Showing posts with label independence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label independence. Show all posts

Sunday, 18 January 2015

History Sunday: Isobel of Mar, and Elizabeth de Burgh

Quite a random History Sunday this week I'm afraid, folks; I was having trouble choosing a topic, just like I was last week.  I contemplated Henry II, but I get the feeling that will be a three post segment at least.

There are two women I will be focusing on in this History Sunday, both are the wives of King Robert I of Scotland, commonly known as Robert the Bruce.  Everyone (well almost everyone) knows Robert the Bruce, he was one of the only men I was actually taught about in my history class at school from the middle ages (William Wallace, of course, being the other one).  Both men fought during the Wars of Scottish Independence from England during the 13th and 14th centuries.  Wallace was killed, whilst Bruce managed to wrangle the Scottish throne away from the English and regain independence (ish).

I think history likes to give Wallace a reputation for being just an ordinary fellow, a classic average Joe turned national hero story to tell the children, but in reality Wallace was a landowner in his own right.  Unfortunately I've become bored of Wallace's place in history, he's just been so overused for everything Scotland orientated.  So has Robert the Bruce on some level, but not the women behind the glory and fables.

Isobel of Mar (commonly known in English as Isabella, in Gaelic as Iseabail).  I translated her name this way because Isobel is the modern Scottish spelling of the Gaelic for whatever origins that overused name has (and because in my mind the name Isabella will be forever placed at Isabella of France's feet, even though that wasn't actually her name either).  Isobel was the daughter of the Earl of Mar, Domhnall I, and his wife Helen, or Ellen, who was the illegitimate daughter of Llewelyn ap Iowerth, Prince of Wales.  There isn't really much to read about poor Isobel.  One of the interesting things is that she and Robert were apparently in love when they married, the reason for the match was that her father thought that Bruce was the rightful Scottish King, and so by making an alliance with him solidified his family's position in Scotland (he must have been confident Bruce could claim the throne from the English).  She was 18 at the time of her marriage (is it just me or is anyone else thinking this was quite old for a young woman of the nobility?  I'm so used to pre-pubescent brides).  Soon after she became pregnant and gave birth to her one and only child, a daughter, Marjorie, who would go onto have Robert II, the founder of the Stuart/Stewart Kings.  She died before Robert was ever crowned King of Scots and so Isobel never gained the title Queen, and her father's hopes were no doubt a little disappointed.

Six years after the death of his first wife Bruce married his second and final wife, Elizabeth de Burgh.  She was the daughter of Richard Og de Burgh, Earl of Ulster, and his wife, simply referred to as Margarite.  Elizabeth married Bruce in 1302 when she was 13 years old (she was actually born on Scottish soil in Dunfermline, Fife).  In 1306 Bruce had a good control of power in Scotland and was crowned King of Scots in 1306, Elizabeth was crowned Queen at this point as well.  Bruce did this despite the fact that the English hadn't given up their claims to Scotland (typical Scottish f***k you to the English if you ask me).  Unfortunately, as with most victories during a warring period, this triumphant patch was short lived.

The women of the Bruce family had a hard time during the Scottish wars of independence, whether they were born into it or married.  I always find reading about what happened to them awful.  The Scottish army was defeated by the English force at Methven in 1306.  The Queen, Marjorie Bruce (her stepdaughter), and her husband's two sisters Mary and Christine/Christian fled to Kildrummy castle where they came under siege by the English army.

When the castle fell (due to a blacksmith with fragile loyalty when it came to money) all men, including Bruce's brother Nigel, were hanged and killed; the women had already fled under the escort of the Earl of Atholl.  The ladies were eventually found by the English, or rather handed over by another traitor sensing the tides were changing.  Mary Bruce and Isabella MacDuff (Countess of Buchan) were put in wooden cages which hung from the walls of Roxburgh and Berwick castles.  Marjorie Bruce and her Aunt Christine were sent to separate nunneries, and Elizabeth was placed under house arrest.  The Earl of Atholl, the ladies' escort, was killed and his head was displayed at the Tower of London (as they usually are during this time).  She was moved around castles and other properties for eight years until in 1314 she was returned to Scotland.

Elizabeth bore Bruce four children, only three of whom survived to adulthood.  Margaret, married the 5th Earl of Sutherland, and had issue.  Matilda, married Thomas Isaac and had issue (two daughters).  John (b.1327) died the same day he was born,  Finally, David, King of Scotland until 1372, married Joan of the Tower, a daughter of Edward II and Isabella of France.

Elizabeth died in October 1327 and is buried in, come on you can guess, Dunfermline.  Bruce died a mere 18 months later.

To tell you the fates of the other Bruce women captured by the English:
Mary Bruce (Robert's sister) was released back to Scotland during an exchange of prisoners after the Battle of Bannockburn where the English were defeated.  She married twice, once to Sir Neil Campbell, and had a son, and secondly to Alexander Fraser, but had no recorded issue.

Christine Bruce (Robert's other sister) was released back to Scotland, no doubt at the same time as the other women.  She married firstly Sir Christopher Seton, who was executed in 1306, and then Sir Andrew Murray.

Marjorie Bruce was released at the same time as Elizabeth, she had been kept at Watton Priory since her capture.  She married Walter Stewart, 6th High Stewart of Scotland, who had distinguished himself.  After David II of Scotland died childless, her son, Robert, became King of Scotland after him, beginning the Stewart dynasty of Scottish, and subsequently English, Kings.

That's it for these unfortunate Bruce women, and Isobel of Mar.  I'll need to think hard this week about what my next segment is going to be about, it's been very Scotland orientated for the last few ones, maybe I'll tackle the illustrious Henry II.

Sunday, 23 November 2014

History Sunday: Dunfermline Abbey

Welcome to my History Sunday blogpost.  As my approximately 4 frequent readers know I am Scottish and frighteningly proud of being so.  Ever since I moved down to England it seems I have become more Scottish; answering questions with aye, and improving my accent.  For this history Sunday I really wanted to write about a Scottish historical figure, not the usual ones like William Wallace or Robert the Bruce, but preferably a queen.  I also thought about doing a history of Scotland one but I would be writing pages until the end of time.  Scotland only became Scotland in the 11th century and even then what we know now as Scotland is different from the first kingdom of Scotland.  I looked at the queens consort list and wanted to write about Saint Maragaret of Scotland; unfortunately she is English, more specifically a daughter of the Earl of Wessex.  When I looked at the list I realised that most of the medieval Queen consorts of Scotland have been English, or French.  There are about three who were Scottish, daughters of Scotland's nobles, but there is sparse information on them that would take barely a paragraph to write up.  It saddened me that I didn't know anything about the historical figures of Scotland; I don't know anything about Scotland during the middle ages and I can name every English monarch from the 11th century to the 17th but no Scottish ones.


To placate the huge disappointment this realisation was I decided on Dunfermline Abbey.  I travel a lot during the summer, going to see this castle and that castle, and on my bucket list for Scotland was the famous Dunfermline Abbey, resting place of the kings, Queens, and royals of Scotland.  I went to this place during the summer of 2014 and as self-appointed ambassador for Scottish heritage sites getting to it is easy; there's a train stop called Dunfermline Town, which you can get to from Edinburgh Haymarket, on a Scotrail line; alight at this station and follow the signposts, or your phone's GPS, until you reach the Abbey which is on the way to the main town centre.  It's probably easier by car.

At this point I'd also like to mention that every picture on this post was taken by yours truly during my visit, no pinterest or google images, I promise.

The Abbey was supposedly originally founded by King Máel Coluim mac Donnchada, or King Malcolm Canmore of Alba (Scotland in Gaelic), and his wife Saint Margaret of Scotland who I mentioned above.  When I went to Edinburgh Castle I was told of Saint Margaret and how she was a very pious woman and this apparently rubbed off on her husband, and it certainly did to her children who were also either cannonised or admired for their piety by chroniclers.  One of their daughters was the wife of King Henry I of England, and their sons became Kings of Alba.
The knave, pictured on the left, is actually the oldest part of the Abbey dating to the 12th Century..  Apparently the Abbey claimed that Saint Margaret was its founder and forged an earlier foundation charter than David I's reign.  King Malcolm and his wife did found something here but it's unclear whether it was the Abbey or just a church.  Dunfermline Abbey became the centre point for the growing cult of Saint Margaret, Scotland's only cannonised royal.  This would have meant a lot of money coming in and so obviously the monks in residence here would have wanted people to keep thinking Saint Margaret founded it therefore forging the charter.

The Benedictine Abbey of the Holy Trinity and Saint Margaret (Dunfermline Abbey) was actually founded by their son King David I in 1128.
Dunfermline Abbey kept standing through the relatively calm years from its founding until the 13th Century when, you guessed it, Edward I stormed his way across the border during the Scottish War of Independence.  He held court at the Abbey in 1303 and then when he left he burned down the buildings.  I don't understand this act.  Edward I was a pious king, Dunfermline was a chartered Abbey with a Saint and numerous kings of Scotland buried in it, did he not fear the wrath of God would come down upon him for effectively destroying a holy place?  Perhaps it was because the kings were buried there that he partially destroyed it.  Nevertheless the Abbey kept standing even after the English were gone.

What I really want at this moment in the post is the guidebook I bought when I was there because it has so much information about this time and about life at the Abbey, but it's at home an I'm in Leicester so apologies.

Let's jump to the Scottish Reformation.  I know nothing about this; I only know about it in England but along those same lines Scotland joined in.  For those who don't know the English Reformation happened around the 1530s and was instigated by Henry VIII of England so he could marry Anne Boleyn.  The Catholic church wouldn't grant a divorce to Henry from his then wife, the poor Katherine of Aragon, and so he broke with Rome, made himself the head of the English church, divorced Katherine in this new religion and married Anne Boleyn, much to her ill fate.  And so began Protestantism.  Because Scotland and England have always been so geographically close, we share a common-ish culture, and our kings married daughters of the kings of England, it was only a matter of time before this new religion came over the border. 
The ruins of Dunfermline Palace

The Scottish Reformation happened in 1560 and banned Mass, etc, and made way for Protestantism.  This would be a very definitive blow against Marie de Guise, effective ruler of Scotland, and her Catholic daughter, the incompetent Mary, Queen of Scots.  Mary was the great-grandaughter of King Henry VII of England through his daughter, Margaret Tudor.  She was shipped off to France when she was very young to marry the Dauphin of France, the heir to the throne, leaving a regent to rule Scotland, and this burden eventually fell to her French mother, Marie de Guise, a catholic.
John Knox was the leader of the Scottish reformation and forced the issue in the wake of Marie de Guises death in early 1560.  Queen Mary didn't arrive in Scotland until 1561.
As all the Abbeys were sacked in England, so they were in Scotland, and one day in March 1560 the Abbey was sacked.
It was rebuilt, in part, in 1570, and reopened for worship in 1821, a huge gap, I know.  It has been extensively restored in the interim between those two periods, but it hadn't been completely destroyed to begin with anyway.  It is now a sight of historical importance as it is, save Iona, the place of the most Scottish Royal burials.  According to the Abbey these people are buried there, although when I was there I must have been looking in the wrong place because I didn't see any grave markers at all.  I do know that they will have been destroyed during the reformation but apparently Saint Margaret and her husband King Malcolm's tomb was restored on the orders of Queen Victoria in the 19th century.
Royals: Malcolm Canmore, Saint Margaret and their sons; Duncan II, Edgar, Alexander I and his wife Sybilla of Normandy, and David I with his wife Maud of Huntingdon.  
Malcolm IV, Alexander III, his wife Margaret of England, and their sons David and Alexander.  Robert the Bruce.
The wives and family members of some kings are also buried there but the full list is on Wikipedia if you're interested.

Dunfermline Palace is also adjoining the Abbey and is a ruin now also; has probably always been there in one form or another and was used to house royal and important guest when they visited the Abbey, it's the only part of the place you have to pay to get into, but it's not steep and the views are excellent.  King Charles I was born in Dunfermline Palace because his mother, Anna of Denmark and wife of King James VI of Scotland, lived in the palace at that time.  When James became King of England after the death of Elizabeth I in 1603 the palace fell into disrepair and ruin, which can still be seen today.

It doesn't take long to go around the Abbey and the Palace, but the inside is breathtaking, as all Abbeys are, and the views are amazing too especially if it's a good day like it was when I visited.  Dunfermline town is also just behind the Abbey so you can go for lunch and some shopping afterwards.  A nice day out overall and it is amazing to know you're walking in the same space as some of the most vibrant of Scotland's kings.

Friday, 19 September 2014

A Historic Day for Scotland......?

The people of Scotland have voted No to independence.  I think the overall vote wasn't really a surprise but there has been little surprises following the publication of the breakdown of areas.  The one that personally surprised me was that Glasgow, the largest city in Scotland, had a majority of yes votes.  I am a Glaswegian born and raised, I have walked around the streets since the campaigns got into full swing, why am I so surprised at this result?  I honestly don't know but it did frighten me a little.

I think people spoke about the result of the referendum more today than any other day; that is what happened for me as with my parents and friends that subject dominated the conversation, but what is there to talk about now that the nation has voted?  Westminster and the current government have been enticing no voters with promise of more ambiguous powers, but nowhere have they stated what these powers are.  People are no getting anxious that they are already reneging on these promises but is it really such a surprise?  Politicians are notorious for saying they will do this and that and then never doing it; this situation wasn't really any different.

I do understand the reasons why the yes voters wished for independence, more autonomy is needed for Scotland, but splitting from the UK was a very extreme way to get it.  On the other hand, how easy is it going to be for Holyrood to gain more powers?

The voting may be over, the decision in, the rumours that fraud went on behind the counting scenes rife, but the debate for Scotland's future in the UK is far from over.

That being said, the politicians will bicker amongst themselves, normal folk who are politically inclined will continue to debate and discuss, but the average joe walking down the street will continue with life because that's what average life is, isn't it?

Saturday, 13 September 2014

Scottish Independence: A somewhat ignorant view

This will probably be one of those posts that will get many views in the next few days as the voting day draws nearer and although I've already cast my vote and every time I step outside of my house there is someone waiting to give me a leaflet, I never really thought about adding it to my blog; unusually so since I am proud of my Scottish-ness.

As a Scottish Resident, National, and native please believe me when I say that although the voting day is this week I have been hearing about the Independence Referendum for at least two years, probably more and my mind has always been made up on the matter but I will leave my opinion till the end, although it may become obvious as I continue to write.  Now that the decision day is nearing us the armies of 'Yes' and 'No thanks' are out in force on every shopping and busy area of Scotland, but since I live in Glasgow, the largest city in our fair country, I can only speak about my experiences here.  First let's start with my somewhat ignorant overview of the arguments.

Yes?  This campaign is headed by Alexander Salmond, MP patriot who is part of the SNP (Scottish National Party), which to me seems to be the Scottish version of the BNP who as their name suggests are very pro-Britain.  He has a second in command, Nicola Sturgeon, although I don't know much about either of them.  They have been shouting, ranting and debating in their rough Scottish burrs for the last few years about how Scotland and Britain are 'Better Apart', although this is just a play on the 'No thanks' campaign tagline.  They have been running with this Scottish Independence thing for years, holding debates, opinion polls and no doubt lectures, handing out leaflets, guidebooks and supposed future plans, but after all that it doesn't seem as though they really have any future plans at all, and no solid foundation with which to nurture Scotland as an independent country.  Yes, we have oil, but doesn't that run out?  According to the 'yes' voters and campaigners Scotland has energy that we can sell for money, but to this day I have only ever heard of the oil; a few whispers about wave technology, but I feel a bit shaky on the details.
They promise we will keep the pound, fair enough, but that comes with its own set of problems.  They promise they will spend money on schools, healthcare and all of these other things, and that's great, not typical of political parties in the slightest, but where are you getting the money to pay for all of these nice things?  Britain has just come out of debt, things still aren't stable economically, and you're going to spend to improve?  If Scotland comes out of Britain we will also have to shoulder our own debts, which if you keep spending as you like will be large enough to sink us before the melting ice caps do.  Everyone has doubts economically about an Independent Scotland, but it seems to me that the words the MPs are saying is just wind with no solid foundation or proof; oil will run out, and that seems to be the only solid way of supporting ourselves.  That's the thing with the 'yes' campaign, everything seems unclear, not quite in focus, fueled by ideologies rather than hard core figures, and as a Statistician I like numbers.
On the other hand, I agree that being ruled by London isn't always great.  We had the poll tax first, Scotland's taxes are higher in general, and things are done up here according to the London way when it probably shouldn't be.  On the same line though, we have a completely different education system from England, our NHS is also slightly different and even our University system is slightly different.  In Britain Scottish students get their fees paid for them by the Government and we have four years and not three at Uni.  Living in Scotland doesn't feel, to me, as though we are hard done to because most of our laws are passed in London rather than Edinburgh's Holyrood.  Yes, we are disadvantaged in things, but we are also advantaged in things too, so for me it kind of balances out.

No?  There feels as if there's a lot more fuel behind the no campaign because in the end, who really likes change?  If we stay in the UK we keep the pound, the Queen and the uncertain stability of a joint nation; we're chained to England, Wales and Northern Ireland and we go through the ups and downs together, united.  Not to say that if we go independent we won't still be allies and friends, but it'll be different.  That's not to say that if we stay in the UK things won't change, Salmond won't give up that easily and next will be the fight for more autonomy from London Westminster, which I am fully on board with.  No seems like a better, safer choice because there isn't really any risk in it because we lose nothing.  Unfortunately I feel there isn't much else to say about the no campaign because it's pretty self-explanatory; things are safer on the 'no thanks' side.

On a personal level I'm more concerned about what it will do to the relations between Scotland and England on a people level rather than a policy one.  As almost everyone in western civilisation knows we haven't exactly had the best working relationship in history and it's only recently, in the past few hundred years or so, that things have gotten better.  Already English people are getting sick of it with the nation divided on their opinions; some don't care if we stay or go, others don't want to pamper after Scotland and are a few days from telling us to F*** off, and others want us to stay.  Salmond and his second in command have successfully divided the population of not one nation but two.  Although I get to vote in this referendum I won't be in Scotland to reap the ultimate decision as I'm moving down to England for University, but that's also worrying me.  If we go independent won't there be more bad blood between Scottish and English people?  If I, a Scotswoman, goes down to England after my country just said "jog on, England" how will that affect the reception I receive?  Selfish way of thinking, I know, but policies and politics have been for politicians, the consequences are for individuals like the average Joe walking down the street.

There are many things I haven't mentioned in this blog post but it's already long enough as it is and also it's because I confess to being completely ignorant of all the silly details.  This was never intended to be an unbiased account of the Referendum but so I don't get any haters of my fresh new blog I won't say what my actual vote is.  I understand the reasons behind the independence vote, I also agree that Scotland, as a nation, should have more political autonomy because although we are similar to England, we are not the same and we have different needs.
At this point in time I don't think anyone knows definitely which way this vote is going to swing, but in true Scottish style it will be a fierce fight till the bitter end.