Showing posts with label heroes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label heroes. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 February 2015

History Sunday: Edinburgh

Last week I trekked most of the way up the country to go home.  What trip to Scotland is complete without another trek across to Edinburgh, the beautiful capital?  There is a traditional rivalry between Glasgow and Edinburgh, but I think rather than comparing them it's better to enjoy the unique experiences both have to offer.

Edinburgh is older than Glasgow, and has held a somewhat more important purpose in Scotland's history, and that's what this History Sunday post is focusing on.  When Glasgow was nothing but a settlement outside of the Cathedral, Edinburgh was home to Kings and Queens, and the government, a position it still holds today.

On my trip to Edinburgh, I went to see the castle, which I've actually only visited about once before.  I know, who goes to Edinburgh and doesn't see the infamous castle?  It's a bit of a tourist trap, obviously.  It's like going to the Tower of London, or Madam Tussaud's in the UK capital, for a lot of people the enjoyment is taken away by the sheer number of people being herded around.  I would love to wander around Edinburgh without having to navigate my way through a group of Americans, or avoiding the camera lenses of the Chinese tour.  Unfortunately I didn't have that privilege this time and so you also get to see the other tourists.

The Edinburgh Castle the world knows today is relatively modern, and still used as an army Barracks, but the sight has been used since the Iron Age.  It won't surprise people to know that the rock it's built on is volcanic, but fear not those who still want to go and visit, it won't erupt any time soon.  It's obvious from every picture you see of this grand castle that the rock is not just another Great Glen, and it dominates every picture of Edinburgh; the views are amazing.

The earliest source mentioning Edinburgh was Ptolemy's map in the 2nd Century, this area belonged to the Votadini tribe and is recorded as Alauna, which means rocky place.  As with many things from this early on his history there are many legends surrounding this piece of land, and the legendary kings, and if you're interested some quick Googling should be better then me.  I did listen to the audioguide but I'm afraid history this early in Scotland doesn't really interest me, so let's skip ahead.

The next recorded name of Edinburgh was in the 7th Century, and now this piece of land was called "Din Eidyn" in a Welsh poem.  The tale in the poem is about a King of Goddodin (what the Eastern part of Scotland was called during this period in time) and his warriors who feasted before riding off to battle with the Angles of what is now England, and being subsequently slaughtered in the act.  A cheery poem.  After the real defeat of the warriors of Goddodin Edinburgh became part of the lands of the Kingdom of Northumbria, one of the seven other kingdoms of the English heptarchy that came to be in the centuries following the Roman departure from Britain.  By the tenth century Northumbria had been united into England, and hence Edinburgh along with it.  According to the audioguide it was after the Goddodin defeat by the Northumbrians that "Din Eidyn" became Edinburgh, and has remained to this day.  To give you a better idea Burgh is an Anglo-Saxon word and doesn't originate from Scotland or any of the languages that has ever been spoken here.  "Gow" on the end of Glasgow, Linlithgow, etc, is a word with Scottish origins and means hollow, or dip.

Unfortunately information from this period comes from middens excavated on the site, and so is sparse, as you can imagine.  The next we hear from the castle is in the 11th Century after the death of the legendary King Malcolm III.  He was the first Scottish King I truly learned about during my travels, and his wife, the illustrious Saint Margaret.  I've briefly spoken about both in my post about Dunfermline Abbey, where she's buried.

Edinburgh Castle hasn't always been called this, and during St Margaret's lifetime it was known as the Castle of Maidens; she was here when she learnt of the death of her husband, Malcolm.  The origin of this name is a mystery that has a few origins in the various chronicles of history, but is was used frequently until the 17th Century.

It was Malcolm and Margaret's son, good ol' King David, that developed Edinburgh and planted the roots for its future importance in the fate of Scotland.  In my opinion it was the first call of anyone wanting to invade Scotland, due to its significance within the royal family.  Wallace and Edward III fought over it, Cromwell marched all the way across the border to destroy it; in fact it's been demolished and rebuilt so many times in its history I'm surprised it doesn't look more like Linlithgow Palace, nothing but a shell of its former glory, literally.
thanks to the panoramic mode on my phone
The oldest building still standing, intact, inside of the walls is St Margaret's chapel which dates from the 11th Century; dedicated to David's mother.  It is small, no more than ten people can fit inside at once, if I remember correctly, but is is lovely; and for those of you who're getting married soon you can have the ceremony in this little chapel, and then the reception at the castle as well.

The castle was destroyed by William Wallace during the Wars of Independence, his thought was that if the Scots couldn't storm and keep it, then the English couldn't have it.  It's been rebuilt since and King James VI and I of Scotland and England, respectively, was born in a tiny room here, which you can still visit today.  There is a War memorial inside of the walls which I didn't go in, and also the Scottish crown jewels (that's right, we have our own separate set) are kept here for people to take a look.

Edinburgh Castle has a long and bloody history that is just too rich to go through in this post.  Much blood was spilled, many buildings destroyed, and many births, deaths, marriages, romances, hatreds, and history came to pass here.  If you ever do get a chance Edinburgh is a must, although it's always busy and so hardly needs my ambassadorial skill.  I think the amazing Fudge Kitchen shop might, at the opposite end of the Royal Mile from the castle, but definitely worth the wander down (I don't like fudge but I eat the stuff they make).  A tour-guide, or even the audio-guide, will do a much better job than I have of informing you about Edinburgh's long history, or even just Wikipedia.

Sunday, 18 January 2015

History Sunday: Isobel of Mar, and Elizabeth de Burgh

Quite a random History Sunday this week I'm afraid, folks; I was having trouble choosing a topic, just like I was last week.  I contemplated Henry II, but I get the feeling that will be a three post segment at least.

There are two women I will be focusing on in this History Sunday, both are the wives of King Robert I of Scotland, commonly known as Robert the Bruce.  Everyone (well almost everyone) knows Robert the Bruce, he was one of the only men I was actually taught about in my history class at school from the middle ages (William Wallace, of course, being the other one).  Both men fought during the Wars of Scottish Independence from England during the 13th and 14th centuries.  Wallace was killed, whilst Bruce managed to wrangle the Scottish throne away from the English and regain independence (ish).

I think history likes to give Wallace a reputation for being just an ordinary fellow, a classic average Joe turned national hero story to tell the children, but in reality Wallace was a landowner in his own right.  Unfortunately I've become bored of Wallace's place in history, he's just been so overused for everything Scotland orientated.  So has Robert the Bruce on some level, but not the women behind the glory and fables.

Isobel of Mar (commonly known in English as Isabella, in Gaelic as Iseabail).  I translated her name this way because Isobel is the modern Scottish spelling of the Gaelic for whatever origins that overused name has (and because in my mind the name Isabella will be forever placed at Isabella of France's feet, even though that wasn't actually her name either).  Isobel was the daughter of the Earl of Mar, Domhnall I, and his wife Helen, or Ellen, who was the illegitimate daughter of Llewelyn ap Iowerth, Prince of Wales.  There isn't really much to read about poor Isobel.  One of the interesting things is that she and Robert were apparently in love when they married, the reason for the match was that her father thought that Bruce was the rightful Scottish King, and so by making an alliance with him solidified his family's position in Scotland (he must have been confident Bruce could claim the throne from the English).  She was 18 at the time of her marriage (is it just me or is anyone else thinking this was quite old for a young woman of the nobility?  I'm so used to pre-pubescent brides).  Soon after she became pregnant and gave birth to her one and only child, a daughter, Marjorie, who would go onto have Robert II, the founder of the Stuart/Stewart Kings.  She died before Robert was ever crowned King of Scots and so Isobel never gained the title Queen, and her father's hopes were no doubt a little disappointed.

Six years after the death of his first wife Bruce married his second and final wife, Elizabeth de Burgh.  She was the daughter of Richard Og de Burgh, Earl of Ulster, and his wife, simply referred to as Margarite.  Elizabeth married Bruce in 1302 when she was 13 years old (she was actually born on Scottish soil in Dunfermline, Fife).  In 1306 Bruce had a good control of power in Scotland and was crowned King of Scots in 1306, Elizabeth was crowned Queen at this point as well.  Bruce did this despite the fact that the English hadn't given up their claims to Scotland (typical Scottish f***k you to the English if you ask me).  Unfortunately, as with most victories during a warring period, this triumphant patch was short lived.

The women of the Bruce family had a hard time during the Scottish wars of independence, whether they were born into it or married.  I always find reading about what happened to them awful.  The Scottish army was defeated by the English force at Methven in 1306.  The Queen, Marjorie Bruce (her stepdaughter), and her husband's two sisters Mary and Christine/Christian fled to Kildrummy castle where they came under siege by the English army.

When the castle fell (due to a blacksmith with fragile loyalty when it came to money) all men, including Bruce's brother Nigel, were hanged and killed; the women had already fled under the escort of the Earl of Atholl.  The ladies were eventually found by the English, or rather handed over by another traitor sensing the tides were changing.  Mary Bruce and Isabella MacDuff (Countess of Buchan) were put in wooden cages which hung from the walls of Roxburgh and Berwick castles.  Marjorie Bruce and her Aunt Christine were sent to separate nunneries, and Elizabeth was placed under house arrest.  The Earl of Atholl, the ladies' escort, was killed and his head was displayed at the Tower of London (as they usually are during this time).  She was moved around castles and other properties for eight years until in 1314 she was returned to Scotland.

Elizabeth bore Bruce four children, only three of whom survived to adulthood.  Margaret, married the 5th Earl of Sutherland, and had issue.  Matilda, married Thomas Isaac and had issue (two daughters).  John (b.1327) died the same day he was born,  Finally, David, King of Scotland until 1372, married Joan of the Tower, a daughter of Edward II and Isabella of France.

Elizabeth died in October 1327 and is buried in, come on you can guess, Dunfermline.  Bruce died a mere 18 months later.

To tell you the fates of the other Bruce women captured by the English:
Mary Bruce (Robert's sister) was released back to Scotland during an exchange of prisoners after the Battle of Bannockburn where the English were defeated.  She married twice, once to Sir Neil Campbell, and had a son, and secondly to Alexander Fraser, but had no recorded issue.

Christine Bruce (Robert's other sister) was released back to Scotland, no doubt at the same time as the other women.  She married firstly Sir Christopher Seton, who was executed in 1306, and then Sir Andrew Murray.

Marjorie Bruce was released at the same time as Elizabeth, she had been kept at Watton Priory since her capture.  She married Walter Stewart, 6th High Stewart of Scotland, who had distinguished himself.  After David II of Scotland died childless, her son, Robert, became King of Scotland after him, beginning the Stewart dynasty of Scottish, and subsequently English, Kings.

That's it for these unfortunate Bruce women, and Isobel of Mar.  I'll need to think hard this week about what my next segment is going to be about, it's been very Scotland orientated for the last few ones, maybe I'll tackle the illustrious Henry II.

Wednesday, 10 December 2014

Travelling Scot: Nottingham

So I mentioned in one of my previous posts that I spent last Friday in Nottingham after having completed all of my coursework; to be honest even if I hadn't I still would have gone.  The night before I charged up my phone, I spent too long on Google maps, and I planned my day so I wouldn't be disappointed.  The three attractions, well if you count a church as an attraction, were St Mary's, the Galleries of Justice, and of course, Nottingham Castle.  The city name, Nottingham, comes from Snota inga ham, Saxon for village belonging to Snota, or Snot, who was a Saxon chieftain.

There was no particular reason why I went to the Galleries of justice, I've rarely written about the law in the 19th century, in fact I've rarely written about the 19th Century at all until recently and even then it's set in Glasgow, but the law is different in Scotland; to put it a charming and very official way, we have Scots Law that is independent of England and Wales, and Ireland.  That being said it was a most enjoyable visit and very informative in case I ever did want to write about it.  It was the first thing I went to see because they have a lot of school trips during the week and so the first thing I did when I got off the train, and followed my GPS a potential mugging way, was go and book my own tour at 12.30.  This gave me roughly 2 hours to look at the castle and the church.

For those of you who haven't been in Nottingham they seem to have jumped on board this fetish with bringing the trams back into major cities.  I've seen them in Manchester and Birmingham but have never been on one, and Edinburgh made such a disaster of theirs that there's not really any point in going on them.  In hindsight I should have jumped on it into town instead of nearly getting lost with my GPS, that being said I wouldn't have known what stop to get off at and would have got lost anyway.  Needless to say I got one back to the station but more on that later.

Thankfully St Mary's church is practically right beside the Galleries of Justice.
So I walked to the very front of the church, which is rarely where the actual entrance is these days, took a few snaps here and there, read that the entrance was in the south porch, not unusual.  The place was really quiet because it's away from the main town centre and no one seemed to be walking past either.  My stomach was talking to me and instead of looking around in wonderment I should have eaten the cereal bar in my bag but I didn't, and more fool me for not.  I found the porch it was talking about and when I entered I found the door on the below right.  Looks pretty solid, and more importantly closed doesn't it?  My heart sank.  This was the oldest church in Nottingham, built in the 14th century as an improvement to one that had already been there and was reported in Domesday book, I really wanted to see inside.  I looked around at the noticeboards I didn't take a picture of to the left and right and found that it should be open.
Bravely....I mean gingerly I stepped towards the door, the heels of my boots thudding on the hollow ramp at my feet, and slowly I began to push on this door.  My God was it heavy, which is kind of obvious when you look at it.  It's the part on the right that opens and in I slipped, straight onto four people of the church having what looked to be an important meeting.
This is the thing about churches, anyone can just walk in.  To be honest the meeting was happening at the other side of the knave from the door, but because of the high ceilings and lovely echoing I would have a problem with a little later I could hear their mumblings and conversation.  I felt very conspicuous, as anyone does when they're the only guest in a church, or customer in a shop.  I walked around the side of the church, taking everything in, passing a man who was carrying the chairs into the knave.  No pews inside of this church, which now I think about it is weird although that thought didn't occur to me at the time.
I won't go into detail about the history of the church, mainly because I don't know anything about it.  There was no handy guidebook to tell me everything, only the occasional sign marking something of interest in the chapels or on the walls.
From what I can remember there isn't much left of the original masonry of the 14th century, but the stained glass window on the right is partly intact from then; you can kind of tell by the face near the top, definitely a medieval drawing.

Now as I was walking around the church my stomach decided to begin grumbling again and this is where my unfortunate run in with the echoing came in.  Yes, it's almost transcendent when you hear a choir sing, the voice of the reverend...minister....priest (? I'm not catholic, I don't know) carries all the way down the knave, but guess what, so does a grumbling tummy.  My stomach and I have had many embarrassing moments of a similar nature, mostly during a silent exam, many silent exams, but in a church is a first.  Thankfully there was no one around, well not many people around, to share in my embarrassment.

The painted ceiling was pretty (pictured on the right).  What I find interesting about churches is that they force people to look up, handy when God is meant to be in heaven.  Walking around in every day life no one ever looks up at buildings, or at people like me looking out of high windows at the tiny figures walking around, but it's different in a church.

I would definitely recommend St Mary's church for those of you who like medieval architecture, quiet and tranquil places, and just like churches in general.  Obviously if you're a Catholic, too.  And as is tradition when I go into a catholic church, I lit a candle at one of the chapels, and donated to the church's upkeep.

By this time I think I had about an hour and a half to find Nottingham castle, look around, and then get back to the Galleries of Justice.  I'm a stickler for time, if I have an appointment or somewhere to be I am constantly looking at my watch so I'm not late; this case was no different.  Rather than using my GPS to find my way from St Mary's to the castle the signposts were very helpful in pointing me in the right direction, which turned out to be a straight road practically.  Thanks Nottingham council.  The last time I used tourist signs I got lost in York, anti-thanks York council!
The castle isn't really a castle anymore, rather it's a stately home placed slap bang in the middle of a city.  It did used to be a castle, a proper one like everyone imagines, but it was destroyed, rebuilt, etc.  As a result I don't know much about the castle either, so Wikipedia will come to the rescue.  All I do remember off the top of my head was that Richard I besieged the castle with his brother, John, still in it.

During its medieval heyday it must have been quite something to behold, even now the views are breathtaking from "castle rock" where the mansion is built.  There used to be a keep situated on the spot where the ducal mansion now sits.
The first castle was built by William the Conqueror in 1067, built in stone under Henry II and remained grand and important throughout the centuries.  Edward III, whose reign I have the most knowledge about, began his own rule at this castle after he staged a coup against his mother and Roger Mortimer who had been acting as regents.
The current castle, or mansion, is your typical 18th century building, and houses an art gallery which was unfortunately closed the day I visited as they were making way for a new exhibit.  The views were the best thing about this castle for me, and I wish I had gone a little later when the sun came out and the clouds went away because when I went, as you can see, it was overcast in typical British style.





Actually before I even got into the castle I was waylaid by English people asking me to take a picture of them in front of the Robin Hood statue outside the castle walls.  They said it was for a team building exercise.  Before that I was asked for directions.  This isn't a rare occurrence for me, well the picture one was, but certainly not directions.  When I was visiting family in Carlisle I actually managed to point someone in the right direction and I had only been in the main city less than 30 minutes.  I must have one of those faces, I inherited it from my mother who can't go out of the house without being approached by a stranger.
Nottingham can't be mentioned without thinking of Robin Hood, and believe me the Nottingham tourism office has taken full advantage.  He is everywhere, statues, signs, merchandise.  It is a shame that he isn't real.

After I had taken in some fresh air at the castle and been awed by the views over the entire city I made my way back into town, did some light shopping, and by the time I was done realised I only had 20 minutes for lunch.  I beat one of my deepest social fears by walking into a busy Costa and having lunch on my own (I do eat on my own but I usually pick empty cafes and places, or I eat on a bench).  After wolfing down a nice toastie and an Orange, festive, hot chocolate, I made my way back to the Galleries of Justice.

I said in my previous post that I was asked to be a witness for the prosecution, and with my best Scottish accent I read the script.  The tour guide said he thought I was American when I first came in, I wonder at this since I didn't say a word to him.  I was with various other Europeans; Italian, Spanish and Brazilian, then the couple from Lincolnshire.  We walked around the prison/courtroom learning all about the horrors and injustice of 19th century law.  Apparently it's haunted, although I am impartial to a well written ghost story, I think they're solely reserved for the pages of a novel or short story, needless to say I never saw any ghosts.  Perhaps you will if you visit.
It was horrific to learn how bad the system was, but I have a feeling that only the truly awful stories and cases were illuminated for the visitor, even then I may just be being optimistic. Definitely worth a visit if you like passionate actors, and a run around an exercise yard.  I would also like to personally thank my first tour guide, the 19th Century usher, who gave me my new name for this blog.

After coming from the Galleries of Justice I had about an hour to kill before I needed to be back in the train station.  There had been a sign post to the old market, or market square, and I wanted to go and see it.  What should I stumble upon but a Christmas market!  I was so happy and it was such a good end to a brilliant day.  In Glasgow the Christmas Market, or German market as it used to be called, is there from December onwards and it really does help you get in the christmas mood.  Leicester doesn't have one and so the only Christmas I get is a thorntons smiley face from my advent calender and the speciality disposable cups you get from Cafe Nero and Costa.  I can't even have a speciality drink because they're too sweet for me, and I've also had to cut out caffeine from my life.  After this week is over ( my last week of the semester, yay!) I will endeavor to ask them to put less syrup in my drink and then it will be Christmas.

I didn't buy anything at the market, mostly because the food makes me cringe.  I did get a decaf latte from the Costa though and after that it was tram time!  I know it's childish of me but I really wanted to ride in a tram.  I had seen them in these cities, waited patiently and without reward for them in Edinburgh, but I'd never been on one.  It was expensive.  There was two stops between me at the market and the train station, a single was £2.10, it would have been cheaper if I had a melon card (at least I think that was what it was called, like the Osyter card for London transport).  It was so fun, the other people must have thought I was a complete nut having just run away from the psychiatric ward, but I don't care, I never do.  The tram was fun and I would reccomend getting it from the station into town raher than walking.  For those of you who do it's the first or the second stop after the train station for the city centre.

I would recommend Nottingham because it was a really nice city and I had a good, relaxing day out.

Sunday, 30 November 2014

History Sunday: William the Conqueror, Duke of Normandy (I)

This post was spurred by a comment I read on pinterest when I was sifting through the pins.  William I of England was apparently "England's Hitler".......just.......what?  How can you possibly compare the first Norman King of England with a dictator who massacred millions of innocent people and terrorised the entirety of Europe for years?  Yes, the Conqueror wiped out the north of England in what can only be viewed as one of the biggest losses of patience in British history, but he was hardly Hitler.  I have to say I didn't realise I was as big a fan of the Duke until I saw this dreadful over-exaggerated, nonsensical and insensitive comment.  I don't think he was amazing, I'm not in love with him like I am the fictional portrayal of John of Gaunt, but I do admire William, and his wife Matilda of Flanders, greatly.  His life is something taken out of an epic fantasy novel where the hero just has a hard life from the very beginning.  Recently I have also purchased the novel "The conqueror" by Georgette Heyer, and I have read a biography about his wife, Matilda of Flanders; "Matilda" by Tracy Borman is definitely worth a read.

William of Normandy, called "The Bastard" by the understandably disgruntled Anglo-Saxon chronicle, was the illegitimate son of Duke Robert I of Normandy and a relatively obscure woman simply known as Herleva of Falaise.

The Dukes of Normandy traced their ancestry back to a man named in historical records as Rollo, a viking who began attacks on what is now Normandy and was appeased by the King of Western Francia (a part of modern day France) when he was given land to settle in, hence the word Normandy comes from "North men" or "those who came from the north".  William's father, Duke Robert I, remained unmarried in his lifetime but had two illegitimate children by different mothers.  A daughter, Adelaide of Normandy, married three times, and of course William became Duke after the untimely death of his father.  There is a very romantic story concerning Robert and Herleva which has no historical foundation and also which appears through physical evidence to be impossible.
It's said that when the young Duke Robert was at a castle in Falaise he spotted Herleva in the dyeing trenches in the courtyard (her father is thought to have been a tanner) and ordered her brought to him immediately (that's right, the good old days of men picking up women literally with a snap of their fingers).  According to a written source instead of being snuck in through the backdoor she demanded she be led in on horse though the front door, effectively telling everyone that she was his mistress.  I doubt this story because if that were true then surely she would have had more recorded children?  Not to mention surely some pious chronicler of the day would have written more about her?  Let's just say I'm only a romantic when I want to be.

William is reported to have been born in either 1027 or 1028 but because his mother and father were not married, his birth was not official, and so was't contemporaneously recorded.  Little is known about his early childhood as well because he was illegitimate.  It can probably be safely assumed he remained with his mother as would have been customary at the time.

Poor little William's harsh reality begins with his father's death in 1035.  Shortly before Duke Robert I left for Jerusalem as a sort of repentance, he named William, who would have been between  7 and 8, his heir.  The other nobles and important people must have thought this a precaution.  The Duke was 35, not young but not an old man by the time, and perhaps they held hope of him properly marrying on his return from Jerusalem.  It's always interesting to think what would have happened if things had turned out differently, if the Duke had returned from his journey.  William, illegitimate son, may have faded into anonymity, or have been an ally to any legitimate siblings he may have had, or perhaps even an enemy in hindsight of what we know of his temper and will.

As we all know by now this was not to be.  Duke Robert I of Normandy died in Nicaea in 1035 on the return journey of an illness of some kind.  William the Bastard was now Duke of Normandy and still a boy.

I think I can safely say that 11th Century Europe was a dangerous and somewhat barbaric place.  England may have been setttled for a few decades, but Scotland at this time was four separate kingdoms (a post about that later), and certainly France as we know it today was a dream of fools.  Normandy, as I've stated before, was given to Rollo and his descendants by the Kings of West Francia.  France, at this time, was split into Duchys and one Kingdom.  The names are still used today to identify provinces of France; Normandy was flanked by the Duchy of Brittany to the West, the Counts of Anjou to the south and the Kingdom of France to the East.  There were more southern Duchys that belonged to Dukes but I don't like over-complicating things.

It was a volatile mix and the Dukes of Normandy had a tempestuous relationship with their neighbours, and at times their own subordinates.  Wars were a thing of constancy, diplomacy and negotiation seemed to be a secondary tactic seldom used.  On the death of Duke Robert, a child inherited a dangerous Duchy, and of course what happens when a child inherits anything?  Greedy adults put their hands in as well.  What was the easiest way to claim Normandy?  Killing the helpless child and invading with your own armies.

I cannot imagine, however hard I try, what it must have been like for the young William constantly having to escape assassination attempts, observing as his loyal body guards, family members and retainers were all murdered in order to save his life.
When he ascended at first he had the support of a few powerful French men such as his great-uncle the Archbishop Robert of Rouen, and King Henry of France.  Unfortunately with the death of the Archbishop in 1037 there began a cycle of guardians being killed in quick succession.

1047 is the first time that the Duke is recorded fighting for his rights in Normandy.  Three powerful nobles in Normandy rebelled against the Duke, causing him to flee to the French Court and King Henry of France.  They came back together and quashed the rebellion.  This was to be the first of many rigorous battles that the Duke would partake in during his tenure as Duke of Normandy and later King of England.

William's story will continue in part II, out next Sunday.

Sunday, 23 November 2014

History Sunday: Dunfermline Abbey

Welcome to my History Sunday blogpost.  As my approximately 4 frequent readers know I am Scottish and frighteningly proud of being so.  Ever since I moved down to England it seems I have become more Scottish; answering questions with aye, and improving my accent.  For this history Sunday I really wanted to write about a Scottish historical figure, not the usual ones like William Wallace or Robert the Bruce, but preferably a queen.  I also thought about doing a history of Scotland one but I would be writing pages until the end of time.  Scotland only became Scotland in the 11th century and even then what we know now as Scotland is different from the first kingdom of Scotland.  I looked at the queens consort list and wanted to write about Saint Maragaret of Scotland; unfortunately she is English, more specifically a daughter of the Earl of Wessex.  When I looked at the list I realised that most of the medieval Queen consorts of Scotland have been English, or French.  There are about three who were Scottish, daughters of Scotland's nobles, but there is sparse information on them that would take barely a paragraph to write up.  It saddened me that I didn't know anything about the historical figures of Scotland; I don't know anything about Scotland during the middle ages and I can name every English monarch from the 11th century to the 17th but no Scottish ones.


To placate the huge disappointment this realisation was I decided on Dunfermline Abbey.  I travel a lot during the summer, going to see this castle and that castle, and on my bucket list for Scotland was the famous Dunfermline Abbey, resting place of the kings, Queens, and royals of Scotland.  I went to this place during the summer of 2014 and as self-appointed ambassador for Scottish heritage sites getting to it is easy; there's a train stop called Dunfermline Town, which you can get to from Edinburgh Haymarket, on a Scotrail line; alight at this station and follow the signposts, or your phone's GPS, until you reach the Abbey which is on the way to the main town centre.  It's probably easier by car.

At this point I'd also like to mention that every picture on this post was taken by yours truly during my visit, no pinterest or google images, I promise.

The Abbey was supposedly originally founded by King Máel Coluim mac Donnchada, or King Malcolm Canmore of Alba (Scotland in Gaelic), and his wife Saint Margaret of Scotland who I mentioned above.  When I went to Edinburgh Castle I was told of Saint Margaret and how she was a very pious woman and this apparently rubbed off on her husband, and it certainly did to her children who were also either cannonised or admired for their piety by chroniclers.  One of their daughters was the wife of King Henry I of England, and their sons became Kings of Alba.
The knave, pictured on the left, is actually the oldest part of the Abbey dating to the 12th Century..  Apparently the Abbey claimed that Saint Margaret was its founder and forged an earlier foundation charter than David I's reign.  King Malcolm and his wife did found something here but it's unclear whether it was the Abbey or just a church.  Dunfermline Abbey became the centre point for the growing cult of Saint Margaret, Scotland's only cannonised royal.  This would have meant a lot of money coming in and so obviously the monks in residence here would have wanted people to keep thinking Saint Margaret founded it therefore forging the charter.

The Benedictine Abbey of the Holy Trinity and Saint Margaret (Dunfermline Abbey) was actually founded by their son King David I in 1128.
Dunfermline Abbey kept standing through the relatively calm years from its founding until the 13th Century when, you guessed it, Edward I stormed his way across the border during the Scottish War of Independence.  He held court at the Abbey in 1303 and then when he left he burned down the buildings.  I don't understand this act.  Edward I was a pious king, Dunfermline was a chartered Abbey with a Saint and numerous kings of Scotland buried in it, did he not fear the wrath of God would come down upon him for effectively destroying a holy place?  Perhaps it was because the kings were buried there that he partially destroyed it.  Nevertheless the Abbey kept standing even after the English were gone.

What I really want at this moment in the post is the guidebook I bought when I was there because it has so much information about this time and about life at the Abbey, but it's at home an I'm in Leicester so apologies.

Let's jump to the Scottish Reformation.  I know nothing about this; I only know about it in England but along those same lines Scotland joined in.  For those who don't know the English Reformation happened around the 1530s and was instigated by Henry VIII of England so he could marry Anne Boleyn.  The Catholic church wouldn't grant a divorce to Henry from his then wife, the poor Katherine of Aragon, and so he broke with Rome, made himself the head of the English church, divorced Katherine in this new religion and married Anne Boleyn, much to her ill fate.  And so began Protestantism.  Because Scotland and England have always been so geographically close, we share a common-ish culture, and our kings married daughters of the kings of England, it was only a matter of time before this new religion came over the border. 
The ruins of Dunfermline Palace

The Scottish Reformation happened in 1560 and banned Mass, etc, and made way for Protestantism.  This would be a very definitive blow against Marie de Guise, effective ruler of Scotland, and her Catholic daughter, the incompetent Mary, Queen of Scots.  Mary was the great-grandaughter of King Henry VII of England through his daughter, Margaret Tudor.  She was shipped off to France when she was very young to marry the Dauphin of France, the heir to the throne, leaving a regent to rule Scotland, and this burden eventually fell to her French mother, Marie de Guise, a catholic.
John Knox was the leader of the Scottish reformation and forced the issue in the wake of Marie de Guises death in early 1560.  Queen Mary didn't arrive in Scotland until 1561.
As all the Abbeys were sacked in England, so they were in Scotland, and one day in March 1560 the Abbey was sacked.
It was rebuilt, in part, in 1570, and reopened for worship in 1821, a huge gap, I know.  It has been extensively restored in the interim between those two periods, but it hadn't been completely destroyed to begin with anyway.  It is now a sight of historical importance as it is, save Iona, the place of the most Scottish Royal burials.  According to the Abbey these people are buried there, although when I was there I must have been looking in the wrong place because I didn't see any grave markers at all.  I do know that they will have been destroyed during the reformation but apparently Saint Margaret and her husband King Malcolm's tomb was restored on the orders of Queen Victoria in the 19th century.
Royals: Malcolm Canmore, Saint Margaret and their sons; Duncan II, Edgar, Alexander I and his wife Sybilla of Normandy, and David I with his wife Maud of Huntingdon.  
Malcolm IV, Alexander III, his wife Margaret of England, and their sons David and Alexander.  Robert the Bruce.
The wives and family members of some kings are also buried there but the full list is on Wikipedia if you're interested.

Dunfermline Palace is also adjoining the Abbey and is a ruin now also; has probably always been there in one form or another and was used to house royal and important guest when they visited the Abbey, it's the only part of the place you have to pay to get into, but it's not steep and the views are excellent.  King Charles I was born in Dunfermline Palace because his mother, Anna of Denmark and wife of King James VI of Scotland, lived in the palace at that time.  When James became King of England after the death of Elizabeth I in 1603 the palace fell into disrepair and ruin, which can still be seen today.

It doesn't take long to go around the Abbey and the Palace, but the inside is breathtaking, as all Abbeys are, and the views are amazing too especially if it's a good day like it was when I visited.  Dunfermline town is also just behind the Abbey so you can go for lunch and some shopping afterwards.  A nice day out overall and it is amazing to know you're walking in the same space as some of the most vibrant of Scotland's kings.

Monday, 17 November 2014

Morality: can protagonists ever be morally corrupt?

This is something I've been thinking about recently especially as I'm starting a new historical novel and nearly finished my previous fantasy one based on Waterhouse's "The Tempest" painting.  I have written many, many characters over the years and all seem to have at least one thread going through them; they're all morally upright.  I used to think this was because I also have very strong morals which I blame entirely on Japanese anime and subsequently South Korean dramas (if you don't know what I mean just go and watch one of them and you'll see all protagonists are near saintly), but more recently I began to think that it's just the nature of the beast.  Your protagonist pushes your story forward and they're the ones that keep your reader abreast of the tale but if they're unlikeable then the reader won't continue.  Are heroes/heroines dislikeable if they have no morals?  Is having no morals the same as being a "bad" character/person?  I am now going to delve into this topic based on sources of books I've read, which doesn't really seem that much but there's a reason.  I am now solely into historical mystery/crime and the characters don't really push the story forward so much as the plot's twists and turns do.

The first example that came to mind when I was brainstorming this post was Game of Thrones.  With such a vast array of characters it's hard to exclude these pieces of work from any literary discussion.  I have read all five of the installments of a Song of Ice and Fire and at the time when the Tv series had just started I was obsessed.  What typically happens with an obsession?  It dies down and now I'm sick of hearing and looking at them, to the extent I stopped watching the TV series and don't know if I'm going to continue reading.  What I don't understand now that I've had time to look objectively is why they're so popular.  They're so so depressing!  I am a girl who likes happy endings, I like when I have hope during a story that things are going to get better, that good things as well as bad are going to happen to any character.  With Martin's works it was always the bad thing that was going to happen to each and every character he wrote about, this happened to the extent where a bit of the stories actually became predictable for me; think of the thing you don't want to happen to Arya, it happens.  Towards book 4 and 5 I was beginning to question the point in reading them, nothing was ever going right, and that is exactly the biggest flaw with this series.  It's too pessimistic and cynical to be convincing.  I know that everyone praises the humanity of the characters, and I will give Martin that, they are quite complex to a certain extent, but his story is just too doom and gloom to have that authentic, real feel to them.  Yes, I know it's fantasy, but I like my fantasy to be believable, a mirror of some sort of the real world.  Bad things do not incessantly happen to normal people, life is balanced, of which there is none in here.
But I didn't come here to talk about the plot, I came to mention a few characters.  I read these books at least two years ago now, probably nearing three, so I've forgotten a lot of things but here are what stuck out.  Tyrion is my favourite character and by far the most misunderstood by other characters in the novels; my opinion of Tyrion was that he was morally upright and wanted to do the right and honourable thing, he had a soft spot for outcasts understandably.  Therefore isn't Tyrion classed as a 'good' character?   Cersei, Tyrion's sister, is vicious, vindictive and let's face it a complete bitch, apparently she cares for her children but the only evidence of that was her threatening Tyrion because he sent one of them away.  Do these traits make her a 'bad' character; an evil queen type?
There are others who follow this same line, Jon Snow wants to do the right thing and is honourable, Danerys Targaryen is reaching for sainthood and even Jaime Lannister starts to become an honourable character when his POV is introduced.  Aren't there clear cut lines here between who's a 'good' character and who's a 'bad' one?
Delving deeper, Tyrion kills his father, but his father is Tywin Lannister, another 'bad' character.  Readers feel less inclined to hate him because of who is father was, some would even say he deserved it.  Unfortunately Jon Snow, Danaerys and Jaime have no such moral blunders the entire way through the books and all seem to do the right thing all of the time.
I give an honourable mention to Joffrey Baratheon/Lannister for being a typical, and unrealistic, villain.  Martin didn't even try to put some humanity in that boy, and guess what, everyone hated Joffrey.

Moving onto more familiar and less complex ground.  Mistresses are looked down upon by women today, being the 'other woman' is something to be ashamed of.  There have been recent assaults of mistresses in China by the spouses of the cheating husbands, it has always been a position of scorn and judgment.  Novel readers, especially historical (romantic) fiction is predominately women, which means you have to aim at your reader.  One of the most popular books of the 20th Century was about a mistress!  I've mentioned this novel before, Anya Seton's "Katherine" was published in 1954 and has maintained popularity ever since (which is why they should make it into a TV series) and is about John of Gaunt's long-time mistress and eventual third wife, Katherine de Roet-Swynford.  Click here to read my History Sunday segment about John of Gaunt and Katherine.  Why is a novel about a mistress so popular?
When I read Katherine I found the heroine morally upright, religiously so, because she was pious.  She had a conscience and was somewhat reluctant, for evident reasons, to become his mistress at first.  Throughout the novel she continues to display kindness, compassion and every trait that most people want for themselves.  Is this what makes her so likeable, or is it the historical setting which takes the heat away from the mistress position?
In Anne O'Brien's novel about Katherine she was also pious and a little reluctant to become Gaunt's mistress but the reasons were purely selfish this time.  I never finished this novel but I never truly hated this version of Katherine (I didn't really like her much but it wasn't because she lacked morals).
Another maligned mistress, Alice Perrers, has been the focus of some newer novels, only one of which I tried to read.  In Seton's novel she's portrayed as the shunned mistress of the king, a foreboding warning to the young katherine what's at stake when a woman gives up her reputation for a man, in Harper's novel about Joan of Kent she's horrible and ugly if I remember correctly and everyone hates her.  Finally, in O'brien's novel about her she's sort of bland but still seems to have a conscience, a far way away from how she's portrayed in every novel that isn't about her.  In the novels with her as a secondary character she's selfish, greedy, everything history reports her to be, whilst in novels about her she has some semblance of a conscience.  Coincidence?

Finally I'll move onto a character from the world of TV.  Dexter is a brilliant show and I honestly can't pin down the reason.  The protagonist is a serial killer and he gets away with it!  But most people who watch the show love Dexter because to a degree he is as cute as a button.
 The more I think about it the more I think its linked to humanity.  What I mean by this is that whenever we watch movies about non-human characters, Edward Scissor hands, Frankenstein, we all feel sorry for the bad things that happen to them because they display human characteristics even though they're not human.  They're learning to be human and are at times so innocent and genuinely good that when misfortune comes their way our hearts crack a little.  Dexter is in a very similar band.  He's human but not quite, a large chunk of what makes us all human is dormant and slowly awakens through the series.  I also think Dexter is very popular because he makes the audience laugh.  I first came across this tactic when I went to see Richard II at the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford.  He was a funny king, a little sardonic but still made me laugh, and I ended up feeling sorry for him by the end of the play.  But Dexter, by definition, is not a 'good' character, he's also not a bad one either.  Voila, a human protagonist.  It's a shame that a hero needs to be a serial killer to be human.  By killing people constantly he is what the world defines as a bad character, watch any murder/police drama and the bad guy kills people; but Dexter loves his family and will do anything, killing included, to protect and seek revenge for them.

It's a bit of a steep decision to make, though, for a writer, and a dangerous one.  I personally always try and avoid my characters killing anyone because I think it may make them seem a little less sympathetic.  Can a person truly be a killer and a 'good' person.  Going along those same lines, Taryn Connagh in my novel "Poison Most Royal" is a hitwoman/assassin.  I didn't think twice about her occupation because I've always wanted to write about a woman who kills people for a living, but Taryn has her reasons for doing so and questions her own morality throughout the novel.  I don't know if Taryn is likeable, it's hard to gain some perspective
when you're reading your own creation, but Taryn has morals, as all my characters seem to.

Returning to the question of this post.  Can a protagonist ever be morally corrupt?  Even Dexter has a set of rules he sticks to.  It is almost impossible for anyone to answer this question because no one in the world has read all the books in existence.  Making characters moral does increase the likelihood that the reader will like them, but simultaneously if you write a bad character they'll be immediately disliked anyway.  I've never read a book where the main characters don't have good morals and don't make good decisions.  I dislike reading posts and blogs about "how to write a good character" or "how to write ....... well".  There is no one set guide to writing!  If that were the case then every book published and written would be nothing more than a creative journal article.  There is a difference between science and art, there always has been.  Writing these guides on how to write is going against the very fabric of creative writing; the clue is in the title, creative!  There is no one way to write a novel, novella, short story, poem, or any of these things; it's not statistics, believe me, I know.  Scientific researchers, like myself, have guides to writing journal articles and reports, most, if not all, of our research write ups have to follow the same structure, but that's science, we like things that have a format.  Art isn't supposed to be like that.

I also love the deviation from statistics reports because at least with this research question I don't have to answer it.  There is no answer to my question.  Do characters have to be morally upstanding?  Personally I think they have to have some semblance of good sense, but above all they should, if possible, make good decisions.  There are books and novels where the main character makes a bad decision and it haunts them for the rest of their lives.  Characters aren't real people, they shouldn't have to conform to an exact human nature.  That being said they shouldn't be unbelievable as human beings.  Characters can reflect the best of human natures and the worst, but they shouldn't be saintly or villainous.  It's easy to make a character a saint that does no wrong and also, say, to make a villain with no good bone in their body, but neither are realistic.  If they do something bad they should have a reason for it, if they're morally upstanding there has to be a foundation for that behaviour.  Reason is what makes a character, their history, the things you don't write about, that's what makes them who they are; the nameless relatives also have a good say in that as well.  I don't know if my characters are very human, no one has reviewed my novel to tell me otherwise, but the above process is what I go through every time I think of a character, every time I sit down and begin typing their reaction to a scenario or something that has happened to them.

What are your views on characters?  Do you think a hero/heroine can be morally corrupt and still be liked by the readers?  Who is the most human character you have ever read?