing whereas most of the other people here would have snatched it without another thought on the matter.

What do you think?  To much contemplation or the foundations of future bad karma?

Sunday, 9 November 2014

History Sunday: Eleanor of Castile

Welcome to my weekly installment of History Sunday.  Since my first three posts in this segment about John of Gaunt I was playing with the idea of writing about his father Edward III, or his brother Edward, Prince of Wales, but I decided that three consecutive weeks on the 14th Century is quite enough for now.  Let me take you back, instead, to the 13th Century (not a very big jump I know).

Edward I receives very mixed opinions from historians.  He was a brutal, almost heartless ruler who beat the Welsh and for the most part the Scottish into submission, earning him the epitaph "the Hammer of the Scots".  But he was an effective ruler, until his later years.  I may do a separate post about him later but it will involve quite a bit of research because I don't know that much about him.  Instead, today, I'm going to write about his easily forgotten wife, Eleanor of Castile.

Leonor, as is her Castilian name, was born in Spain (at that time a part of the Kingdom of Castile) in probably 1241 to King Ferdinand III of Castile and his wife, Joan, Countess of Ponthieu in her own right.

If we look up the ancestry tree, first on her father's side, Ferdinand III was the son of Alfonso IX of Leon and Berenguela of Castile, and during his lifetime secured the union of the crowns of Leon and Castile.  He was a great grandson, on his maternal side, of Henry II of England and Alienor of Aquitaine from their daughter, Eleanor of England who had married Alfonso VIII of Castile in 1177.  This means Edward I and Leonor of Castile were related (no surprise there then, I'm beginning to think that being related was actually a pre-requisite for royal marriages, the popes must have been sick of giving out papal bulls to waive the degrees of consanguinity, why not just abolish it because hardly any medieval European royal dynasty observed it).

Looking to her mother's side, Joan, Countess of Ponthieu, was the eventual heiress of Simon of Dammartin, Count of Ponthieu, and his wife, Marie of Ponthieu, and if we trace her paternal line we get back to the kings of France.
Leonor of Castile was quite a pedigree; related to Edward I through her paternal line and Countess of Ponthieu in her own right when her mother and brother both died, so a desirable heiress for any King.

Her father's court encouraged the extensive education of royal children, girls and boys alike, so Leonor was educated to a much higher standard than was expected in the day.

After a possible betrothal to the heir of the Kingdom of Navarre, she was eventually given in marriage to the son and heir of Henry III of England, Edward Longshanks.  In 1254, when she was about 13, the couple were married in Burgos.  Afterwards they remained in Gascony with her husband ruling Aquitaine.  It was here that she gave birth to her first daughter, who didn't live for very long.  I disapprove of this greatly, as most people of the 21st Century do when they look back.  I do realise that heiresses and royal women married young, I do accept that it happened without blanching at the thought, but what I don't understand in this case is why she was sleeping with her husband at 13.  The church said girls were of marriageable age at 12, but usually frowned upon them actually completing their wifely duties until a little bit older, probably 15 or 16.  Why did Edward sleep with the 13 year old Leonor?  It makes me shudder.

The couple were summoned to England by Henry III and I think I remember reading somewhere that it was because she had been pregnant so young that the king was trying to prevent any mishaps happening to her during childbirth; I'm happy she actually survived at 13 years old.

Some sparse information on her father-in-law; one of the semi-incompetent kings of the middle ages, King Henry III of England.  He was the successor of the infamous King John "Lackland" of England who had been forced to sign the Magna Carta in around 1215.  Unfortunately it seems his son was not a better king.  In the 1260s a Baron's revolt broke out supported and lead by Simon de Montfort, Earl of Leicester, who was actually the brother-in-law of the King.  During the 1260s, save from a short time when de Montfort became de facto ruler of England, Eleanor had a great part in supporting her father-in-law and her husband.  She summoned archers from her county of Ponthieu in France and kept hostages and prisoners for Edward at Windsor until she was forced to surrender it by de Montfort who imprisoned her at Westminster Palace.
How must she have felt at this time?  The impression I have of Eleanor is a devoted wife and mother, perhaps not the best defender of castles but you can hardly blame her for that.  I admire her staunch loyalty to Edward, and his for her also, and their mutual trust made the foundations for one of the best marriages between medieval monarchs I have ever read about.

Obviously she wasn't as scary as
one of these things.
Eventually the Second Barons' War was ended at the Battle of Evesham with the death of Simon de Montfort in 1265.  By the end of the 1260s she had given birth to two boys therefore securing her position and the dynasty of her husband.  She had a gaggle of children and I always admire medieval woman who survived all of these pregnancies; even today any woman who births more than five kids has my eternal respect.  Queen Eleanor is suspected to have given birth to a frightening 16 children during her lifetime.

In the 13th Century crusades were still the popular thing of medieval monarchs and Edward I, being young and enthusiastic, agreed to go to the Holy Land and fight alongside the French King Louis IX.  Unfortunately for Louis he died in Carthage which left Edward as de facto leader of the crusade.  Eleanor, in what would become the norm for her life with her husband, followed him to Palestine.  She gave birth to a daughter, called Joan or Joanna of Acre for her birthplace.
There is an interesting and famous story of what happened to the future King of England whilst he was in the Holy Land.  Being so successful there an attempt was made on his life; an assassin stabbed him with a dagger laced with poison.  I have read half an article about the causes and backstory of this attempt but I won't go into it here.  The stories differ, and by far the mot amazing one is Eleanor sucking the poison out of the wound with her teeth.  The other, and probably the more true of the two, is that she was weeping and wailing when the doctor told her to leave because she was making too much noise.

After an unsuccessful campaign in the Holy Land (the beginning of a pattern, by the way) they left in 1272.  When they were in Sicily they learned of the death of Henry III and upon their return to England were crowned in a joint ceremony in 1274.  They really didn't hurry back to England but this may have been because they found out she was pregnant again; a son, Alfonso, was born in Gascony and became heir presumptive.

That's all for Eleanor's story for this week but the second and final part will follow in the next History Sunday segment.




Sunday, 2 November 2014

History Sunday: John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster (III)

My apologies for having to split this up into so many parts, I honestly thought one post and that would be it.  Presenting the third and final instalment of my posts about John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster.

Gaunt was in charge of the 1376 "Good Parliament" when the commons demanded less taxation and
Alice Perrers at Edward III's side
the removal of Alice Perrers, King Edward III's mistress.  Another woman hated at the time and condemned by history, fiction and fact alike, although a few novels have tried to remedy that opinion (the only one I've read is Anne O'Brien's, another one I couldn't finish; I do apologise, Ms O'Brien you are a talented writer but the romance is personally too soppy for me).  Gaunt was opposed to this but didn't have the support of the rest of the lords or Edward of Woodstock and so initiated their demands.

Edward of Woodstock died at 38 in June 1376, effectively leaving Gaunt with the responsibility for everything.  His nephew, Richard, was now heir presumptive to the English throne but was still a child.

1377 was the year of the "bad parliament" when Gaunt effectively reversed all of the things he had done the previous year.  Alice Perrers was reinstated as mistress and apparently controller of the King, and the poll tax was levied much to the furious displeasure of the commons.  Why did Gaunt do this?  It's a decision I can't get my head around, perhaps it's because I don't know enough.  Had he perhaps agreed to the 1376 parliamentary terms because his older brother had insisted and that as soon as he was dead he did as he pleased?  Gaunt wasn't a stupid man, he would have known his decision to anull the acts of 1376 would provoke national anger but he did it anyway. I will never understand that decision and I don't condone or approve of it either; it was a dickish move, sir!  The commons obviously thought so too because apparently his coats of arms were destroyed wherever they were to be found and his famous Savoy Palace on the Strand in London was nearly looted; John himself was also forced to remain at the other side of the Thames to escape the violence.

Gaunt's unpopularity maintained and during this time was when various nasty rumours surrounding him were created.  One that was reported to riled him was that he was actually the son of a butcher, or
baker (think it was butcher) in Ghent so wasn't the King's real son.  I think the person I feel more sorry for is Philippa in this rumour because it puts her in a terrible light; I'm actually glad she was dead when that rumour was bandied about.  The reason, or origin, of this rumour was that Edward III was not at John's birth in Ghent....how is that a clue that he must be illegitimate?  Poor commoners, grasping at straws.  The other, and one I've mentioned before, was that John wanted the throne of England for himself......oh, really, is that why he angered the nation he was trying to claim?  Yes, you can see these rumours were beyond baseless.

When John went once again to France in 1378 and was unsuccessful his popularity took a further dip.

King Edward III died in June 1377, Richard II, son of Edward of Woodstock, was made King at ten years old.  John proved the rumours false by disappearing and not acting as regent to his young nephew.

Jumping to 1381, the Peasant's revolt, evidently Gaunt was a main target of anger and violence, being the figurehead of the government under the young King Richard II.
The revolt is not really complicated but there are a lot of moving parts and it doesn't all begin in 1381.  I don't know that much about it, I know the leader of the movement was Wat Tyler and that he and a large group of commoners marched on London to demand change.  Richard II, at 14, went out to meet them.  Because he was so young nobody blamed him for the decisions of government because he was still a minor and had practically no power.  The rebels demanded the removal and execution of some of the leading people in the government, Gaunt was one of them.  John was in Scotland at the time.  Richard agreed to all of their terms and everything looked peachy, until Tyler was killed following some easily misunderstood actions in a tense situation.
If Richard looked anything
like David history would
be a lot different.  I also
went to see this in Stratford
and ended up feeling
sorry when Richard died.
 The revolt stretched out over months as parts of the south of England and London were destroyed by the rebels.  It all ended with Tyler's death, and of course, the reneging by Richard of his promises of change and the execution of the other main leaders.

Gaunt, who was in Scotland, came back down into England only to be told about the peasant revolts and that his mansion in London, the Savoy, had been destroyed as a result.  The nobles in the north of England closed their doors to him and he had to go back over the border to my native Scotland, to the court of King Robert II until everything had been settled.  How must he have felt then?  Having to, effectively, run back to Scotland who had minor skirmishes with England during this time, and practically beg for protection?  As much as I want to feel sympathy for John, he did bring it on himself.  This, for me, is where the fictional version I absolutely adore and the real man really separate for me.  The man I speak of, the man who practically gave the finger to the commons and ploughed on, isn't the chivalric, noble man I wish he was.  Nobody's perfect but it seems as though if John had ever been noble or kind it had disappeared by 1377.  I do get the impression he was stubborn and terribly wilful, both of which do not make good leaders.

In 1386 John set sail to Castile to try to take the throne there but failed and remained in Portugal where he married his eldest daughter, Philippa, to King John I in 1387.  This was to create an alliance, and a place for his army to rest, where he could get to Castile better, but in the end it was to no avail. His only surviving child by Constance of Castile, Catherine, was married to Henri III of Castile in 1388.  He then went to Aquitaine where he remained until 1389.

Whilst John was gone it left his youngest brother, Thomas, Duke of Gloucester, to raise a form of rebellion against Richard II who was by now beginning to irritate the nobles.  He was an unsuitable king and his decadent behaviour got him dethroned by his cousin in 1399.  The Lords Appellant, led by Gloucester, caused a political crisis whilst Gaunt was absent.  Gloucester, it seems, would never give up his opposition of Richard's rule.

When John returned in 1389 it was less than a year later that his nephew, the king, gave him the Duchy of Aquitaine.  Apparently this was not popular in Aquitaine as they were accustomed to being ruled by either the King or his heir.  He didn't actually go to Aquitaine until about 1394.

We all know he returned to England in 1396 and married his long time mistress, Katherine de Roet-Swynford.  Gaunt at this time was a counsellor to the king, but also by this time his son had become involved in the politics of Richard's unhappy reign.  When Gloucester was murdered sometime in the late 1390s Gaunt said and did nothing, probably because Henry, his son, had also been involved in the anti-Richard corner.  Unfortunately he could do nothing to prevent his son's exile in 1398.  How must he have felt when his only son was forced to leave England and only return after six years had passed?  John was in his late 50s by now and at a time when people didn't live that long he may have thought he would never see his son again.  Unfortunately if that was the case his fears came to fruition.

John of Gaunt, first Duke of Lancaster, died at Leicester castle on the 3rd February 1399 at aged 58.  He was buried beside his first wife, Blanche of Lancaster, at St Paul's cathedral.
A reconstruction of what St Paul's
used to look like.
 My mind always goes to Katherine here.  How did she feel that the love of her life wanted to be buried beside his first wife and not her?  I think I read somewhere that his decision to be buried next to Blanche was to effectively strengthen Henry of Bolingbroke's claims, as he was the only legitimate son of Gaunt.  Maybe I just made that up but whatever the reason that's where he was buried.

As I've said in another post Leicester castle is now just a mound but I do intend to go there next week and see where Gaunt, and Constance of Castile, both left this world; when I put it like that it sounds morbid, doesn't it?

What was intended as one post became three, I would like to thank those who have made it to the third post, it must have been difficult with all my lapses of concentration.  As for references, there are none in the text (I hate referencing and I find with history someone has always said it before you).  I have two sources.

Wikipedia (numerous pages on everyone I've mentioned in this post)
Weir, Alison: The Story of John of Gaunt and his scandalous Duchess, 2011.

I would also recommend the novels:
Seton, Anya: Katherine, 1954
O'Brien, Anne: The Scandalous Duchess, 2014
                         The King's Concubine, 2012
Harper, Karen: The First Princess of Wales, 2006

No doubt I've read more on this time period but those are the ones that stick out in my mind.  Happy reading!

Saturday, 1 November 2014

Halloween post: presentations are the most frightening thing

So for those of you who are my frequent readers, which I estimate to be about 4 at this point, you will know that I suffer from social anxiety.  There is nothing more frightening to someone like me than being told you have to stand up in front of people and talk.....about anything.  Even introducing myself is a nightmare.  I've figured out my limit is about 4-5 people, anymore than that and you can forget actual intelligible English coming out of my mouth.  So when I attended my course's induction and they said there would be a group presentation to do every week you can imagine what my feelings on this subject were.  Not only would I have to mingle with everyone I would then have to stand up and speak.
Thankfully they're not graded or marked in any way because I wouldn't even be getting 50%.  We're given about 2 hours to make a presentation together before we have to present them; this has led to something forever called "presentation Friday".  Since we're only in half a day on a Friday they decided that during the morning we would be subject to standing up and presenting the half-dashed attempt at understanding whatever we had done that week.  Then came this week.
We had not one, not even two, but three presentations.  You'd think after four weeks of standing up on a regular basis that I wouldn't be nervous anymore but this time I hit rock bottom.  On the first day I began to laugh to myself when I deviated from my script that was quivering in my shaking hands and then proceeded to start talking, just using any words that sounded relevant when someone asked a question and no one else in my group answered.  The second day was actually ok save from the sweat soaked script in my hand, and on the third day my poor little piece of paper had a heartbeat of its own and was shaking uncontrollably in my hands the entire way through.  I would like to take this opportunity to thank my group members who, by far, have made it the best group week I've had since I started.
Deviating slightly from the subject I will say a few words on student life, or rather Masters life.  I thought my undergrad degree was bad, stressful and upsetting in so many ways.  I thought, somewhat naively, if I could get through it then I could get through anything.......hahahahahaha.  Holy crap was I wrong.  Coursework weeks are not as kind as they sound; you get an entire week off classes just to do coursework!
Thankfully the deadlines were all met and to be honest because I break up the coursework into pieces and chip away at that giant iceberg from the moment we get it, things haven't been that hectic for me.  Unfortunately what did stress me out was everyone else constantly asking me for help, but I won't go into a rant about it here (believe me I could write an entire post about how irritating my classmates were on the last coursework week; why are you asking me, I don't know either!!!)

I haven't used a pencil for years, we weren't allowed to use one for my exams so all mathematical calculations had to be done in pen; cue many ugly scribbles adorning my notes and exam scripts (sorry lecturers).  Since I came down to Leicester pencil has been my saviour because with the amount of mistakes I made in the first few weeks my notes would have looked unreadable with the amount of ugly, but colourful, scribbles.

This happens a surprising amount; just remember, kids, highlighters aren't always your friend.  In fact I think I remember reading somewhere that they were actually detrimental to studying because your mind is busy thinking you should highlight it rather than read and learn it.
At the end of my undergrad degree I'm pretty sure my entire class suffered from this (it had been a long four years) and 8 exams within two weeks is criminal!
So if uni is so stressful and awful, why do people continue to go?  It would be so easy to be upbeat about this but the fact is, sorry folks, it's the done thing nowadays.  We live in a society that places a lot of importance on a university degree, and if your school was anything like mine, we were made to believe that if we didn't have one then we would never get a good job.  I know now that's not true but at the time we were impressionable.

It is easy to get stressed about uni, to get really irritated over the small things, but at the end of the day I chose to do a masters.  I didn't need one (actually I do but that's besides the point) but I like being a student; I like the stress and I like that it's interesting and challenging, how boring would life be if everything was easy?  My favourite saying is "anything worth doing is never easy".
Besides, it's all good, we get student discount!
If only they didn't have an expiry date on them


Sunday, 26 October 2014

History Sunday: John of Gaunt, First Duke of Lancaster (II)

This is the second installment of my new segment, History Sunday! More about the amazing John of Gaunt (Ghent), first Duke of Lancaster, son of King Edward III and Queen Phillipa.

I'm not so sure about this image of him.  I remember reading somewhere that it was a copy of an actual portrait, perhaps I'm wrong.  Due to Anya Seton's novel, and most others I've read that concerns Edward III and his family, the children have blue eyes, or "Plantagenet blue eyes" and since this portrait is lacking that I'm a little disappointed.  That's not to say they actually had blue eyes but since blue eye colour is my favourite I wanted that to be true.  I will have to be consoled by King Henry II who had blue eyes and was red haired to boot.

Getting back to it, and something I missed in my last post.  John was created Duke of Lancaster in 1362 by his clever father, who also gave similar titles to his other sons.  It was the first creation of an English Duke if I remember that correctly.  John's younger brother, Edmund, was created Duke of York and this is where the families in the wars of the roses came from.  The other titles were, Lionel, Duke of Clarence, John's immediate elder sibling, and Thomas, Duke of Gloucester, who was the youngest of the brood.  I think Edward of Woodstock was also created Duke of Cornwall but since he was also Prince of Wales and Duke of Aquitaine I suppose it was a bit less important than those two.

So we left John in France where it seemed to be a lot of Guerrilla tactics, attacking towns, and small skirmishes with the French Army.  All in all the only thing these years provided to do was prevent an apparent French invasion of England (that's from wikipedia and has a source but I'll take it with a pinch of salt).  John would have been around 29-30 during these years and it was his first proper command so there must have been pressure, at least placed by himself if not by those around him, to have a glorious victory as his father and eldest brother had.  Sadly it was not to be.

If you can't tell by now I know very little about the Duke's military campaigns because it just doesn't interest me that much but I will march on because there were many during his lifetime.  In 1370 he was summoned to Aquitaine (or Gascony but I prefer the first name) to help his brothers Edward of Woodstock and Edmund of Langley defend England's territory there.  By this time Edward of Woodstock was not in the best of health and after fighting off enemies as long as he could he gave up (because he was Duke of Aquitaine) and sailed back to England, leaving John in charge (Edmund of Langley was John's younger brother).  Unfortunately Aquitaine was not in a good way, he struggled for a year to defend it against the French but subsequently also gave up and returned to England, but not before he found himself a wife.

Peter "the cruel" of
Castile
Infanta Constance (Constanza and many other variations) of Castile was a claimant to the throne of Castile (apparently the true heir).  She was the second eldest daughter of King Peter of  Castile and Leon and his mistress Maria de Padilla.  When King Peter died his illegitimate half-brother, Henri of Trastamara, claimed the throne and ousted Constance and her younger sister Isabella (who went onto marry Edmund of Langley).  The English, wanting an ally against the French, supported Constance's claim to the Castilian throne (even though she was just as illegitimate as Henri of Trastamara).

This is where John's reasons and mind become very interesting to think about.  As the third son of Edward III he was in line to the throne, but as his two older brother's had children he got further and further away.  When Gaunt became unpopular in later life people thought he wished the throne for himself but there has never been any evidence in any source that he ever had designs on the English throne.  Yet, he went after the Castilian throne in right of his wife.  He obviously wanted a throne but why did he go for Castile?  I think it probably has to do with the relationship between Edward of Woodstock and John.  As we all know the Prince of Wales had two sons by Joan of Kent, the younger of which, Richard of Bordeaux, became Richard II of England.  I think it was the love John had for Prince Edward that he didn't go after the throne and supported his nephew when he ascended to the English throne.  Gaunt could have taken England, he was the richest man at the time, is the 15th or 16th richest man in history, there is no way he could have failed, especially given the unpopularity Richard's reign quickly cultivated (even if it wasn't always, in the early years, directed at the boy king).  Instead, John wanted the throne of Castile, by right of Constance.

And so began a bitter and ultimately fruitless campaign.  Constance was taken back to England whilst Henri of Trastamara ruled in Castile.  John claimed the hollow title of King of Castile in 1372.  It wouldn't be until the late 1380s he actually tried to take the throne with an army but it ended in defeat.

Now, what Gaunt is perhaps most famous for.  Katherine de Roet.  Anya Seton's novel, and one by Anne O'Brien which I also attempted to read but couldn't.  The latter novel was just too focused around their love story and it wasn't as believable or realistic as Katherine by Anya Seton.  It did satisfy my lust for the time period though.
Another book I read about her was by Alison Weir and I really enjoyed that one and would recommend it if you want to find out about the true story of Katherine de Roet.

Katherine was a daughter of a herald from Hainault, Paon de Roet, who probably had something to do with Queen Philippa.  She had two sisters and a brother and I only know about her sisters and nothing about her brother, Walter.  Elizabeth, who people assume is the eldest, was given as a nun to St Waudru's in Mons, and later became the Canoness.  According to Weir this seemed to be a de Roet family tradition of giving a daughter to God as Katherine also did the same.  Phillipa de Roet, better known as the wife of the famous writer Jeoffrey Chaucer, was the other sister.  Who was older has been debated, some say Katherine was the eldest, others say Philippa; certainly in Anya Seton's novel Katherine is the younger one, not to say that is any kind of proof whatsoever.

Katherine married Ottes Swynford, or Hugh Swynford, kind of confused by the naming, but he was a knight from Lincolnshire.  She had two or three children with him, one son and potentially two daughters, although the existence of Margaret Swynford, a nun, is disputed.  The other daughter, Blanche, was John of Gaunt's Goddaughter and she was put into the ducal nursery with his two daughters by Blanche of Lancaster.  Katherine was given the position of governess to his two children during the time Blanche was still alive.  They did not begin their long lasting relationship until after she had died in 1369.
Probably a contemporary image of
Katherine

I'm not really sure when Hugh Swynford died but Katherine was unmarried by the time she began her relationship with John.  It was some time after 1369 but before 1372, but as we all know John was away a lot in France and Aquitaine between these years.  Weir gives some accurate dates so please read her book, it is much more informative than these posts which is mostly from memory and checked by Wikipedia.

If John was faithful to Blanche he was not so honest to Constance of Castile. The couple had a daughter and a son, but the son, John, died in infancy, and the daughter, Catherine (I chose a different spelling because Katherine had nothing to do with the naming of Catherine, as you can see it was a popular name) who later went onto become the Queen of Castile when she married King Henri III.  I have no idea how Constance felt about Katherine.  From what I've read in Weir's biography John was not discrete about his relationship with Katherine, perhaps at the beginning but that discretion didn't last long.  The opening pages of Weir's book vividly paints a picture of John and Katherine out riding with him holding her horse's bridle, a sign that she was his.  I feel sympathy for Constance even though both her fictional portrayals do nothing to evoke such a sentiment; in O'Brien's novel she is a bit of a spoiled child, the typical rightful wife who scorns the mistress.  I don't blame O'Brien for doing this, Katherine is the main character and the reader would like her less because at the end of the day she is the 'other' woman.  Seton's portrayal is a little less opposing but from what I can remember Constance features very little in the book at all.
How must it truly have felt for her?  So far away from home in a foreign, very different country.  Did she feel the same fervour that John did for the throne of Castile?  Did the existence of Katherine truly hurt and bother her?  It is wrong to look on medieval royalty as we look on ourselves in the 21st Century.  These days extramarital affairs are scorned and looked down upon, everyone feels sympathy for the wife and loathing for the mistress, but that's because monogamy is a huge part of our culture, we are all taught to think, or know, that we deserve a faithful partner.  This wasn't the case in the 14th century, or really any century until perhaps the 20th and even then it was a slow time in coming.  As a royal woman, the daughter of a King, would she have been taught to accept that her husband would take a mistress and that she had no place or even right to question that, or to become irritated by it.  Did she have a resigned acceptance that her future husband would take mistresses, but she would always be his proper wife?  Constance was the daughter of a mistress so perhaps I'm delving too much into this.
On the other hand did she really ever care for John in that way at all?  Was he just a means to an end which was the Castilian throne?  Perhaps she genuinely didn't give a fig about Katherine's existence but I find that a little hard to believe.  If she hated John, or truly never liked him, then fair enough, but John was fighting for her corner when few other people were, surely that breeds some kind of affection, if not mutual respect?  There is no doubt they had that for each other, but did that mean Katherine's existence would have irked Constance, potentially not.

Oh dear, so much for John of Gaunt.  His relationship with Katherine de Roet-Swynford lasted until his death and if you don't know by now he eventually married her.  It's easy to get all mushy and romantic about this
"he loved her so much he defied all boundaries to marry her"
"that's true love, enduring time and social stigma."
As much as I want to believe that John only married Katherine because he loved her I seriously doubt, no, I don't believe, that was the only reason; I think a big part of it was, as does Weir, that their children were actually the reason.  As most history buffs know illegitimate children were left out of inheritance unless specifically stated in the will.  The children Gaunt had by Katherine, the well-known Beauforts, were all illegitimate.  There were four in total:

John, Earl of Somerset, and the ancestor of the Tudor Kings.
The Beaufort Earls of Somerset
coat of arms
Henry, Cardinal
Thomas, Duke of Exeter
Joan, Countess of Westmorland.

*gasp* they have titles!  Indeed, and probably as a result of their father's marriage and subsequent efforts to have them legitimised.  Gaunt married Katherine in 1396 and sadly he died a mere three years later, but left Katherine to be the second lady in all of England; quite the rise for a mistress isn't it?  She was respected by both Richard II and Henry IV, there was even affection with the latter as he his own mother had died when he was very young and Katherine must have been a comfort.

Getting back to Gaunt, poor man I've been so distracted by the women in his life I've forgotten all about him, and this is the reason I'm not a biographer, or a very good blogger; too easily distracted.  He married Constance in 1371/1372 and had also began his relationship with Katherine.  Gaunt was in France until 1374 when he was forced to return to England after his army had either died of dysentery or deserted.  Edward of Woodstock was still ailing and now Edward III was also ill so Gaunt took a lot of responsibility of government on his shoulders.  Unfortunately this also marked the start of his negatively spiraling popularity with the people of the nation.
Or the Peasant's revolt




Saturday, 25 October 2014

What do you mean earphones are no longer a deterrent?

It's been something I've noticed for many years now; train journeys, walking down the street and waiting in queues, even if someone sees your headphones they still insist on speaking to you.  As a disclaimer I will say that my music isn't loud because I want to retain my hearing past the age of 50, and since I used to ride my bike everywhere I disliked being deaf to the numerous cars that wanted to flip me over their bonnet.

My Discussion will start with: are earphones ever really a deterrent to get people not to speak with you?  Haha, discussion.  With my many years of experience at being stopped in the street and asked for directions, for money, or for my poor opinion, wearing earphones has never, ever, ever worked.  It's like most people don't even notice I have them in; I was not born with a colourful wire draping fashionably from my ears!  I think the closest I've come to having them acknowledged was by one of the people on my course who apologised after realising I had them in after he asked me a question.  I get no such courtesy from the people on the street.

Now, why, I hear you ask, am I making such a fuss?  If you don't know by now you obviously haven't been reading this blog for very often.  I probably should have named it "how to be an open recluse in the 21st Century" or apparently "awkward moments of my life".  The origin of my anxiety comes from the fact that I am not a spontaneous person, I have to think about everything before I say it unless it comes out completely nonsensical.  You may think I'm exaggerating but only this morning I had to go down to the reception of my building to hand in three stray letters that had made their way into our mailbox and instead of saying:
"These letters don't belong to anyone in my flat."
"I said there is no one living with me with these names"
but I didn't get through the whole sentence so it was more like,
"There's no one with these names."
spectacularly untrue and not to mention sounds a bit like a murderer.  It also took me at least three attempts to get half the sentence out.  And the sole reason for this awkward repertoire is because if I don't think of what to say before I say it, I don't say anything reasonable at all.  Course introductions were the worst and as we were going through everyone, instead of listening to them I was formulating and practicing how to introduce myself.  That's right I have to think about saying;
"I'm Wren, I'm from Scotland and I studied Statistics".  It gets worse with presentations but more on that later in the year.

So when people stop me in the street or comment on something random, or about me, I literally mumble back, and that's on a good day, otherwise, which is most of the time, I smile and laugh.  They could be insulting me and I would just grin like an idiot and quicken my pace.
I am actually ok with directions, if I know where they're asking about, but otherwise you can forget it.

As for the most recent incident.  One Saturday morning (this morning actually) I was walking into Leicester city centre early to get breakfast, which I do every Saturday.  I was just walking, chilling, stomach rumbling hungrily, listening to my music, when this man sweeping up the leaves outside of a small hairdressers saw me and began to laugh.  He was just on the corner that I wanted to use and he spotted me from at least 8 metres away.  I will admit, my music was louder than usual and the only reason I know this is because when he did say something to me I couldn't hear a word he was saying.
It was quite cold this morning, especially at the time I go out at, so I was wearing my favourite scarf which has robins on it.  He spotted me and began to laugh, then kept taking regular glances in my direction no doubt to log my progressive walk to within hearing distance where he would then spout his well formulated comment about my pretty scarf.  Until my dying day I will never piece together what he said but the only words I heard were;
"....wearing...scarf......*laugh/creepy chuckle*"
There was this younger man/boy (I couldn't tell what age he was) leaning in the doorway and he also joined in whatever the older sweeping man said that was so funny.  I just did my usual and smiled awkwardly.
Running away is one thing, but folks, always make sure there is an alternative way back, which for me there wasn't.  I literally dreaded going past that corner on my way back from breakfast as I was buying the damn thing in the shop.  Needless to say I ran past that hairdressers.

Earphones.  They come in all shapes and sizes, and this meme I found perhaps explains a little better why people speak to me when I have mine in.
I do have the ones in the second window but they are reserved for the house since I'm not allowed speakers, nor do I want to share my alternative taste in music with my flatmates through the paper thin walls here.  Sometimes I think it's your facial expression, and from my Dad I'm told I go around with a "face as though I've been sucking lemons".

To be honest if I look as cute as that cat I don't blame people for stopping me.  But as it stands I'm pretty sure I look worse than this:
Perhaps that's just mine and my dad's perception because believe me, when I'm walking trough a large crowd of people, I'm not happy.  So why do strangers insist on stopping me and asking for directions, or feeling the need to talk to me as they see me passing by?

Perhaps I'm being too pessimistic and grumpy about this.  Humans are by nature social creatures, and even I get the occasional urge for some company, but how does talking to a stranger fulfil this need?  It just does sometimes; I understand that.  When I first moved into this flat I wasn't that homesick but I was full of foreboding and anxiety; how was I going to survive?  What if I made no new friends on my course?  Then the day after I arrived I was making dinner when one of my flatmates came in and we talked for a few hours and at the end I felt so much better.  Sometimes company is the best thing, and although I sit and type rants about awkward social interactions, I actually love the time I spend with my friends and I love that my life has these awkward moments that I can share for a few laughs with them.

I would like others to observe the wearing of the headphones as a sign that the person wearing them doesn't want to banter or talk to anyone except when they're buying things.  Unfortunately for those socially awkward people out there like me, I'm afraid that will never happen and we will just keep mumbling to strangers and smiling awkwardly having no idea what they're saying.  I suppose that's just life.