Showing posts with label novel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label novel. Show all posts

Monday, 17 November 2014

Morality: can protagonists ever be morally corrupt?

This is something I've been thinking about recently especially as I'm starting a new historical novel and nearly finished my previous fantasy one based on Waterhouse's "The Tempest" painting.  I have written many, many characters over the years and all seem to have at least one thread going through them; they're all morally upright.  I used to think this was because I also have very strong morals which I blame entirely on Japanese anime and subsequently South Korean dramas (if you don't know what I mean just go and watch one of them and you'll see all protagonists are near saintly), but more recently I began to think that it's just the nature of the beast.  Your protagonist pushes your story forward and they're the ones that keep your reader abreast of the tale but if they're unlikeable then the reader won't continue.  Are heroes/heroines dislikeable if they have no morals?  Is having no morals the same as being a "bad" character/person?  I am now going to delve into this topic based on sources of books I've read, which doesn't really seem that much but there's a reason.  I am now solely into historical mystery/crime and the characters don't really push the story forward so much as the plot's twists and turns do.

The first example that came to mind when I was brainstorming this post was Game of Thrones.  With such a vast array of characters it's hard to exclude these pieces of work from any literary discussion.  I have read all five of the installments of a Song of Ice and Fire and at the time when the Tv series had just started I was obsessed.  What typically happens with an obsession?  It dies down and now I'm sick of hearing and looking at them, to the extent I stopped watching the TV series and don't know if I'm going to continue reading.  What I don't understand now that I've had time to look objectively is why they're so popular.  They're so so depressing!  I am a girl who likes happy endings, I like when I have hope during a story that things are going to get better, that good things as well as bad are going to happen to any character.  With Martin's works it was always the bad thing that was going to happen to each and every character he wrote about, this happened to the extent where a bit of the stories actually became predictable for me; think of the thing you don't want to happen to Arya, it happens.  Towards book 4 and 5 I was beginning to question the point in reading them, nothing was ever going right, and that is exactly the biggest flaw with this series.  It's too pessimistic and cynical to be convincing.  I know that everyone praises the humanity of the characters, and I will give Martin that, they are quite complex to a certain extent, but his story is just too doom and gloom to have that authentic, real feel to them.  Yes, I know it's fantasy, but I like my fantasy to be believable, a mirror of some sort of the real world.  Bad things do not incessantly happen to normal people, life is balanced, of which there is none in here.
But I didn't come here to talk about the plot, I came to mention a few characters.  I read these books at least two years ago now, probably nearing three, so I've forgotten a lot of things but here are what stuck out.  Tyrion is my favourite character and by far the most misunderstood by other characters in the novels; my opinion of Tyrion was that he was morally upright and wanted to do the right and honourable thing, he had a soft spot for outcasts understandably.  Therefore isn't Tyrion classed as a 'good' character?   Cersei, Tyrion's sister, is vicious, vindictive and let's face it a complete bitch, apparently she cares for her children but the only evidence of that was her threatening Tyrion because he sent one of them away.  Do these traits make her a 'bad' character; an evil queen type?
There are others who follow this same line, Jon Snow wants to do the right thing and is honourable, Danerys Targaryen is reaching for sainthood and even Jaime Lannister starts to become an honourable character when his POV is introduced.  Aren't there clear cut lines here between who's a 'good' character and who's a 'bad' one?
Delving deeper, Tyrion kills his father, but his father is Tywin Lannister, another 'bad' character.  Readers feel less inclined to hate him because of who is father was, some would even say he deserved it.  Unfortunately Jon Snow, Danaerys and Jaime have no such moral blunders the entire way through the books and all seem to do the right thing all of the time.
I give an honourable mention to Joffrey Baratheon/Lannister for being a typical, and unrealistic, villain.  Martin didn't even try to put some humanity in that boy, and guess what, everyone hated Joffrey.

Moving onto more familiar and less complex ground.  Mistresses are looked down upon by women today, being the 'other woman' is something to be ashamed of.  There have been recent assaults of mistresses in China by the spouses of the cheating husbands, it has always been a position of scorn and judgment.  Novel readers, especially historical (romantic) fiction is predominately women, which means you have to aim at your reader.  One of the most popular books of the 20th Century was about a mistress!  I've mentioned this novel before, Anya Seton's "Katherine" was published in 1954 and has maintained popularity ever since (which is why they should make it into a TV series) and is about John of Gaunt's long-time mistress and eventual third wife, Katherine de Roet-Swynford.  Click here to read my History Sunday segment about John of Gaunt and Katherine.  Why is a novel about a mistress so popular?
When I read Katherine I found the heroine morally upright, religiously so, because she was pious.  She had a conscience and was somewhat reluctant, for evident reasons, to become his mistress at first.  Throughout the novel she continues to display kindness, compassion and every trait that most people want for themselves.  Is this what makes her so likeable, or is it the historical setting which takes the heat away from the mistress position?
In Anne O'Brien's novel about Katherine she was also pious and a little reluctant to become Gaunt's mistress but the reasons were purely selfish this time.  I never finished this novel but I never truly hated this version of Katherine (I didn't really like her much but it wasn't because she lacked morals).
Another maligned mistress, Alice Perrers, has been the focus of some newer novels, only one of which I tried to read.  In Seton's novel she's portrayed as the shunned mistress of the king, a foreboding warning to the young katherine what's at stake when a woman gives up her reputation for a man, in Harper's novel about Joan of Kent she's horrible and ugly if I remember correctly and everyone hates her.  Finally, in O'brien's novel about her she's sort of bland but still seems to have a conscience, a far way away from how she's portrayed in every novel that isn't about her.  In the novels with her as a secondary character she's selfish, greedy, everything history reports her to be, whilst in novels about her she has some semblance of a conscience.  Coincidence?

Finally I'll move onto a character from the world of TV.  Dexter is a brilliant show and I honestly can't pin down the reason.  The protagonist is a serial killer and he gets away with it!  But most people who watch the show love Dexter because to a degree he is as cute as a button.
 The more I think about it the more I think its linked to humanity.  What I mean by this is that whenever we watch movies about non-human characters, Edward Scissor hands, Frankenstein, we all feel sorry for the bad things that happen to them because they display human characteristics even though they're not human.  They're learning to be human and are at times so innocent and genuinely good that when misfortune comes their way our hearts crack a little.  Dexter is in a very similar band.  He's human but not quite, a large chunk of what makes us all human is dormant and slowly awakens through the series.  I also think Dexter is very popular because he makes the audience laugh.  I first came across this tactic when I went to see Richard II at the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford.  He was a funny king, a little sardonic but still made me laugh, and I ended up feeling sorry for him by the end of the play.  But Dexter, by definition, is not a 'good' character, he's also not a bad one either.  Voila, a human protagonist.  It's a shame that a hero needs to be a serial killer to be human.  By killing people constantly he is what the world defines as a bad character, watch any murder/police drama and the bad guy kills people; but Dexter loves his family and will do anything, killing included, to protect and seek revenge for them.

It's a bit of a steep decision to make, though, for a writer, and a dangerous one.  I personally always try and avoid my characters killing anyone because I think it may make them seem a little less sympathetic.  Can a person truly be a killer and a 'good' person.  Going along those same lines, Taryn Connagh in my novel "Poison Most Royal" is a hitwoman/assassin.  I didn't think twice about her occupation because I've always wanted to write about a woman who kills people for a living, but Taryn has her reasons for doing so and questions her own morality throughout the novel.  I don't know if Taryn is likeable, it's hard to gain some perspective
when you're reading your own creation, but Taryn has morals, as all my characters seem to.

Returning to the question of this post.  Can a protagonist ever be morally corrupt?  Even Dexter has a set of rules he sticks to.  It is almost impossible for anyone to answer this question because no one in the world has read all the books in existence.  Making characters moral does increase the likelihood that the reader will like them, but simultaneously if you write a bad character they'll be immediately disliked anyway.  I've never read a book where the main characters don't have good morals and don't make good decisions.  I dislike reading posts and blogs about "how to write a good character" or "how to write ....... well".  There is no one set guide to writing!  If that were the case then every book published and written would be nothing more than a creative journal article.  There is a difference between science and art, there always has been.  Writing these guides on how to write is going against the very fabric of creative writing; the clue is in the title, creative!  There is no one way to write a novel, novella, short story, poem, or any of these things; it's not statistics, believe me, I know.  Scientific researchers, like myself, have guides to writing journal articles and reports, most, if not all, of our research write ups have to follow the same structure, but that's science, we like things that have a format.  Art isn't supposed to be like that.

I also love the deviation from statistics reports because at least with this research question I don't have to answer it.  There is no answer to my question.  Do characters have to be morally upstanding?  Personally I think they have to have some semblance of good sense, but above all they should, if possible, make good decisions.  There are books and novels where the main character makes a bad decision and it haunts them for the rest of their lives.  Characters aren't real people, they shouldn't have to conform to an exact human nature.  That being said they shouldn't be unbelievable as human beings.  Characters can reflect the best of human natures and the worst, but they shouldn't be saintly or villainous.  It's easy to make a character a saint that does no wrong and also, say, to make a villain with no good bone in their body, but neither are realistic.  If they do something bad they should have a reason for it, if they're morally upstanding there has to be a foundation for that behaviour.  Reason is what makes a character, their history, the things you don't write about, that's what makes them who they are; the nameless relatives also have a good say in that as well.  I don't know if my characters are very human, no one has reviewed my novel to tell me otherwise, but the above process is what I go through every time I think of a character, every time I sit down and begin typing their reaction to a scenario or something that has happened to them.

What are your views on characters?  Do you think a hero/heroine can be morally corrupt and still be liked by the readers?  Who is the most human character you have ever read?



Monday, 1 September 2014

Italian Renaissance, 15th Century fantasy dress

Once more I will emphasise that this project was strictly FANTASY and in no way historically accurate.

Let us start at a good place....the beginning.  I finished the first draft of 'Poison Most Royal' in the summer of 2013.  One thing I do whenever I start a new idea is to imagine what my characters are wearing; this is probably a bit strange to some people but I always build on the character's clothes and looks.  I am in no way interested in modern fashion, I wear what I like for better or worse, but I LOVE historical clothing.  For some reason I decided to chose the 15th Century Italian fashion as my base for my character's costume in 'Poison Most Royal'.  For the front cover of the novel I wanted to make the dress I imagined in my mind.

This involved many terrible drawings (I graduated University with a degree in the College of Science, the specific subject I will keep to myself for now, and have never excelled at anything artistic, which is where the concern for my poor novel sets me biting my nails), many orders of fabric samples and many, many jabs and prods with a sharp needle.

The Pattern I bought was 'Period Patterns, no. 41; Italian Renaissance gowns'.  It took me ages finding a pattern that fitted the drawings I had.


To give some background knowledge by the time I began this project at the start of summer 2014 I had made a total of two cotton summer dresses and one chiffon tunic, so my experience was sparse.  I did embroider for about a year or so a few years back, but my wish to make my own clothes had always been there, even as I stitched that multi-coloured song bird onto white fabric thinking which of my family members would have to look at it on their walls.  I needed a pattern for this because I just didn't have enough experience to make my own (nor did I have the courage).

I ordered it from Patterns of Time on Etsy (check them out if you have a sudden urge to create a historical costume because I spend hours on there).  For my character's dress none of these individual dresses were fulfilling my ideal so I had to cut out different pieces from the different numbers.  The dress that I created was made from; the bodice of Figure II, the skirt from Figure IV and the top part of the sleeve from Figure V.

Having cut them out with lessening difficulty (there was a lot of pattern paper) it came the time of choosing fabric.  I think it may be best at this point to just show you the finished product and work back from there because I never took pictures at each stage.  Everything was hand sewn because I don't own a sewing machine (but believe me at times this project made me wish I did).


This was the finished product with full chemise/camicia, the pattern of which I got from a website; find link here:

How to Make an easy Italian Renaissance chemise





I think this was the only part of the entire thing that was actually historically accurate.....and then I ruined it by putting very modern black lace on the cuffs and neckline.  It was made with white linen, weight light.  I took a picture of me in just the chemise but you can see right through it (duh!) and I wished to keep my modesty and of course the reader's mind, undisturbed.  It's also the reason why I've cropped my make-up-less face out.
Let's start at the top with the bodice.  Cut from four pieces it is made of navy blue cotton velvet and lined with cobalt blue 100% cotton.  The reason for this choice was that I had quite a lot of blue cotton left over from my first dress making project and 'waste not want not'.  Unfortunately I didn't line it correctly because I didn't believe, or I couldn't figure out, that the proper way worked; so I sewed it on manually.  


I wanted it to be front fastening and so the back is really just for show.  Eyelets placed hopefully in the proper way and what I think to be spiral lacing (and if it is then another thing that's historically accurate).  The gold braiding is very 21st Century and bound at the ends by cello-tape because I never bought agelets. There are eyes on the armholes to attach the sleeves.  The trim is this very strange silver ribbon type stuff and definitely 21st Century but personally quite pretty.


The stomacher was made from this really nice grey satin-but-not-satin.  I can't remember what it was actually called but it reminded me of tie material.  It was also lined with the last remnants of the 100% blue cotton.

Sleeves were made with the not-quite-satin but this time lined in purple definitely-satin, also leftovers from my very first ever, ever project of a 13/14th Century sideless surcote (I know it was not historically accurate but it was cheap and I was experimenting).  Three eyelets, one at the top and two at the sides to correspond with the bodice and tied with very modern navy blue satin ribbon.  You can see on the right-hand side one that the seam isn't even, something went wrong when cutting out the pieces and so one side was longer than the other.  The lining process was done right this time, i.e right sides together then turn inside out and sew (God, I hope that is the right way but it worked better.)

The finished project off me because I want to talk about the skirt.  This by far took me the longest when it shouldn't have and it was because of the design I have on it.  There was no pattern for this design and to be honest I think it looks very similar to Vanozza's dress in HBO's The Borgias (that programme was completely not a factor when designing this dress).

It was actually this pattern on Vanozza's dress that gave me the idea for mine....thanks The Borgias.

First thing first, the skirt is made from navy blue Duchesse satin and the strange grey not-quite-satin.  What I had to do was cut out the duchesse satin from the pattern and alter it a little so it didn't join up at the front.  There were markings on the pattern piece, don't ask me what they were for though, and I ended up using them to decide how thick the front grey piece was going to be (think it's larger than I planned for actually).

When all strange pieces were cut I had to sew the grey not-quite-satin onto the navy satin and boy did that take ages.  There are no seams between the grey and blue because I was frightened that if I altered the navy I wouldn't do it properly.  If I got a close up of that bottom border you would see it popping out of the invisible stitch I did.

I got really lazy with this project towards the end because things just kept getting in the way of my finishing it and I also lost my zeal for it, so the seams are raw and not finished, but at least the hem is ok...ish.

So that was my Italian 15th Century fantasy replica dress.  It was done for the front cover of my first novel Poison Most Royal, published under the name L Barnett.  Available on Amazon Kindle if you wish to read it.  WARNING: not set in 15th Century Italy, is is strictly fantasy and set in a fantasy Kingdom.

I am undecided what to do my next project on.  I really want to try an 1880's bustle dress but that comes with a load of trimmings like petticoats, the actual cage bustle and possibly the corset so perhaps when I'm more experienced.  It's a toss up between patterns I already have and buying a new one.  The Contenders are:
Lord of the Rings Eowyn green gown reproduction (but not in green velvet) and with this pattern.


18th Century gown reproduction.  The only bad thing about this is those horrible panniers, but if they're not too big then I accept.  This is the pattern I already own.

Lastly the open-robe regency-ish gown and the actual empire waisted gown, like the one worn by the lovely Hattie Morahan (on the right) as Eleanor Dashwood from the BBC's 2008 version of Sense and Sensibility.
I am leaning towards the regency but it involves having to buy a new pattern, but who's against buying new things?

Hopefully will be adding new blogposts soon, including a link to my published book, some information about it and perhaps a post about my latest travels.