I'm not one for doing a review of things I've sewed in 2017, mostly because I've never taken pictures of them. However, I will briefly go over what I've accomplished in words, and then make another list for 2018 that I will forget about in a few months. The beginning of the year is always obvious because I spend it making my Victorian ball garments, everything from foundations up, and then in the other half of the year I just potter about from one era to another depending on what book I'm reading, story I'm writing, or TV show I'm watching. Yes, I'm just that contrary.
My sewing goals for 2017 were:
1.) First Bustle Era Victorian ensemble (day, evening, bustle, and corset).
Status: COMPLETE
2.) Regency Ball gown
Status: COMPLETE
I only have about 3 pictures of this gown, and only two that survived the great computer crash of 2017 where I lost all the pictures I stupidly hadn't put in my Dropbox. I will post about this gown eventually, despite the fact it was way back in March, I still have a draft article that needs adding to. The sleeves need fixed, and I know exactly how to do it, but we'll leave that for 2018.
2.5) Regency spencer
Status: COMPLETE
Again, no pictures, apart from if you head over to my Instagram where I took a lot of process ones. I messed up the sleeve lining so this also needs fixed in 2018. Pictures hopefully coming soon.
3) Open project
Status: COMPLETE
Again, no pictures of blog post (wow, I've been an awful blogger this year, I swear they're all still in draft form). I had three options for this, an adaptation of a purple gown from season 1 of Victoria on ITV, that 11/12th century gown I've had on my list for at least 3 years (but which I am officially giving up on for now), and a fantasy.
I went for fantasy, and this was my first foray into drafting patterns from scratch. I'm proud of this project for many things, and hopefully I will catch up with this project in a blog post at some point in 2018.
5.) HSM challenges 2017.
Status: COMPLETE?
I wanted to do at least 7 of them, and only managed to do one. I must say, regarding this I've been , seen, and semi-conquered. Despite following rules for my job, it turns out I don't really like setting challenges like the HSM for myself. My sewing brain is always running to its own schedule, and it never fitted with any of the HSM challenges. At least I did one.
I'm actually really surprised. I managed to accomplish all of the goals I set for myself for 2017, and even added four new ones (18th century undergarments, which, you've guessed it, I haven't blogged about, or even finished for that matter....2018 is going to be a big year for catch-up, a regency open-robe which again haven't blogged about, Sew Curvy's Victoria corset kit, and my 1950s winter coat).
Now we come onto 2018. This year is pretty much the same as the two before. the Victorian ball (hopefully my last one for a while, and wouldn't be happening at all if my friend hadn't persuaded me) will dominate the first 4/5 months of 2018, but at least I already have a corset, and my Christmas project consisted of making combination underwear, so it's just design decisions to be made. And then after that I have free reign to do whatever I want.
1.) Natural Form Era ensemble (day and evening)
Lots of ideas. I've more or less finalised the design for the evening, but I have less of an idea about the day ensemble.
2.) Finish 18th century outfit
I started this a month or two back, and started with scaling up a pattern in Waugh (1776 pair of stays), and started drafting a suitable chemise, and then the Victorian ball took over at Christmas. The stays and chemise are almost complete, just binding and seam finishing to do on both, but I may make another pair of stays just for the fun of it. Next is a false rump, petticoat, and Pierrot jacket. The American Duchess's new book came out just at the right time for me. And in place of HSM challenges, I've decided to set my own with this one. The entire outfit will be from scaled up or self-drafted patterns. Not a commercial pattern in sight.
3.) Blog
As happy as I am that I managed to complete all of my sewing goals for 2017, I only blogged about 1 thing. Most of the finished projects are sitting in draft form on my Google account. My goal this year is to finish those drafts, and blog about all completed projects.
4.) Make do and mend
Possibly a little misleading. There are a few projects with problems that I know how to fix but haven't because I've only worn them once.
The sleeves on the regency ball gown need altered.
The sleeve lining on the regency Spencer needs fixed.
The seams need finishing on my 2016 Victorian ball gown; the cage bag needs re-done, and I need to make a day bodice from the remaining silk.
no doubt many other things.
So my goal is to fix all projects to date so they're in an acceptable condition (let's hope it's not as big a task as it sounds to me right now).
5.) Build a portfolio
All the greats have them, and hopefully in 2018 one not so great (me) will have one too. Now I've purchased my first DSLR camera and have scouted out a few suitable locations I really want to start doing photoshoots of the finished garments.
6.) Open projects
I found myself sewing faster this last year. projects I've allocated a month for only take 2 weeks, and so on, and because I jump from interest to interest I'm leaving this open to whatever takes my fancy at the time.
2017 was a big year personal life wise. No I haven't got married, no I'm not pregnant/had children, but I moved house, came to the end of my contract at work, and made the transition into being a PhD student. I'm almost afraid of what 2018 has in mind.
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Friday, 5 January 2018
Sunday, 18 September 2016
Sewing Scot: 1870's undergarments
This weekend was all about undergarments for the ball next May. I know, I'm starting very early and there's a few reasons for that. This year I want to make both night and day time wear, which each involve some separate components, but I'll get to that.
The innermost foundation layer in any Victorian ensemble is, of course, the chemise. I had loads, and I mean loads, of trouble with this pattern. The only thing about it that was good was the yoke style. For the chemise I used Simplicity 2890.
Last year's chemise, I recently found out, was supposed to have a front closure on it....which isn't there because I must have given up on reading the destructions, as always. It has no closure, and is just a curved yoke around my shoulders. It's a little big so I could hide it beneath the off-shoulder bodice. The thing I didn't like about it were the sleeves.
I also used bias binding to finish the sleeves, good old tartan because I own a 50m roll, and why not? As you can see on my gown last year it popped out. It's not as bad as it may seem but I confess, despite my laziness I am a wee bit of a perfectionist. This sleeve will forever annoy me in this picture...it's one of two things that do (the white lace is attached to the belt and I wanted it to sit a little further back than it does). I'm getting carried away.
Back to this year. I could use the same chemise......but why not make another one I know won't show (potentially)? I swapped one simplicity pattern for another. The one I chose to make this year has short sleeves, not puffed, and I made them quite short just to ensure no exposure. It has a closure, although it's hard to miss on this pattern to be fair.
But my God, it's a terribly sized pattern. patterns are always a little on the big side for me, despite me taking my measurements on a regular basis, but this one was ridiculous. I wish I had a picture for how large the original was on me (no mock-up, I'm afraid). I later found out if I'd simply Googled a review for this pattern I would have found this out a lot sooner....oops.
The yoke is meant to skim over the top of the shoulders, if we go by how it looks both on the drawing and the woman modelling it. It went a few inches past the ends of my shoulders!! And the main body...like I had decided to attach a bin liner to a yoke and wear it! It made me laugh.
I couldn't tell how to fix it so that went in the bin. Onto the next go and I fiddled around with the yoke. Last year's pattern came out, I drafted a new yoke that incorporated what I liked about the new one and what had fit in the old one. Still no luck...yokes went in the bin, panels remained intact.
Finally I decided to get the original yoke pattern and place it on myself to see what the problem was. A few bits of folding here and there and I'd got it the way I wanted. I used the folded paper to make a new yoke pattern, front and back. Voila, solved.
I can live with a little bit too big, falling gracefully off my shoulders big. It's not as well fitted as last year's one, so there's quite a lot more room; we'll see if that's a good thing or not.
However, I couldn't get through making this without one stupid mistake that was completely avoidable. I cut the front opening too far. I did it on the first one and thought I hadn't transferred the markings properly, but when I checked it turned out I had. I may have made some alterations to the yoke, but the length at the front was kept intact. However, due to some misstep the front yoke didn't go all the way down to the bottom of the opening, leaving a really annoying half an inch gap where there is raw material.
My only solution now is good old bias binding. It won't look neat, but at least it'll cover the raw edges, and maybe make that front opening a little sturdier, because we all know what cotton lawn is like.
It is pinned to the mannequin at the shoulder seams. Last year I let one side hang off the mannequin, but because of that flimsy front opening I didn't want to put any strain or weight on it. It is very loose on my shoulders still, but that (hopefully) means that it won't be making an appearance over the top of my evening bodice. Short sleeves should also disappear. So overall success with the chemise, and no tartan bias binding in site.
Next....the bloomers! I didn't make these last year and I can't remember why. I had the pattern but for some reason didn't use it. I might have thought it would make me too hot? I honestly can't remember past-me logic. This year, though, I'm tackling the bloomers.
The bloomers were a pretty simply pattern to follow, a front and back waistband, and the largest patter piece you've ever seen. There's no using folded fabric here, it was opening out the entire piece of cotton lawn.
First is to add lace and hem. I didn't have any lace to hand so I added pintucks to the bottom. I confess I didn't transfer the pin tuck patterns but the instructions told you the gap between the first tuck and the hem so I worked it out from there and how big I wanted the tucks. I really liked the graded effect on my regency petticoat, so I thought I'd try a little bit of a twist on that. I measured how long the panels were and thought I could get a way with a few more. After meticulously measuring out each of the 4 pintucks (bottom 2 at 1cm thick, the top 2 at 2cm thick) it was time to make legs. Frustratingly despite my measuring, an unusual occurrence for me, the tucks didn't match at the seams! I literally copied exactly what I did to one side to the other, yet the larger pintucks don't match at the seams. Irritating.
Next was the waistband (I'll finish the seams one hand sewing afternoon). I forgot to cut 4 of the back waistband so had to get the lawn out again. That was easy to assemble, and then it was to gather the top of the legs to the bodice. Overall these bloomers took my most of a 4 hour afternoon. And not so shockingly enough they are huge! I did measure the waistband before I made it up and it seemed as though it would fit alright, with a bit of room but I can live with that. However the legs themselves are like balloons, or those short trouser things you see in 17th century paintings (can't think of the name).
I can also, potentially, deal with this since they're undergarments, but since they were so quick to make up I can always make another pair in case I can't live with them.
I was meant to begin tackling the corset, but after I'd finished the bloomers it was late afternoon and I didn't really see the point. I had difficulty inserting the gussets on the mock-up and I want to take my time with the real one, so I'm spared that until next week!
The innermost foundation layer in any Victorian ensemble is, of course, the chemise. I had loads, and I mean loads, of trouble with this pattern. The only thing about it that was good was the yoke style. For the chemise I used Simplicity 2890.
Last year's chemise, I recently found out, was supposed to have a front closure on it....which isn't there because I must have given up on reading the destructions, as always. It has no closure, and is just a curved yoke around my shoulders. It's a little big so I could hide it beneath the off-shoulder bodice. The thing I didn't like about it were the sleeves.
I also used bias binding to finish the sleeves, good old tartan because I own a 50m roll, and why not? As you can see on my gown last year it popped out. It's not as bad as it may seem but I confess, despite my laziness I am a wee bit of a perfectionist. This sleeve will forever annoy me in this picture...it's one of two things that do (the white lace is attached to the belt and I wanted it to sit a little further back than it does). I'm getting carried away.
Back to this year. I could use the same chemise......but why not make another one I know won't show (potentially)? I swapped one simplicity pattern for another. The one I chose to make this year has short sleeves, not puffed, and I made them quite short just to ensure no exposure. It has a closure, although it's hard to miss on this pattern to be fair.
But my God, it's a terribly sized pattern. patterns are always a little on the big side for me, despite me taking my measurements on a regular basis, but this one was ridiculous. I wish I had a picture for how large the original was on me (no mock-up, I'm afraid). I later found out if I'd simply Googled a review for this pattern I would have found this out a lot sooner....oops.
The yoke is meant to skim over the top of the shoulders, if we go by how it looks both on the drawing and the woman modelling it. It went a few inches past the ends of my shoulders!! And the main body...like I had decided to attach a bin liner to a yoke and wear it! It made me laugh.
I couldn't tell how to fix it so that went in the bin. Onto the next go and I fiddled around with the yoke. Last year's pattern came out, I drafted a new yoke that incorporated what I liked about the new one and what had fit in the old one. Still no luck...yokes went in the bin, panels remained intact.
Finally I decided to get the original yoke pattern and place it on myself to see what the problem was. A few bits of folding here and there and I'd got it the way I wanted. I used the folded paper to make a new yoke pattern, front and back. Voila, solved.
I can live with a little bit too big, falling gracefully off my shoulders big. It's not as well fitted as last year's one, so there's quite a lot more room; we'll see if that's a good thing or not.
However, I couldn't get through making this without one stupid mistake that was completely avoidable. I cut the front opening too far. I did it on the first one and thought I hadn't transferred the markings properly, but when I checked it turned out I had. I may have made some alterations to the yoke, but the length at the front was kept intact. However, due to some misstep the front yoke didn't go all the way down to the bottom of the opening, leaving a really annoying half an inch gap where there is raw material.
My only solution now is good old bias binding. It won't look neat, but at least it'll cover the raw edges, and maybe make that front opening a little sturdier, because we all know what cotton lawn is like.
![]() |
| Bias binding attached to front opening raw edges |
Next....the bloomers! I didn't make these last year and I can't remember why. I had the pattern but for some reason didn't use it. I might have thought it would make me too hot? I honestly can't remember past-me logic. This year, though, I'm tackling the bloomers.
The bloomers were a pretty simply pattern to follow, a front and back waistband, and the largest patter piece you've ever seen. There's no using folded fabric here, it was opening out the entire piece of cotton lawn.
First is to add lace and hem. I didn't have any lace to hand so I added pintucks to the bottom. I confess I didn't transfer the pin tuck patterns but the instructions told you the gap between the first tuck and the hem so I worked it out from there and how big I wanted the tucks. I really liked the graded effect on my regency petticoat, so I thought I'd try a little bit of a twist on that. I measured how long the panels were and thought I could get a way with a few more. After meticulously measuring out each of the 4 pintucks (bottom 2 at 1cm thick, the top 2 at 2cm thick) it was time to make legs. Frustratingly despite my measuring, an unusual occurrence for me, the tucks didn't match at the seams! I literally copied exactly what I did to one side to the other, yet the larger pintucks don't match at the seams. Irritating.
Next was the waistband (I'll finish the seams one hand sewing afternoon). I forgot to cut 4 of the back waistband so had to get the lawn out again. That was easy to assemble, and then it was to gather the top of the legs to the bodice. Overall these bloomers took my most of a 4 hour afternoon. And not so shockingly enough they are huge! I did measure the waistband before I made it up and it seemed as though it would fit alright, with a bit of room but I can live with that. However the legs themselves are like balloons, or those short trouser things you see in 17th century paintings (can't think of the name).
![]() |
| My bloomers |
I was meant to begin tackling the corset, but after I'd finished the bloomers it was late afternoon and I didn't really see the point. I had difficulty inserting the gussets on the mock-up and I want to take my time with the real one, so I'm spared that until next week!
![]() |
| Finished Ball undergaments! |
Saturday, 21 March 2015
Sewing: 19th Century Corset
The first thing I'd like to say is: my goodness I'm glad I'm finished this! This is the first corset I've ever made and I hand sewed all of it, my poor fingers were nearly dead by the end! I've sewed a few things where I felt I wanted a sewing machine, but this is the only piece that made up my mind to get one (soon, my darlings). Unfortunately I did sew it all by hand. The reason I don't own one is because I have so far made clothes in a time period that didn't have them, and because sewing is the solution to many bad habits of mine, most specifically boredom binging. But in a few months I'm getting one, mostly because of a summer project I've been thinking about since Christmas: more about this nearer the time.
Back to topic. The corset I wanted was meant to be late 19th Century, and when I began this it was actualy meant to be 1900, and if you look back at my previous posts about corsets you'll realise why I used a 19th century pattern and not the horrible Edwardian corset pattern. I used Laughing Moon LM100, which covers the years 1837-1900.
I didn't know the difference really in corsets in the 19th century. In this packet there are two, one with bust gores and longer, one without. After I cut out the one I thought I wanted and cut out the fabric I realised I may have chosen the wrong one for my timing.
The way I understand it now is that bust gores are very first half of 19th century, and the other pattern was more the one I was looking for. The only reason I chose the bust gore one was because it was slightly longer (despite my having to shorten it at the fitting stage), and since the 1900 skirt pattern I bought was fitted over my massive hips I wanted a little more coverage for my disproportionate shape.
I am still terrible at reading paper pattern pieces, but I'm getting much better reading instructions. The bust gores were the first problem I was faced with. I only cut out 2 instead of 4, and for longer than I'd care to admit I was wandering why you needed 4. But I'm getting ahead of myself a little.
I cut out the right size for my measurements, according to the back, but before actually cutting out anything I reviewed this pattern online, a first for me. A few I saw mentioned the bust gores, and how the bust was always bigger than their chests were. For my size I have quite a small chest and so I cut out the smaller size. The corset remained my measurements. After this project I've definitely learned that either I'm not reading the numbers on my tape measure correctly or pattern sizes are wrong. Reviews also said that the corset they made closed up at the back, adn I know from pictures, etc., that they don't. To solve this minor problem I decided to increase the seam allowances and made them 2cm, so not that big an increase.
Now to the rant about fabric. Corsets are made of stiff material, I just didn't appreciate how stiff. I ordered white cotton coutil; I must admit here I've always wandered what blinds were made of....now I know. This stuff was absolutely solid, and for those of you with experience of it, you can imagine what a problem I had getting a hand sewing needle through it. For the lining I just used white cotton. For the bias binding I wasn't sure, but I knew I wouldn't decorate this one. I was scrolling through the bias binding of my regular suppliers and I found an amazingly cool tartan bias binding. I bought the whole reel that's how much I loved it, and it didn't fail to disappoint.
So for weeks after I managed to cut it out I hand sewed all of the pieces together, drawing on it with pencil, measuring each and every seam to 2 cm. The number of times I put the needle into my skin; I had to put a plaster on my middle finger because every time I pushed the needle through with it the skin scratched off. This has to be the most painful project ever.
There were seven pieces to this corset, all panels, and then the bust gores, of which there were supposed to be four, but were two instead. I'm glad I stuck with two because this corset at the fitting was so so big at the top, gaping at my chest, and that was with the smaller cup size. The alteration would have been a nightmare if I'd had four bust gores in place; at least it would have given me a place to keep valuables, or socks.
A steel busk was inserted at the front, and as you can see from the pictures there is a little gap at the front; I tried my best and thanks to the white shift underneath I don't think it's that bad. Next time I make a corset I'm using a machine. The two back panels had the grommets inserted for the lacing. Unfortunately the suppliers were out of silver, so I got black instead, but it doesn't look as stark as I'd pictured it. I bought too much lacing as well so there's a lot of excess. I laced it properly, which took a while because I got confused from the drawings at one point, but got it sorted. I tied it at the front simply for ease, when I wear it under garments it will be tied properly at the back. The last thing is the waist stay, meant to reinforce the seams since the waist is where most strain is felt. I hated this thing, and I hated "stitch in the ditch", it was really tedious.
I had to shorten this corset because it was just too long, especially sitting down in it. There are spiral steel bones on every seam, and there's four just off the front, which aren't symmetrical as I found out after it was finished. It doesn't give me a shape, and it flattens my chest, unfortunately I don't really know what went wrong with those two things. As you can see from the picture that's as far as it gets tightened, even with me changing the seam allowances. I also had to alter the top as it was gaping out the back and at my chest, as mentioned before.
There are also a few creases and wrinkles that I just couldn't get rid of. Taking all of that into consideration I think it's not bad for a first attempt.
As for the shift underneath, I'm actually proud of how this turned out. My last experience pattern-less was a disaster, but this one was much better. I was too cheap to buy a pattern for an all-in-one drawers-shift from late 19th century, but I wanted a shift rather than the bloomers. The Laughing Moon pattern came with a shift pattern but it was gathered at the chest and I didn't really want that. Instead I got an old t-shirt with the neckline I wanted and I just around it, as pictured below. It looks as though there is a lot of difference between the t-shirt and the end of the cut line, my seam allowance was generous but I wasn't taking any chances with the fabric or the fit. It's made of cotton lawn and is quite sheer, hence why there's no picture of my in just that. It has white bias binding on the neckline and armholes.
My next item is a corset cover, which I bought a pattern for, and a petticoat. I did run into a problem early on in the cover construction in that I didn't have enough cotton lawn left to cut out the two pieces. By my estimation I was only a few inches out, but I wasn't buying a metre just for this when there must be a solution. There was. I placed the pattern on my body and saw where it came down to, my torso is apparently quite short as I had to alter the corset as well. So I adjusted the pattern and they both just fit onto the length I had. I also like the embellishment I have for the corset cover, peephole lace with a lovely mint green ribbon going through; I had to thread it through myself which was, again, tedious.

Rather than making a 1900 skirt I really want a bustle skirt first, so that'll be soon after I finish the petticoat. I also want to make a blouse, but not a loose fitting one like the pattern I have, so that needs a little bit more thought since I can't find a pattern I like that matches what I imagine in my head. I will put the pics when I finish the corset cover. I'm not making a bustle, I'm buying a bustle pillow rather than a cage because I'm not that big a fan of huge bustles, but I'll have to see what my skirt needs because a cushion may not give it the right support. Still not making a cage though, there are nice people who sell them and I assure you they'll be getting my patronage.
Back to topic. The corset I wanted was meant to be late 19th Century, and when I began this it was actualy meant to be 1900, and if you look back at my previous posts about corsets you'll realise why I used a 19th century pattern and not the horrible Edwardian corset pattern. I used Laughing Moon LM100, which covers the years 1837-1900. I didn't know the difference really in corsets in the 19th century. In this packet there are two, one with bust gores and longer, one without. After I cut out the one I thought I wanted and cut out the fabric I realised I may have chosen the wrong one for my timing.
The way I understand it now is that bust gores are very first half of 19th century, and the other pattern was more the one I was looking for. The only reason I chose the bust gore one was because it was slightly longer (despite my having to shorten it at the fitting stage), and since the 1900 skirt pattern I bought was fitted over my massive hips I wanted a little more coverage for my disproportionate shape.
I am still terrible at reading paper pattern pieces, but I'm getting much better reading instructions. The bust gores were the first problem I was faced with. I only cut out 2 instead of 4, and for longer than I'd care to admit I was wandering why you needed 4. But I'm getting ahead of myself a little.
I cut out the right size for my measurements, according to the back, but before actually cutting out anything I reviewed this pattern online, a first for me. A few I saw mentioned the bust gores, and how the bust was always bigger than their chests were. For my size I have quite a small chest and so I cut out the smaller size. The corset remained my measurements. After this project I've definitely learned that either I'm not reading the numbers on my tape measure correctly or pattern sizes are wrong. Reviews also said that the corset they made closed up at the back, adn I know from pictures, etc., that they don't. To solve this minor problem I decided to increase the seam allowances and made them 2cm, so not that big an increase.
So for weeks after I managed to cut it out I hand sewed all of the pieces together, drawing on it with pencil, measuring each and every seam to 2 cm. The number of times I put the needle into my skin; I had to put a plaster on my middle finger because every time I pushed the needle through with it the skin scratched off. This has to be the most painful project ever.
There were seven pieces to this corset, all panels, and then the bust gores, of which there were supposed to be four, but were two instead. I'm glad I stuck with two because this corset at the fitting was so so big at the top, gaping at my chest, and that was with the smaller cup size. The alteration would have been a nightmare if I'd had four bust gores in place; at least it would have given me a place to keep valuables, or socks.
A steel busk was inserted at the front, and as you can see from the pictures there is a little gap at the front; I tried my best and thanks to the white shift underneath I don't think it's that bad. Next time I make a corset I'm using a machine. The two back panels had the grommets inserted for the lacing. Unfortunately the suppliers were out of silver, so I got black instead, but it doesn't look as stark as I'd pictured it. I bought too much lacing as well so there's a lot of excess. I laced it properly, which took a while because I got confused from the drawings at one point, but got it sorted. I tied it at the front simply for ease, when I wear it under garments it will be tied properly at the back. The last thing is the waist stay, meant to reinforce the seams since the waist is where most strain is felt. I hated this thing, and I hated "stitch in the ditch", it was really tedious.
I had to shorten this corset because it was just too long, especially sitting down in it. There are spiral steel bones on every seam, and there's four just off the front, which aren't symmetrical as I found out after it was finished. It doesn't give me a shape, and it flattens my chest, unfortunately I don't really know what went wrong with those two things. As you can see from the picture that's as far as it gets tightened, even with me changing the seam allowances. I also had to alter the top as it was gaping out the back and at my chest, as mentioned before.
There are also a few creases and wrinkles that I just couldn't get rid of. Taking all of that into consideration I think it's not bad for a first attempt.
As for the shift underneath, I'm actually proud of how this turned out. My last experience pattern-less was a disaster, but this one was much better. I was too cheap to buy a pattern for an all-in-one drawers-shift from late 19th century, but I wanted a shift rather than the bloomers. The Laughing Moon pattern came with a shift pattern but it was gathered at the chest and I didn't really want that. Instead I got an old t-shirt with the neckline I wanted and I just around it, as pictured below. It looks as though there is a lot of difference between the t-shirt and the end of the cut line, my seam allowance was generous but I wasn't taking any chances with the fabric or the fit. It's made of cotton lawn and is quite sheer, hence why there's no picture of my in just that. It has white bias binding on the neckline and armholes.
My next item is a corset cover, which I bought a pattern for, and a petticoat. I did run into a problem early on in the cover construction in that I didn't have enough cotton lawn left to cut out the two pieces. By my estimation I was only a few inches out, but I wasn't buying a metre just for this when there must be a solution. There was. I placed the pattern on my body and saw where it came down to, my torso is apparently quite short as I had to alter the corset as well. So I adjusted the pattern and they both just fit onto the length I had. I also like the embellishment I have for the corset cover, peephole lace with a lovely mint green ribbon going through; I had to thread it through myself which was, again, tedious.
Rather than making a 1900 skirt I really want a bustle skirt first, so that'll be soon after I finish the petticoat. I also want to make a blouse, but not a loose fitting one like the pattern I have, so that needs a little bit more thought since I can't find a pattern I like that matches what I imagine in my head. I will put the pics when I finish the corset cover. I'm not making a bustle, I'm buying a bustle pillow rather than a cage because I'm not that big a fan of huge bustles, but I'll have to see what my skirt needs because a cushion may not give it the right support. Still not making a cage though, there are nice people who sell them and I assure you they'll be getting my patronage.
Friday, 16 January 2015
Catching the Outlander bug
Is it really so surprising that I began to watch this series? I've never read the books, and I only intend to read the first for the purposes of minor research; they're actually not really my thing. Time-travel, I've since found out, is a really, really common topic for a novel. I think I've attempted one in the last seven years but that was back when I was younger and ideas were rather short-lived. I personally think the whole "travel back to another time" vein has been a little overplayed; there's only so many different reactions of that happening to a protagonist.
That all being said this TV series did inspire me to write a novel/series of short stories, set in 17th century Scotland rather than Jacobite time. Actually my novella The Lady of Blacktower is set in a pseudo-Scottish land with warring Clanns and the like. I sometimes feel when I get inspired by someone else's story I have to justify why mine is different, even though most of the recommended reading after Outlander are stories of the exact same thing: someone getting stuck in 18th century Scotland and being swept off their feet by fearsome, rugged Scotsman. Worry not, if I do decide to stick with this one over my other two current tales it won't be like that (-ish). Seeing as my current A4 page count on it is about 7 I won't even bother going into details of the story (seeing as I haven't really solidified it yet).

It may surprise you to know this post is actually a brief review of the series. It really is good and I would recommend it. I've actually been putting this drama off, thinking that it was a summer drama and that meant it would be finished by now; it is not. There are 8 episodes currently aired, and we have to wait until April for the rest of season 1! Boooo!
If you've been reading my previous blogposts, and have seen the awful attempt at a blurb I have on Amazon, you'll notice I'm not really the best at summarising tales (strange when I'm really good at writing abstracts for my reports). In short, with no spoilers, is War-nurse Claire Randall travels to Scotland for a second honeymoon with her husband Frank after WWII is over. Once there she is catapulted back to 1743 Scotland, has many, many confrontational run-ins with both English red-coats and Scottish clan members alike, due to either wrong place wrong time, or her sheer willfulness.
Let's have a look at the heroine first; Claire Randall/Beauchamp. The first thing I thought when I read the series was that her surname was Beecham, literally that surname. I didn't know that Beecham was the anglicized version of the much prettier Beauchamp, which after "Witches of East End" I pronounce in French (Bow-shomp). Minor detail. Claire is much funnier in the books, there seems to be no humour in the series for me, or if there is it's minimal. She has a very dry personality, quite cynical, and that makes her dialogue and thoughts just jump right off the page. Unfortunately it's her wilfullness that I find annoying. I have a different definition of "strong" women apparently, because I think being pig-headedly stubborn is irritating and doesn't translate into strength of character. She has a good heart, as all protagonists must, but at times during the series I found myself being annoyed by her.
I really liked her costumes, although the dress she wears in "Wedding" fell so irritatingly short of perfect. It is a stunning gown, seriously, so simple and elegant, but it's too low!! I know in the 18th century they did have their ladies popping out like that, but for me this dress would have been so much better if it hadn't looked as though it was stuck on with removable glue at the top.
Update: after reading the blog of the costume designer I have now learned that there was a top to this dress made of silver material, unfortunately it was damaged when wool cloaks were being taken on and off during filming and so had to be scrapped. Such a shame!
The costume on the left I really liked, the jacket was amazing and looked so cozy and warm. All of the other costumes were suitably similar to one another. I've been researching 17th century highland wear and have learned that everyone, save the very rich, wore quite muted colours, which Claire does throughout.
She is a good character, don't get me wrong, just during the times she's pig-headed I get annoyed. It struck me that Claire spent the entire series, and so far in the book, endeavoring to find her way back to the 20th century, most of the books I've read on this topic just has the protagonist resigned to stay there until fate decided to return them.
Congratulations, Ms Gabaldon, on a well-rounded heroine.
Jamie MacTavish/Fraser. I must admit I don't seem to have become as obsessed with him as I have with other fictional characters. The Outlander fandom love this man; I love the colour of his hair. He is a good character, very saintly and noble, and surprisingly shy. When I was watching the series I couldn't believe that he was a virgin, in the books I didn't believe it either, in reality it would be highly unlikely, especially in that time.
Sam Heughan, on the other hand, I could spread on a cracker. Dear me is this man attractive; and that's how I understand why fans love both novel Jamie, and the TV Jamie. He really brings the character to life and for me it helps that he's Scottish as well.
Dougal and Callum MacKenzie are very good, all the characters are interesting in this.
What I really wanted to speak about was the accents. As a Scottish person, albeit a Glaswegian one, I cringed when I heard some of the accents in this series. Especially poor Lotte Verbeek's. Glaswegians have their own accent, which I speak, and Highlanders have their own too, but I swear that half of the cast just did your typical Highland accent that sounds fake. Lotte Verbeek and Annette Badland were the worst offenders, everyone else sounded genuine. Sam Heughan's was strange as well, so much so I thought he wasn't Scottish! He's from Galloway in Dumfries near the border, and his natural accent is quite a gentle Scottish, but his highland accent was weird.
I also really liked the fact that they filmed in Scotland, some productions based here are rarely filmed here, and I salute the production team for their decision.
A part from the weird, fake accents I really enjoyed this series, it made me sorry I don't know Gaelic. I look forward to seeing this in April when it returns for the second half of the series, and I would recommend anyone into historical dramas to watch it, if you haven't already.
That all being said this TV series did inspire me to write a novel/series of short stories, set in 17th century Scotland rather than Jacobite time. Actually my novella The Lady of Blacktower is set in a pseudo-Scottish land with warring Clanns and the like. I sometimes feel when I get inspired by someone else's story I have to justify why mine is different, even though most of the recommended reading after Outlander are stories of the exact same thing: someone getting stuck in 18th century Scotland and being swept off their feet by fearsome, rugged Scotsman. Worry not, if I do decide to stick with this one over my other two current tales it won't be like that (-ish). Seeing as my current A4 page count on it is about 7 I won't even bother going into details of the story (seeing as I haven't really solidified it yet).

It may surprise you to know this post is actually a brief review of the series. It really is good and I would recommend it. I've actually been putting this drama off, thinking that it was a summer drama and that meant it would be finished by now; it is not. There are 8 episodes currently aired, and we have to wait until April for the rest of season 1! Boooo!
If you've been reading my previous blogposts, and have seen the awful attempt at a blurb I have on Amazon, you'll notice I'm not really the best at summarising tales (strange when I'm really good at writing abstracts for my reports). In short, with no spoilers, is War-nurse Claire Randall travels to Scotland for a second honeymoon with her husband Frank after WWII is over. Once there she is catapulted back to 1743 Scotland, has many, many confrontational run-ins with both English red-coats and Scottish clan members alike, due to either wrong place wrong time, or her sheer willfulness.
Let's have a look at the heroine first; Claire Randall/Beauchamp. The first thing I thought when I read the series was that her surname was Beecham, literally that surname. I didn't know that Beecham was the anglicized version of the much prettier Beauchamp, which after "Witches of East End" I pronounce in French (Bow-shomp). Minor detail. Claire is much funnier in the books, there seems to be no humour in the series for me, or if there is it's minimal. She has a very dry personality, quite cynical, and that makes her dialogue and thoughts just jump right off the page. Unfortunately it's her wilfullness that I find annoying. I have a different definition of "strong" women apparently, because I think being pig-headedly stubborn is irritating and doesn't translate into strength of character. She has a good heart, as all protagonists must, but at times during the series I found myself being annoyed by her.
I really liked her costumes, although the dress she wears in "Wedding" fell so irritatingly short of perfect. It is a stunning gown, seriously, so simple and elegant, but it's too low!! I know in the 18th century they did have their ladies popping out like that, but for me this dress would have been so much better if it hadn't looked as though it was stuck on with removable glue at the top.Update: after reading the blog of the costume designer I have now learned that there was a top to this dress made of silver material, unfortunately it was damaged when wool cloaks were being taken on and off during filming and so had to be scrapped. Such a shame!
The costume on the left I really liked, the jacket was amazing and looked so cozy and warm. All of the other costumes were suitably similar to one another. I've been researching 17th century highland wear and have learned that everyone, save the very rich, wore quite muted colours, which Claire does throughout.
She is a good character, don't get me wrong, just during the times she's pig-headed I get annoyed. It struck me that Claire spent the entire series, and so far in the book, endeavoring to find her way back to the 20th century, most of the books I've read on this topic just has the protagonist resigned to stay there until fate decided to return them.
Congratulations, Ms Gabaldon, on a well-rounded heroine.
Jamie MacTavish/Fraser. I must admit I don't seem to have become as obsessed with him as I have with other fictional characters. The Outlander fandom love this man; I love the colour of his hair. He is a good character, very saintly and noble, and surprisingly shy. When I was watching the series I couldn't believe that he was a virgin, in the books I didn't believe it either, in reality it would be highly unlikely, especially in that time.Sam Heughan, on the other hand, I could spread on a cracker. Dear me is this man attractive; and that's how I understand why fans love both novel Jamie, and the TV Jamie. He really brings the character to life and for me it helps that he's Scottish as well.
Dougal and Callum MacKenzie are very good, all the characters are interesting in this.
What I really wanted to speak about was the accents. As a Scottish person, albeit a Glaswegian one, I cringed when I heard some of the accents in this series. Especially poor Lotte Verbeek's. Glaswegians have their own accent, which I speak, and Highlanders have their own too, but I swear that half of the cast just did your typical Highland accent that sounds fake. Lotte Verbeek and Annette Badland were the worst offenders, everyone else sounded genuine. Sam Heughan's was strange as well, so much so I thought he wasn't Scottish! He's from Galloway in Dumfries near the border, and his natural accent is quite a gentle Scottish, but his highland accent was weird.
I also really liked the fact that they filmed in Scotland, some productions based here are rarely filmed here, and I salute the production team for their decision.
A part from the weird, fake accents I really enjoyed this series, it made me sorry I don't know Gaelic. I look forward to seeing this in April when it returns for the second half of the series, and I would recommend anyone into historical dramas to watch it, if you haven't already.
Monday, 17 November 2014
Morality: can protagonists ever be morally corrupt?
This is something I've been thinking about recently especially as I'm starting a new historical novel and nearly finished my previous fantasy one based on Waterhouse's "The Tempest" painting. I have written many, many characters over the years and all seem to have at least one thread going through them; they're all morally upright. I used to think this was because I also have very strong morals which I blame entirely on Japanese anime and subsequently South Korean dramas (if you don't know what I mean just go and watch one of them and you'll see all protagonists are near saintly), but more recently I began to think that it's just the nature of the beast. Your protagonist pushes your story forward and they're the ones that keep your reader abreast of the tale but if they're unlikeable then the reader won't continue. Are heroes/heroines dislikeable if they have no morals? Is having no morals the same as being a "bad" character/person? I am now going to delve into this topic based on sources of books I've read, which doesn't really seem that much but there's a reason. I am now solely into historical mystery/crime and the characters don't really push the story forward so much as the plot's twists and turns do.
The first example that came to mind when I was brainstorming this post was Game of Thrones. With such a vast array of characters it's hard to exclude these pieces of work from any literary discussion. I have read all five of the installments of a Song of Ice and Fire and at the time when the Tv series had just started I was obsessed. What typically happens with an obsession? It dies down and now I'm sick of hearing and looking at them, to the extent I stopped watching the TV series and don't know if I'm going to continue reading. What I don't understand now that I've had time to look objectively is why they're so popular. They're so so depressing! I am a girl who likes happy endings, I like when I have hope during a story that things are going to get better, that good things as well as bad are going to happen to any character. With Martin's works it was always the bad thing that was going to happen to each and every character he wrote about, this happened to the extent where a bit of the stories actually became predictable for me; think of the thing you don't want to happen to Arya, it happens. Towards book 4 and 5 I was beginning to question the point in reading them, nothing was ever going right, and that is exactly the biggest flaw with this series. It's too pessimistic and cynical to be convincing. I know that everyone praises the humanity of the characters, and I will give Martin that, they are quite complex to a certain extent, but his story is just too doom and gloom to have that authentic, real feel to them. Yes, I know it's fantasy, but I like my fantasy to be believable, a mirror of some sort of the real world. Bad things do not incessantly happen to normal people, life is balanced, of which there is none in here.But I didn't come here to talk about the plot, I came to mention a few characters. I read these books at least two years ago now, probably nearing three, so I've forgotten a lot of things but here are what stuck out. Tyrion is my favourite character and by far the most misunderstood by other characters in the novels; my opinion of Tyrion was that he was morally upright and wanted to do the right and honourable thing, he had a soft spot for outcasts understandably. Therefore isn't Tyrion classed as a 'good' character? Cersei, Tyrion's sister, is vicious, vindictive and let's face it a complete bitch, apparently she cares for her children but the only evidence of that was her threatening Tyrion because he sent one of them away. Do these traits make her a 'bad' character; an evil queen type?
There are others who follow this same line, Jon Snow wants to do the right thing and is honourable, Danerys Targaryen is reaching for sainthood and even Jaime Lannister starts to become an honourable character when his POV is introduced. Aren't there clear cut lines here between who's a 'good' character and who's a 'bad' one? Delving deeper, Tyrion kills his father, but his father is Tywin Lannister, another 'bad' character. Readers feel less inclined to hate him because of who is father was, some would even say he deserved it. Unfortunately Jon Snow, Danaerys and Jaime have no such moral blunders the entire way through the books and all seem to do the right thing all of the time.
I give an honourable mention to Joffrey Baratheon/Lannister for being a typical, and unrealistic, villain. Martin didn't even try to put some humanity in that boy, and guess what, everyone hated Joffrey.
Moving onto more familiar and less complex ground. Mistresses are looked down upon by women today, being the 'other woman' is something to be ashamed of. There have been recent assaults of mistresses in China by the spouses of the cheating husbands, it has always been a position of scorn and judgment. Novel readers, especially historical (romantic) fiction is predominately women, which means you have to aim at your reader. One of the most popular books of the 20th Century was about a mistress! I've mentioned this novel before, Anya Seton's "Katherine" was published in 1954 and has maintained popularity ever since (which is why they should make it into a TV series) and is about John of Gaunt's long-time mistress and eventual third wife, Katherine de Roet-Swynford. Click here to read my History Sunday segment about John of Gaunt and Katherine. Why is a novel about a mistress so popular?
When I read Katherine I found the heroine morally upright, religiously so, because she was pious. She had a conscience and was somewhat reluctant, for evident reasons, to become his mistress at first. Throughout the novel she continues to display kindness, compassion and every trait that most people want for themselves. Is this what makes her so likeable, or is it the historical setting which takes the heat away from the mistress position?
In Anne O'Brien's novel about Katherine she was also pious and a little reluctant to become Gaunt's mistress but the reasons were purely selfish this time. I never finished this novel but I never truly hated this version of Katherine (I didn't really like her much but it wasn't because she lacked morals).
Another maligned mistress, Alice Perrers, has been the focus of some newer novels, only one of which I tried to read. In Seton's novel she's portrayed as the shunned mistress of the king, a foreboding warning to the young katherine what's at stake when a woman gives up her reputation for a man, in Harper's novel about Joan of Kent she's horrible and ugly if I remember correctly and everyone hates her. Finally, in O'brien's novel about her she's sort of bland but still seems to have a conscience, a far way away from how she's portrayed in every novel that isn't about her. In the novels with her as a secondary character she's selfish, greedy, everything history reports her to be, whilst in novels about her she has some semblance of a conscience. Coincidence?
Finally I'll move onto a character from the world of TV. Dexter is a brilliant show and I honestly can't pin down the reason. The protagonist is a serial killer and he gets away with it! But most people who watch the show love Dexter because to a degree he is as cute as a button.
The more I think about it the more I think its linked to humanity. What I mean by this is that whenever we watch movies about non-human characters, Edward Scissor hands, Frankenstein, we all feel sorry for the bad things that happen to them because they display human characteristics even though they're not human. They're learning to be human and are at times so innocent and genuinely good that when misfortune comes their way our hearts crack a little. Dexter is in a very similar band. He's human but not quite, a large chunk of what makes us all human is dormant and slowly awakens through the series. I also think Dexter is very popular because he makes the audience laugh. I first came across this tactic when I went to see Richard II at the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford. He was a funny king, a little sardonic but still made me laugh, and I ended up feeling sorry for him by the end of the play. But Dexter, by definition, is not a 'good' character, he's also not a bad one either. Voila, a human protagonist. It's a shame that a hero needs to be a serial killer to be human. By killing people constantly he is what the world defines as a bad character, watch any murder/police drama and the bad guy kills people; but Dexter loves his family and will do anything, killing included, to protect and seek revenge for them.
It's a bit of a steep decision to make, though, for a writer, and a dangerous one. I personally always try and avoid my characters killing anyone because I think it may make them seem a little less sympathetic. Can a person truly be a killer and a 'good' person. Going along those same lines, Taryn Connagh in my novel "Poison Most Royal" is a hitwoman/assassin. I didn't think twice about her occupation because I've always wanted to write about a woman who kills people for a living, but Taryn has her reasons for doing so and questions her own morality throughout the novel. I don't know if Taryn is likeable, it's hard to gain some perspective
when you're reading your own creation, but Taryn has morals, as all my characters seem to.
Returning to the question of this post. Can a protagonist ever be morally corrupt? Even Dexter has a set of rules he sticks to. It is almost impossible for anyone to answer this question because no one in the world has read all the books in existence. Making characters moral does increase the likelihood that the reader will like them, but simultaneously if you write a bad character they'll be immediately disliked anyway. I've never read a book where the main characters don't have good morals and don't make good decisions. I dislike reading posts and blogs about "how to write a good character" or "how to write ....... well". There is no one set guide to writing! If that were the case then every book published and written would be nothing more than a creative journal article. There is a difference between science and art, there always has been. Writing these guides on how to write is going against the very fabric of creative writing; the clue is in the title, creative! There is no one way to write a novel, novella, short story, poem, or any of these things; it's not statistics, believe me, I know. Scientific researchers, like myself, have guides to writing journal articles and reports, most, if not all, of our research write ups have to follow the same structure, but that's science, we like things that have a format. Art isn't supposed to be like that.
I also love the deviation from statistics reports because at least with this research question I don't have to answer it. There is no answer to my question. Do characters have to be morally upstanding? Personally I think they have to have some semblance of good sense, but above all they should, if possible, make good decisions. There are books and novels where the main character makes a bad decision and it haunts them for the rest of their lives. Characters aren't real people, they shouldn't have to conform to an exact human nature. That being said they shouldn't be unbelievable as human beings. Characters can reflect the best of human natures and the worst, but they shouldn't be saintly or villainous. It's easy to make a character a saint that does no wrong and also, say, to make a villain with no good bone in their body, but neither are realistic. If they do something bad they should have a reason for it, if they're morally upstanding there has to be a foundation for that behaviour. Reason is what makes a character, their history, the things you don't write about, that's what makes them who they are; the nameless relatives also have a good say in that as well. I don't know if my characters are very human, no one has reviewed my novel to tell me otherwise, but the above process is what I go through every time I think of a character, every time I sit down and begin typing their reaction to a scenario or something that has happened to them.
What are your views on characters? Do you think a hero/heroine can be morally corrupt and still be liked by the readers? Who is the most human character you have ever read?
Friday, 31 October 2014
Review: Reign, Season 1
It might not be surprising to most that I chose to watch this drama about Scotland's most famous Queen, but in order to do so I had to let go of one of my principles. It took me a year or self-refusal to finally watch this drama by CW. I've mentioned before on this blog that I don't write historical
fiction because that particular group of fans are so harsh and at times very critical, but I will now confess my sin; I am kind of the same when it comes to costume dramas. I'm not an expert, or a historian, but a self-taught fashion history enthusiast. That being said I am not extreme, I do not really know that much about what materials were available when, but I do know style, shape and rough fashion changes from the eleventh century onward.
This is why Reign really, really annoyed me when I saw episode stills.
They did not have 21st Century designers in 16th Century France, they did not have silly little wire crowns and other headpieces, in fact they were still covering their hair! So many things about the costumes in this drama annoyed me and that was before I began to watch it. I was aware before I started that not only were the costumes inaccurate, but the plot was too; no surprise there then, there hasn't been a truly accurate historical drama in decades, perhaps ever, because history is relatively slow and sometimes uneventful and doesn't make for good watching material. That being said, once I began to watch it I started feeling that self-loathing that many people do when they watch a drama like this.
First of all let's start with plot so I don't seem like a crazy, ignorant judgmental person. It has your typical twists and turns, court intrigues, assassination plots and of course the poor sod who has visions of a dark and gloomy future. I know Nostradamus was never associated with France in this way, nor did he play as big a part at court, but I love him, or rather the way the actor played him. I won't put any spoilers in this review because that would be bad for anyone who hasn't watched it. The drama is good, typical teen-angst filled drama with too much kissing and too-perfect men. I didn't really like Mary's relationship with either Francis or Bash, there just didn't seem any spark in either of them. I loved Catherine de Medici and I have a grudging respect for Mary. I liked that Mary wasn't a naive sap that things just kept happening to; there are bad things happening to her because there has to be for character growth but I liked how she dished some back. I would recommend this if you've ran out of dramas to watch.
Now, my biggest pet peeve. Fashion! The picture on the right, folks, was as close to historically accurate the show ever got. Her hair isn't covered but at least she has the semblance of a French Hood on and slightly period correct clothing.
I think a part of the reason people watch historical dramas is because of the costumes. The costume department of Reign really let the audience down. It felt to me as though they just bought loads of dresses from designers as a form of product placement rather than designing anything themselves, which is a shame because there is so much opportunity in situations like these.
The men's costumes looked pretty accurate most of the time but I to admit to having a huge gap in my knowledge about men's fashion at any time in history. It was weird that the men looked as though they were from the 16th Century but the women's clothing definitely wasn't; the whole thing seemed disjointed and really weird.
Another thing that irked me was that Mary, Queen of Scots, did not look even the slightest bit like the real Queen.
Mary Stewart, Queen of Scotland had red hair, couldn't they have at least gotten the actress to wear a wig, or die her hair a dark shade of auburn? Adelaide Kane is gorgeous, and she would be a perfect actress to play one of my unpublished characters if it was ever made into a movie (I think about these things, I can't help it) and she is a good actress, save from the romance scenes, there was just no chemistry for me; but I was disappointed she didn't look more authentic.
I am not the Queen's biggest fan, in fact I think she was incompetent and aimed her ambition in the wrong direction rather than actually successfully ruling Scotland. Her marriage choices were never popular and she was so disliked by the nobility she fled to England. I don't know if beheading her was a wise decision, whoever's decision it really was, but she hadn't done any good for Scotland and was forced to abdicate! I hate how Elizabeth I is so maligned in popular history because she beheaded Mary, Elizabeth was badass, she was competent and launched England into an era of stabiliy and plenty. What did Mary Stuart do? She married the wrong people, plunged Scotland into chaos and when things got tough she fled the country. If the real Mary was as smart and as quick to adapt as her fictional counterpart, Scotland wouldn't have had a problem and she probably would have been famous for the right reason.
Rant over, I promise. Back to the show; I will admit the costumes were nice, I was just disappointed they weren't accurate.
Mary's headpieces were lovely and I even thought about making my own version of one of them just for fun. But again, they were no French Hoods. I am aware that historical dramas these days don't have women covering their hair; The Tudors and The White Queen failed to give the females the correct period headdress, but I will give a nod to the costume designer of the movie "The Other Boleyn girl," for having not only French Hoods, but Gable Hoods as well!
One of the most irritating costumes that I could not forgive was Mary's riding dress, which I can't find a picture of. It's when the Portuguese villain proposes to her. What really irritated me was that it wasn't even of full length! At least all of the dresses were floor length (well the ones they wore outside of their chambers anyway).
I loved Catherine de Medici, she was just so awesome. I liked the fact she wasn't a Disney villain type character and although her reasons for doing harm were kind of pathetic I liked that she had heart as well. She wasn't completely void of compassion or kindness but her protective mother streak was a bit extreme, as they always have to be with plots like this. Although her costumes weren't historically accurate as well I found I was much more forgiving with her because she was so awesome.
So onto the other ladies of the show. I think my favourite was Lola because her teen drama thing was over relatively quickly (*ahem* Colin), and she was by far the smartest and most down to earth. My second was Greer who I respected throughout and genuinely felt for. Poor Kenna, I just didn't warm to her, I didn't really understand why her character acted the way she did but I do firmly love the person she ended up with.
The men of the show. King Henry II of France was.....alluring. He had such charisma that it was fascinating to watch until they ruined it. Bash is by far the finest one on the show, unfortunately his character was a bit bland for me, but at least he's pretty. And Francis, poor, poor Francis. I don't know why but I'm kind of sick of this "perfect king" thing that shows about royalty have. I say that but the only other show I can think of with an arthurian type king is, ironically, Camelot. I find I'm fed up of 100% honourable characters, I like them to have flaws, to not be so moral all the time. Francis always put France first, and I suppose you could say that was a flaw, but it was a very short lived only in about two episodes. Still, Francis always did the right thing, was always opposed to the shady plan concocted by everyone around him; the shadiest thing he did wasn't even that bad (he got someone pregnant but only when he was technically single so not adultery).
The last thing I will say is an honourable mention to Marie de Guise. I don't know much about her but from what I do know she held Scotland up after the death of her husband and the departure of her daughter to France, yet the woman has been maligned twice in dramas about this period (The Tudors and Reign). I've never heard horrible stories about her but no doubt there are some, but I think I'm joining the club "let's be fair to Marie de Guise".
Overall it is a good show, definitely a guilty pleasure like the Vampire Diaries was for me, but I had no problem getting through all 22 episodes which I count as a good drama. Season 2 is currently airing but I wait until all of the episodes are aired before watching any drama because I lose track of what episode and what drama I'm on; easier to just marathon them in the summer when I have nothing better to do.
Currently I am watching New Girl with Zooey Deschanel and crew. This is an amazing drama and I regret never watching it before!! I think I have a girl crush on Jess, she's so awesome and I wish I could be more outwardly like her rather than trying to contain the quirkiness.
Any other opinions on Reign? Am I being too obsessed with the costumes? If you think I'm bad you should see the post that zoomed in on a zip on one of the costumes from the White Queen. It's just a costume, why can't it be made with the ease of the 21st Century, just so long as it looks authentic?
Wren's recommendation: Worth a watch.
fiction because that particular group of fans are so harsh and at times very critical, but I will now confess my sin; I am kind of the same when it comes to costume dramas. I'm not an expert, or a historian, but a self-taught fashion history enthusiast. That being said I am not extreme, I do not really know that much about what materials were available when, but I do know style, shape and rough fashion changes from the eleventh century onward.
This is why Reign really, really annoyed me when I saw episode stills.
They did not have 21st Century designers in 16th Century France, they did not have silly little wire crowns and other headpieces, in fact they were still covering their hair! So many things about the costumes in this drama annoyed me and that was before I began to watch it. I was aware before I started that not only were the costumes inaccurate, but the plot was too; no surprise there then, there hasn't been a truly accurate historical drama in decades, perhaps ever, because history is relatively slow and sometimes uneventful and doesn't make for good watching material. That being said, once I began to watch it I started feeling that self-loathing that many people do when they watch a drama like this.
First of all let's start with plot so I don't seem like a crazy, ignorant judgmental person. It has your typical twists and turns, court intrigues, assassination plots and of course the poor sod who has visions of a dark and gloomy future. I know Nostradamus was never associated with France in this way, nor did he play as big a part at court, but I love him, or rather the way the actor played him. I won't put any spoilers in this review because that would be bad for anyone who hasn't watched it. The drama is good, typical teen-angst filled drama with too much kissing and too-perfect men. I didn't really like Mary's relationship with either Francis or Bash, there just didn't seem any spark in either of them. I loved Catherine de Medici and I have a grudging respect for Mary. I liked that Mary wasn't a naive sap that things just kept happening to; there are bad things happening to her because there has to be for character growth but I liked how she dished some back. I would recommend this if you've ran out of dramas to watch.
Now, my biggest pet peeve. Fashion! The picture on the right, folks, was as close to historically accurate the show ever got. Her hair isn't covered but at least she has the semblance of a French Hood on and slightly period correct clothing.I think a part of the reason people watch historical dramas is because of the costumes. The costume department of Reign really let the audience down. It felt to me as though they just bought loads of dresses from designers as a form of product placement rather than designing anything themselves, which is a shame because there is so much opportunity in situations like these.
The men's costumes looked pretty accurate most of the time but I to admit to having a huge gap in my knowledge about men's fashion at any time in history. It was weird that the men looked as though they were from the 16th Century but the women's clothing definitely wasn't; the whole thing seemed disjointed and really weird.
Another thing that irked me was that Mary, Queen of Scots, did not look even the slightest bit like the real Queen.
Mary Stewart, Queen of Scotland had red hair, couldn't they have at least gotten the actress to wear a wig, or die her hair a dark shade of auburn? Adelaide Kane is gorgeous, and she would be a perfect actress to play one of my unpublished characters if it was ever made into a movie (I think about these things, I can't help it) and she is a good actress, save from the romance scenes, there was just no chemistry for me; but I was disappointed she didn't look more authentic.
I am not the Queen's biggest fan, in fact I think she was incompetent and aimed her ambition in the wrong direction rather than actually successfully ruling Scotland. Her marriage choices were never popular and she was so disliked by the nobility she fled to England. I don't know if beheading her was a wise decision, whoever's decision it really was, but she hadn't done any good for Scotland and was forced to abdicate! I hate how Elizabeth I is so maligned in popular history because she beheaded Mary, Elizabeth was badass, she was competent and launched England into an era of stabiliy and plenty. What did Mary Stuart do? She married the wrong people, plunged Scotland into chaos and when things got tough she fled the country. If the real Mary was as smart and as quick to adapt as her fictional counterpart, Scotland wouldn't have had a problem and she probably would have been famous for the right reason.
Rant over, I promise. Back to the show; I will admit the costumes were nice, I was just disappointed they weren't accurate.
Mary's headpieces were lovely and I even thought about making my own version of one of them just for fun. But again, they were no French Hoods. I am aware that historical dramas these days don't have women covering their hair; The Tudors and The White Queen failed to give the females the correct period headdress, but I will give a nod to the costume designer of the movie "The Other Boleyn girl," for having not only French Hoods, but Gable Hoods as well!
One of the most irritating costumes that I could not forgive was Mary's riding dress, which I can't find a picture of. It's when the Portuguese villain proposes to her. What really irritated me was that it wasn't even of full length! At least all of the dresses were floor length (well the ones they wore outside of their chambers anyway).
I loved Catherine de Medici, she was just so awesome. I liked the fact she wasn't a Disney villain type character and although her reasons for doing harm were kind of pathetic I liked that she had heart as well. She wasn't completely void of compassion or kindness but her protective mother streak was a bit extreme, as they always have to be with plots like this. Although her costumes weren't historically accurate as well I found I was much more forgiving with her because she was so awesome.
So onto the other ladies of the show. I think my favourite was Lola because her teen drama thing was over relatively quickly (*ahem* Colin), and she was by far the smartest and most down to earth. My second was Greer who I respected throughout and genuinely felt for. Poor Kenna, I just didn't warm to her, I didn't really understand why her character acted the way she did but I do firmly love the person she ended up with.The men of the show. King Henry II of France was.....alluring. He had such charisma that it was fascinating to watch until they ruined it. Bash is by far the finest one on the show, unfortunately his character was a bit bland for me, but at least he's pretty. And Francis, poor, poor Francis. I don't know why but I'm kind of sick of this "perfect king" thing that shows about royalty have. I say that but the only other show I can think of with an arthurian type king is, ironically, Camelot. I find I'm fed up of 100% honourable characters, I like them to have flaws, to not be so moral all the time. Francis always put France first, and I suppose you could say that was a flaw, but it was a very short lived only in about two episodes. Still, Francis always did the right thing, was always opposed to the shady plan concocted by everyone around him; the shadiest thing he did wasn't even that bad (he got someone pregnant but only when he was technically single so not adultery).
The last thing I will say is an honourable mention to Marie de Guise. I don't know much about her but from what I do know she held Scotland up after the death of her husband and the departure of her daughter to France, yet the woman has been maligned twice in dramas about this period (The Tudors and Reign). I've never heard horrible stories about her but no doubt there are some, but I think I'm joining the club "let's be fair to Marie de Guise".
Overall it is a good show, definitely a guilty pleasure like the Vampire Diaries was for me, but I had no problem getting through all 22 episodes which I count as a good drama. Season 2 is currently airing but I wait until all of the episodes are aired before watching any drama because I lose track of what episode and what drama I'm on; easier to just marathon them in the summer when I have nothing better to do.
Currently I am watching New Girl with Zooey Deschanel and crew. This is an amazing drama and I regret never watching it before!! I think I have a girl crush on Jess, she's so awesome and I wish I could be more outwardly like her rather than trying to contain the quirkiness.
Any other opinions on Reign? Am I being too obsessed with the costumes? If you think I'm bad you should see the post that zoomed in on a zip on one of the costumes from the White Queen. It's just a costume, why can't it be made with the ease of the 21st Century, just so long as it looks authentic?
Wren's recommendation: Worth a watch.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)























